Should foreigners be conscripted into the Singapore army

Posted in the Singapore Forum


Showing posts 1 - 2 of2
Alvin Gonzalez

Singapore, Singapore

Report Abuse
Judge it!
Mar 4, 2012
Jan 18, 2006
Let those who intend to emigrate opt out of NS

I REFER to the Insight article,‘Doers & dodgers: Time to heal the rift?’(ST, Jan 14).

I share the same sentiment as Mr Paul Wong, feeling no allegiance to Singapore and not being able to assimilate into Singaporean culture even though I was born and raised here.

As a child, I grew up watching classic American movies and cartoons, and listening to American-genre music like country, southern gospel and classic American oldies.

My paternal aunts and uncles are Ivy League students and speak with a slight American accent and use American grammar in speech. I was influenced by them.

Because I am the child of a Thai father and a Singaporean mother, I am a citizen of both Thailand and Singapore. I hold a Singapore passport and will have to serve national service next year.

I do not intend to live in Singapore and, in fact, have made serious plans to emigrate to the United States in future.

Many friends of mine who have gone overseas to study intend to settle down in their host country after serving national service.

I do not support the evasion of national service but I appeal to the Government to make some changes to the policy.

For those who do not intend to live in Singapore, there is no purpose in serving national service. It is a waste of resources for the Government and a waste of time for those affected.

In my case, I will renounce my Singapore citizenship at age 21 and take on Thai citizenship. The US will be my home in future and if a war breaks out between Singapore and the US, God forbid, obviously I would help to defend the US and fight Singapore if need be.

Therefore, I do not see the purpose of training men who might ‘turn against’ their country in unforeseen circumstances.

Perhaps the Ministry of Defence could come up with a policy to permit those who intend to emigrate to opt out of national service but if they do not leave by a certain age, then they would be drafted.

Patriotism and loyalty cannot be forced. It is ultimately up to an individual whether he wants to serve the country.

Pavin Limanont

straits times forum

Winchester, UK

Report Abuse
Judge it!
Apr 5, 2013
You are correct singapore needs a professional army not 3rd rate forced labour

Tell me when this thread is updated: (Registration is not required)

Add to my Tracker Send me an email

Showing posts 1 - 2 of2
Type in your comments below
(appears on your post)
Characters left: 4000

Please note by clicking on "Post Comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

21 Users are viewing the Singapore Forum right now

Search the Singapore Forum:
Topic Updated Last By Comments - Singapore No.1 Membership based ... 10 min Jobsnapp 1
Is there an increase in crime in Singapore? 17 hr willy wong 6
Commonwealth Towers Showflat - 9652 6095 for sh... Wed ming 12
Ferry tragedy - Taiwan TV hosts ridiculed South... Wed Just not right 1
Why are Tamils so violent? Are they savages? Wed xxx 4
Spanking in Singapore (Apr '11) Wed thighspank 905
bohsia sg (May '10) Tue sex king 38