what was the purpose of creating pakistan?

[ruthless]

everyone is invited to express their views on the pupose of creation of pakistan.no abuses please.

[ruthless]

no answers? even pakistani citizens are confused.

[debasis behera]

dear ruth less,
there are three contradicting vesions of creation of pakistan. i am discussing them in short
1. one theroy (most pakistanis say so)is that it was created to save muslims from hindu domination.
2. another theory is that pakistan was created as an artifical state to satisfy the hunger for power of jinnah and his loyal supporters. on the other words it was meant to serve some handful of people.
3. another versions says that it was product of PQP PLAN- post quit plan of MI-5 to have a permanent base of the orgisation which can be used to counter the communists. some also say that it has direct link with disappearence with netaji subas chandra bose.

[HinduCrusades]

Islam.

Areas with Muslim majority areas usually wish to secede for under their theology,they can discharge duties better when they are wholly Islamic.

The Soviet Union when it disintegrated saw thet much of the Muslim areas were kept out of the Russian federation.

Even small areas like Yugaslaia where he Serbs Croats and Muslims share a language and cultural similarities there is a strong pull of Islamic population to secede.

It is again happening Kashmir.

Islam has a strong political message which others should not ignore for it is directed against non Muslims.

Joginder Nath Mandal was a member of the constituent assembly of Pakistan and its first Justice Minister.

He resigned within a year and a half protesting against the 'Islamisation' which started under Liaqat Ali Khan.

FACTS.HARD COLD FACTS.GOOGLE IT.

[HinduCrusades]

Jaganath Azad, a Hindu wrote the first national anthem of Pakistan.

Jinnah specifically asked him to write an anthem for Pakistan and he did it upon his request.

It was later discarded for a hightly Persianised Urdu.

The cultural pull of Islam-Arabic Persian Shariah laws...ga ga ga ga...

[HinduCrusades]

Dhirendra Nath Dutta, a Bengali Hindu put forth a legitimate demand.Status for Bengali on par with Urdu...it was not conceded.

A thousand ond one events will turn up in a highly flawed history and thinking that went into creating Pakistan and bringing misery to millions and killing a million more.

It needs a lots of research and patience.

62 years on,the still terrorize us and we are not able to hit back effectively.

[Nitin]

ruthless wrote:

everyone is invited to express their views on the pupose of creation of pakistan.no abuses please.

It was a base step which was taken to make India progressive and develop,
its said .
one awful fish pollutes the whole pond , and those awful fishes were to be separated.
And I am happy to see India's influence on the global stage today

[HinduCrusades]

Nitin wrote:

<quoted text>It was a base step which was taken to make India progressive and develop,
its said .
one awful fish pollutes the whole pond , and those awful fishes were to be separated.
And I am happy to see India's influence on the global stage today

Yes you are 100% right.

Hindu and Muslim ethos are fundamentally different and though the sub continents Muslims have a basic cultural affinity with the Hindus what their religion still calls the shots.

Hindu-secular out look draws us to things like central planning,democracy,literacy and need to develop a just and fair society:all these concepts have roots in Europe and barristers like Nehru who studied in Europe easily imbibed these political/economic axioms and put them to practice.

What happened in Pakistan was a natural corollary to state which was more than three quarters Muslim-it drew more and more upon"Islamic values' and it's attendant medieveal barabarity and gradually regressed,with none of the state institutions surviving as it did it in India.

Both the countries drew from the Anglo Saxon law and government,but both followed different political trajectories.

[HinduCrusades]

Providence played dice.Partition happened.What would have become a gangrenous part of the country was ampuatated and the rest of India grew healthy.

A regressive,backward looking population,feudal landlords,unworkable religion based politics has driven Pakistan to where it is today.

[HinduCrusades]

'Secular,Socialist Republic of India'

earlier 'Sovreign Democratic Republic of India

Vs

'Islamic Republic of Pakistan"

Whole tomes can be written about this fundamental differences in political axioms and body politic.

[ruthless]

but the majority of muslims are still in india, so how can the partition be regarded as on communal basis.

[Khan from Islamabad]

Purpose of creating Pakistan was f*cking India and Pakistan has unfasten your ass every time thats better response of stupid question.

[Khan from Islamabad]

Pakistan and Indian Muslims will claim whole India again.It will be called "grater Pakistan"

[george w]

it was to give the intolerant indian muslims a land of their own so they would not give people trouble.however being the violent,inbred,intolerant,vile ,wicked scum that the muslims are they turned it into a terrorist haven and created,funded,taught,trained and harboured every militant organisation under the sun.NUKE the sh ithole and be done with these pondlife scum.

[ruthless]

Khan from Islamabad wrote:

Pakistan and Indian Muslims will claim whole India again.It will be called "grater Pakistan"

rather india should take back its punjab region as partition was incompelete.

[rahul07712]

jinnah ambition was the reason for creation of the Pakistan ,
Jennag knew that if he is to be remain in power then he has to create a new nation for Muslim ,otherwise In india Nehru will be in power ,
His desire to get the power is the reason,
His politics got failed so he thought if wants to be in power , he has to play game of religion differences and that is what he did ,
It is easy to divide people on the basis of their religion & that was done by Jinnah,
He had not loved the Muslim , he had loved the power

[Nitin]

rahul07712 wrote:

jinnah ambition was the reason for creation of the Pakistan ,
Jennag knew that if he is to be remain in power then he has to create a new nation for Muslim ,otherwise In india Nehru will be in power ,
His desire to get the power is the reason,
His politics got failed so he thought if wants to be in power , he has to play game of religion differences and that is what he did ,
It is easy to divide people on the basis of their religion & that was done by Jinnah,
He had not loved the Muslim , he had loved the power

what ever happen to pakistan is good in other way. Khalistani's now look at pakistan and they get a lesson.....than ..yes..this is what happen if we seperate....

[HInduCrusades]

The best thing that happened to India is Partition.

They can have Allah( the kind which kills mercilessly),the can be a merceanaries of the US( while abusing it all the while),they can steal nuclear tech( while denying a Nobel prize winning Abdus Salam any official recognition for being an 'heretic'),open madrasas (overseas Pakistanis are involved in terror bombing) break up their own country.

To make themselves feel good send terrorists into India and mouth everything bad about it.

[HInduCrusades]

Khan from Islamabad wrote:

Purpose of creating Pakistan was f*cking India and Pakistan has unfasten your ass every time thats better response of stupid question.

You are ABSOLUTELY RIGHT.

You are demons who are out to destroy not just your country,but entire south asia and rest of the world.

Good you acknowledged it!

[HInduCrusades]

Khan from Islamabad wrote:

Pakistan and Indian Muslims will claim whole India again.It will be called "grater Pakistan"

Actually a "Lesser Pakistan" is in making

Give Baluchs and Sindhis their due and learn to give and take within your own country!

You wanted to TAKE and lost East Pakistan.

You wanted to TAKE Kashmir and lost your country to terrorists.

You want to TAKE India and you will lose everything!

Learn to GIVE too?