Shelter Island New Homes

New homes for sale in and around Shelter Island, NY

We're sorry

Unfortunately we could not find new homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY.

Please enter a nearby City, ST or ZIP:

Shelter Island Home Insurance

Please select: Renter Home Owner

Shelter Island Conditions

(updated 53 min ago)

Clear 68°F
Feels like: 68°F
Visibility: 10 mi

See Tomorrow's Forecast »

Shelter Island Info

Shelter Island, New York is located in Suffolk County. Zip codes in Shelter Island, NY include 11964. The median home price in Shelter Island is $1,099,000 which is roughly $481/per square foot. More Shelter Island information.

Local Charities in Shelter Island, NY