India in UNSC? No way, say Pakistan, ...

India in UNSC? No way, say Pakistan, China

There are 467 comments on the Welcome to rediff.com story from Nov 13, 2010, titled India in UNSC? No way, say Pakistan, China. In it, Welcome to rediff.com reports that:

Pakistan and China strongly feel that India should not become a permanent member of the United Nations Security Council, as it would disturb the balance of power in the region, Pakistan's Foreign Minister Shah Mehmood Qureshi has said.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Welcome to rediff.com.

First Prev
of 24
Next Last

“image gallery of moenjodaro”

Since: Jan 06

Location hidden

#1 Nov 13, 2010
Yes without Solving Kashmir and as India also Brutally Killing Innocent Kashmniri People ...

Yes No Way India Can Take UNSC Membership for permanant
Pak China

Pakistan

#2 Nov 13, 2010
India is terrorist country. so how can he get seat in UNSC. not possible. India terrorist govt is killing innocent Kashmirs, Tamil. More then 100 freedom movements are fighting for their freedom in India. 50% of all world hungry people live in India. so India is not fit for UNSC seat.

Pak and China are right that INDIA IS UNSE? NOW WAY ...
Pak China

Laval, Canada

#3 Nov 13, 2010
Pak China wrote:
India is terrorist country. so how can he get seat in UNSC. not possible. India terrorist govt is killing innocent Kashmirs, Tamil. More then 100 freedom movements are fighting for their freedom in India. 50% of all world hungry people live in India. so India is not fit for UNSC seat.
Pak and China are right that INDIA IS UNSE? NOW WAY IS OUT,INDIA CAN CLAIM UNSC SEAT ...
Pakistan a terrorist state killing innocent muslims with bombs in Pakistan.So India does not need Pakistan terrorist state's support to go to UNSC permanent seat.Baluchistan is fighting for freedom from Ghachi Pakistan.50% of the worlds beggar population lives in Pakistan and sleep hungry.So Pakistanis are not fit to give support to India so India does not need beggars support to be UNSC permanent member.China is right that Pakistan is a farting weakling and does not have enough power to obstruct India's demand to be a permanent membership (seat) in UNSC. So India can claim UNSC permanent seat.OK

Since: Nov 10

Location hidden

#4 Nov 13, 2010
Arre ye paki log kabhi samaj nahi sakte that pakistan is dog of china. when china asks them to fetch a ball, they run and jump and fetch, like a dog.

when pakistan is nice, china feeds them. when they are bad, china whips them.

a total dog and its owner relationship.
secular

Mumbai, India

#6 Nov 13, 2010
in globalized world. when india is alreadt making usa dancing on indias tune?why don’t u think china will?
future of world is multi polar power sharing, not single supa power all major powers will be interdependent
those will be usa china india russia and slowly brazil

all majority countries supports india be african countries, middle east,isreal.. where india buys oil/weapons running their economy high.
western countrie like british/brazil/france/usa/germ any/japan etc who are indias frend
russia and many other countries as well as india will influence more countries in coming future

india won non permananent seat with 187 votes out of 191 highest than any other country..

All major veto power nations russia/britain/france support india on permanant unsc along with veto now even usa has joined the supporting league
china vetoing against india??
india and china have trade relation running in billions india starves more trade buying from them do u think they can resist such big market?loosing it to some other country? china has long been telling india to except china occupied kashmir to declare it china's..how about india give it to them which india is not or never have been concerned about but used it as leverage?..for getting seat in indias favour??.. lol india will get what it wants wait and watch

china will use pakistan till india shake hans with them.. chinas condition of handing them one of two, cok or arunachal pradesh.

india will give cok ... to get things in indias favour retain arunachal. china and india will become close and pakistan roles over lol
usa used u.now its ur last ally china who uses u as proxy against india , the day india gives cok, security and assurance of indian ports china wont have to depend on pak, and ends pakistans role
wait till that day.. its comin soon like ur ally suadi arabia ,usa... china will also swing in indias favour like others hahaha
secular

Mumbai, India

#7 Nov 13, 2010
Pak China wrote:
India is terrorist country. so how can he get seat in UNSC. not possible. India terrorist govt is killing innocent Kashmirs, Tamil. More then 100 freedom movements are fighting for their freedom in India. 50% of all world hungry people live in India. so India is not fit for UNSC seat.
Pak and China are right that INDIA IS UNSE? NOW WAY ...
hahaha india terrorist country? well unfortunatly world doesnt think like wise india. and maintains india as as a power
"terror" has always been attached to pakistans name not india sin world scenario,so it doesnt matter what a mullah student thinkz

tamils? lol tamils are fighting for freedom in srilanka not india u fool lola wonder what education fools like u get

50% of world rofl yeah right why not why not bluff more? india has lifed millions of poor in past 5 years,and thats just expanding wait and watch

now about kashmir india has right to kill millitants in kashmir funded by pakistan. and india will continue to do so,no sympathy for terrorist unlike pakistan a terror state and terrorist supporter

now about disputs

china has bad relations with all its meighbour except beggar pakistan. be veitnam,japan,india,south korea,taiwan sharin disputes and attacks

russia has dispute with japan

america has bad human right record on iraq afganistan etc

china has occupied tibet and expoilt and harass them and have worst human record on it

when all these type of people can be in UN then why not india?
india will get the seat anyway in coming years
not matter what pakistan does
world order is changing

Since: Nov 08

Cologne- Germany

#8 Nov 13, 2010
Which scoundrel in UNSC is better qualified than South Africa.
Forget about the nasty smelly dirty INDIA?
UNSC is a club formed by the criminals made for criminal politcs and devoid of any basic decency, decipline or decorum.

I wish a sort of nonviolent club but not the perpetrators of injustice
India is unfit to be the member of this immoral institution.
That is my view and i was born in INDIA
Pak China

Lahore, Pakistan

#9 Nov 13, 2010
secular wrote:
<quoted text>
hahaha india terrorist country? well unfortunatly world doesnt think like wise india. and maintains india as as a power
"terror" has always been attached to pakistans name not india sin world scenario,so it doesnt matter what a mullah student thinkz
tamils? lol tamils are fighting for freedom in srilanka not india u fool lola wonder what education fools like u get
50% of world rofl yeah right why not why not bluff more? india has lifed millions of poor in past 5 years,and thats just expanding wait and watch
now about kashmir india has right to kill millitants in kashmir funded by pakistan. and india will continue to do so,no sympathy for terrorist unlike pakistan a terror state and terrorist supporter
now about disputs
china has bad relations with all its meighbour except beggar pakistan. be veitnam,japan,india,south korea,taiwan sharin disputes and attacks
russia has dispute with japan
america has bad human right record on iraq afganistan etc
china has occupied tibet and expoilt and harass them and have worst human record on it
when all these type of people can be in UN then why not india?
india will get the seat anyway in coming years
not matter what pakistan does
world order is changing
Arrre yaar ! don't beat us so much. We are simply envious of you, Indian folks. I mean you are progressing by leaps and bounds and we are sinking in a cesspool.

We thought sucking the dicks of the chinese would save our asses. But it seems even they can't help us. Our only export is, as you all know is terrorism and we excel in terror training. It is as though we have the best universities for training terrorists that all of them come here to learn. Our leaders are so jealous of India. Those muttonheads know only to cry and beg for aid to the Americans, not run the country. Perhaps, we should ask our chinese friends to run our country.
Rong

Shah Alam, Malaysia

#10 Nov 13, 2010
1) All the south Asian nations, Pakistan, Nepal, Sri Langka and Bangladesh are against India becoming a permanent member.

2)In the UN General Assembly there is a huge block of nations who are against expanding the permanent membership in the security council. It remains to be seen if they can be bribed into supporting India or any other nations eg Japan or Germany. Their logic is simple. What do they gain from it? Only more headache and political horse trading. It is always the small nations that pay the price of lobbying the big powers.

Since: Nov 08

Cologne- Germany

#11 Nov 13, 2010
Most of the Indians wish to survive and die without any conflict.
UNSC membership will never make the toiling, indian's life better.
I am dead against INDIA to be a partner perpetual injustice.

“We are what we think!!!!!!!!!!”

Since: Aug 08

Anger has no eyes!

#13 Nov 13, 2010
Can we expect some general knowledge ? It's Sri Lankan Tamils who are fighting for freedom.

Indian Tamils are living in peace. Now DO YOU KNOW ANY DIFFERENCE BETWEEN NATION AND LANGUAGE ?
Pak China wrote:
India is terrorist country. so how can he get seat in UNSC. not possible. India terrorist govt is killing innocent Kashmirs, Tamil. More then 100 freedom movements are fighting for their freedom in India. 50% of all world hungry people live in India. so India is not fit for UNSC seat.
Pak and China are right that INDIA IS UNSE? NOW WAY ...

“We are what we think!!!!!!!!!!”

Since: Aug 08

Anger has no eyes!

#14 Nov 13, 2010
From my understanding, Indian troops are already in many region like Rwanda, Afghanistan, and many other parts of the world conduction humanitarian aids.

Remember, they wanted to aid pakis but pakis ONLY wanted the money.
Ramafuchs wrote:
Most of the Indians wish to survive and die without any conflict.
UNSC membership will never make the toiling, indian's life better.
I am dead against INDIA to be a partner perpetual injustice.

“We are what we think!!!!!!!!!!”

Since: Aug 08

Anger has no eyes!

#15 Nov 13, 2010
What are you blabbering about Kashmir ? Terrorism is perpetuated by ISI and that the reason you guys are in such disaster.

Now, talk about Gilgit Baltistan , it's in the state of disaster and you've SOLD to China.


HOPEFULLY CHINA WILL TAKE WHOLE OF THE PAK, AND THERE WILL PEACE in the region. You guys have proved you aren't capable of ruling yourself.
MOMIN ANSARI wrote:
Yes without Solving Kashmir and as India also Brutally Killing Innocent Kashmniri People ...
Yes No Way India Can Take UNSC Membership for permanant

“We are what we think!!!!!!!!!!”

Since: Aug 08

Anger has no eyes!

#16 Nov 13, 2010
With pak being such a failed state, do you even think the world care about "it's" opinion ?
MOMIN ANSARI wrote:
Yes without Solving Kashmir and as India also Brutally Killing Innocent Kashmniri People ...
Yes No Way India Can Take UNSC Membership for permanant
Suraj

India

#17 Nov 14, 2010
Rong wrote:
1) All the south Asian nations, Pakistan, Nepal, Sri Langka and Bangladesh are against India becoming a permanent member.
2)In the UN General Assembly there is a huge block of nations who are against expanding the permanent membership in the security council. It remains to be seen if they can be bribed into supporting India or any other nations eg Japan or Germany. Their logic is simple. What do they gain from it? Only more headache and political horse trading. It is always the small nations that pay the price of lobbying the big powers.
That is a wrong assumption. No other South Asian nation except Pakistan (for obvious reasons) opposes India's membership in the UNSC. Even China has not made its explicit opposition to India. I mean it would look mean and petty, to oppose another Asian country and a rising power.

About the second part, the reformation of the UN cannot take place with out including India, the second populous country and the fourth largest economy of the world. It is a reality from which no nation can shy away from. The present membership of the UNSC is anachronistic and representative of the power structure of a bygone era.
Suraj

India

#18 Nov 14, 2010
EkDesiLadki wrote:
With pak being such a failed state, do you even think the world care about "it's" opinion ?
<quoted text>
That is the point. Who cares about what Pakistan thinks....

First and foremost it is the opinion of the five permanent members in the UNSC that matters. All except China are favourable toward India and as said before, even the Chinese have not made their opposition clear.The majority of the UN general assembly would want India, another third world nation to represent them in the SC and give them an even more louder voice.

Since: Nov 10

Location hidden

#19 Nov 14, 2010
Rong wrote:
1) All the south Asian nations, Pakistan, Nepal, Sri Langka and Bangladesh are against India becoming a permanent member.
2)In the UN General Assembly there is a huge block of nations who are against expanding the permanent membership in the security council. It remains to be seen if they can be bribed into supporting India or any other nations eg Japan or Germany. Their logic is simple. What do they gain from it? Only more headache and political horse trading. It is always the small nations that pay the price of lobbying the big powers.
Do you have references and web links? I would really doubt any except Pakistan in that list to oppose India for 1).
Ek sawal

Mumbai, India

#20 Nov 14, 2010
Pak China wrote:
<quoted text>
Arrre yaar ! don't beat us so much. We are simply envious of you, Indian folks. I mean you are progressing by leaps and bounds and we are sinking in a cesspool.
We thought sucking the dicks of the chinese would save our asses. But it seems even they can't help us. Our only export is, as you all know is terrorism and we excel in terror training. It is as though we have the best universities for training terrorists that all of them come here to learn. Our leaders are so jealous of India. Those muttonheads know only to cry and beg for aid to the Americans, not run the country. Perhaps, we should ask our chinese friends to run our country.
No need to ask chinese to run your country. Just try to anylise the things and dont compete with anybody now and let the time come. just concentrate internal affairs of pakistan. Your politicians only try to do which you people like. so change your interest, take interest in pakistani situation without comparing it to anybody. if you come out of denial mode, the day will come soon when you will also be in race with these counrties then compete.
PakSympathiser

Mumbai, India

#21 Nov 14, 2010
The Coffee Club doesn't want any additional nation to be a permanent member of UNSC.

China / Paki gang doesn't want India to become. Spain doesn't want Germany to become. Mexico doesn't want Brazil to become.

Coming back to China, India was instrumental in it getting into UN and UNSC. Looking at Pakis, India votes for them in ADB/WB for the financial aid it gets. These two countries are a drag on international affairs and lead members of rogue countries.

UNSC should be dissolved and reformed with restated but complete rights for the member countries. I am sure that India will find its place.

Finally if Pakis don't want India to become a permanent member of UNSC for whatever reason, they should look back at themselves and think whether they should even exist.
New China

Wuhan, China

#22 Nov 14, 2010
so far I havn't yet read and seen on our medias that China strongly oppose India become a permanent member of the United Nations Security Council

but what chinese donate pakistan flood disaster is really true.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 24
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

China Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Vladivostok lures Chinese - many of whom think ... 3 hr just a guy i knew 1
News Sun Yat-sen's 150th birth anniversary marked in... 8 hr Russian Ainu 5
News Analysis: South China Sea ruling has so far fue... Sat Go Blue Forever 3
News 25 years on, no fading of Tiananmen wounds, ideals (May '14) Sat Go Blue Forever 109
News China Expands Naval Power to Waters U.S. Dominates (Apr '10) Sat Go Blue Forever 3,286
why are chinese ugly? (Aug '13) Jul 22 Passersby 10
News Take That, Tesla Jul 21 Solarman 1
More from around the web