what mcneill did was inhuumane

[hayley]

this man is absolutely disgusting. i am researching this case for my leagal studies class. he should just admit he is a murderer, a demented one at that!!! who just goes around murdering people they don't know on such a friendly little island. i was at nnorfolk island earlier this year with the cadets. the place is lovely, the locals are sooooo friendly!! who would ever want to commit a murder there? this guy is a sicko!!!1

[hayley]

i tell you what. i can't believe that anyone would want to murder. it is horrible. who are we to decide who lives and who dies?

[sanity]

Sadly, you do not appear to have learned much from your legal studies. Read the transcripts and see whether you agree with the jury that there was no reasonable doubt. There was no evidence he suffers from any psychiatric problem at all, which is one reason why his guilt is so unlikely. Perhaps you should be asking how a jury convicted him, and an appeal court upheld it, with no explanation for the unidentified female DNA found on her clothes where they were cut? Perhaps everyone wanted a non-Islander to be responsible?

[member1]

How could anyone get a fair trial on that island anyway!!