No just marriage now back to your "life partner".<quoted text>
And I was mounting a criticism of the argument that you were using on the subject of marriage. You should only use an argument of you agree with ALL of its implications otherwise it can be used against you when you disagree with it and you end up looking like a hypocritical douchbag for mounting the argument in the first place.
Your argument goes like this:
1. Action a is traditional
2. Any action which is traditional is acceptable
3. Ergo action a is acceptable
Your argument ONLY WORKS if you accept premise 3, otherwise it's a non-sequiter. Do you agree that anything that is traditional is acceptable? Or if something you thought was morally reprehensible was traditional would you not be convinced by your own argument?
Civil Unions Debate - New Lenox, IL
Discuss the national Civil Unions debate in New Lenox, IL.
Are Civil Unions Enough?
New Lenox thinks marriage is between a man and a woman
|Marriage is bet...||
|No, gay marriag...||
|Yes, that's plenty||
21 - 23 of 23 Comments Last updated -
29 Users are viewing the New Lenox Forum right now
|IL Ill. House Approves Legalizing Same-Sex Civil U... (Dec '10)||16 min||truth||48,865|
|Travel Baseball||1 hr||Scotty beam||12|
|Looping Big Money around democracy's neck||1 hr||EJCDad||10|
|Lifting America up by raising the wage floor||2 hr||Professor||23|
|Across RT 30 from Target||2 hr||Former Resident||14|
|IL Who do you support for Governor in Illinois in ... (Oct '10)||4 hr||nuguyntwn||3,827|
|old american pride gas station info||4 hr||Concerned Citizen||4|
Copyright © 2014 Topix LLC