Nanking Massacre is fake
Nana

Osaka, Japan

#242 Jul 25, 2013
akaboshi
■(Part1) The so-called 'Nanking Massacre' is the case wherein 300,000 people of Nanking city and the captives have been alleged to have been murdered during the six weeks occupation period under the Japanese Army, from December 13 immediately after the fall of Nanking through the beginning of February of 1938. Where 300,000 of dead bodies were? Let's look at the statistics.
(Part2)The Chinese postwar investigation, which has claims Japanese killed 300,000 people in Nanking Massacre, has presented the following two groups of evidences to prove the victims of more than 300,000:
1 Burial records of 150,000 corpses by the Advance Benevolence Society and the Red Swastika Society.
2 Chinese testimonies of the eleven cases to verify the murder of 190,000 people.
In here, let’s look at the number 1 which shows 150,000 corpses.
(Part3)All the activities that the Advance Benevolence Society was involved were provision of clothes, relief of widows, and nurture. Burial was not included. According to Nanking compiled by ICHIKI Yoshimichi (published by Japan Business and Industry Institution, Nanking Office, 1941), the Advance Benevolence Society suspended its activities from December 1937 to August 1938. There existed no proof showing that the Advance Benevolence Society was written in 1946, nine years after the incident.
(Part4)Why has the Chinese presented the Advance Benevolence Society for evidence? No matter what, they wanted the massacre was occurred by the Japanese, so they presented the wrong evidence? What did the Red Swastika Society report? To the Tokyo Trial, a record was submitted that the company buried 42,000 corpses, but the accuracy of its record could be doubtful. A Japanese man whose name was Maruyama testified, "The number of burials per day was at most 200.”
(Part5) Rabe also wrote in his diary dated on Feb 15, "Until now, 200 bodies were buried a day.(The Good Man of Nanking P197) The company was capable of burying an average of 180 a day. About 5,000 were buried in end of February. In March, burials per day increased in number because the Japanese gave extra charge each corpse to workers and 5 trucks, so the number of burials per day increased by from 600 to 800.
(Part6)The same number could be found in the report dated on March 4, addressed to the Foreign Office in Germany by Georg Rosen. At this time, however, a serious issue happened. Having padding the number of buried corpses in order to gain more wages, the Red Swastika Society reported on their activities. As of the end of February, 5,000 were reported, and on March 15, the figure mounted to 31,791.
(Part7)It was calculated that they had buried 26,000 in fifteen days. In other words, 1,700 a day had to be disposed. Japanese soldiers knew the Chinese were lying. However, the Japanese paid money to them because they didn’t want to have any troubles. What was the actual figure of burials? The total number would be from 10,400 to 12,400.
(Part8)This figure could almost coincide with that appeared in The Nanking City government general condition (edited by the Nanking Secret Service) which read that 9,364 were buried in the period of from January 1938 to April. Based on the facts stated so far, the actual burials made by the Red Swastika Society were around 10,000, so that the identify of corpses could be assumed to be the war dead of the Chinese Army.
(Part9)The Battle of Nanking, p.351. Battle of Nanking Editorial Committee estimates that Chinese soldiers were killed in action with 12,366 from December 4 to 12 evening, based on the Nanking Garrison Battle Report. Chinese government presented the Burial records of 150,000 corpses by the Advance Benevolence Society and the Red Swastika Society to the Tokyo Trial. So, can you believe the reports? Where were 300,000 of Chinese civilians’ dead bodies? The Nanking Massacre really occurred?
Nana

Osaka, Japan

#243 Jul 25, 2013
■Here is the burial record presented to the IMTFE (International Military Tribunal for the Far East) by the Red Swastika Society. The statistics show where the corpses were found and buried. Only about 2,800 corpses are found inside Nanking castle (walled city of Nanking), and the rest are recovered outside, which were almost 40,000. There are few corpses of women and children. Where were 300,000 of dead bodies?

■(Part1)One picture shows Japanese troops created the nameless war dead of Chinese soldiers’ resting place in China during the war. In contrast, according to Chinese reports, Chinese authorities did not any attention to dead or wounded soldiers. Before the Japanese Army entered Nanking, there had been many corpses in the city. German correspondent Lily Abegg wrote an account entitled Escape from Nanking.「Our Last Days in China's Capital, as to the aspect on Nov 29, 1937:
(Part2)”Wherever we went, we could see that order was given way to chaos. A train carrying 2,000 wounded soldiers arrived at Nanking Station, but no one paid it any heed. There were no medical soldiers. The wounded soldiers were left there for two days, and during the time, dragged out of the train with corpses. The corpses emitted a horrible stench, polluting the air.” They have appealed these stories must have been committed by the Japanese.
 

thebattleofchina1.jpgthe_battl e_of_china_2
■(Part1)People should be careful to watch Chinese propaganda which has been shown Japanese atrocity. I’d like to show a film which is called The Battle of China. This wartime propaganda film is directed by Frank Capra, American famous director of 1930's, and comes out in l944. In the film, there are ten-second scenes of the description of Nanking Massacre. However, these can hardly be the true description, because of the following reasons.
(Part2)
1 An officer is taking a woman by force. His epaulet is different from that of the Japanese officer. The medal he wears on the breast is not of the Japanese Army in terms of design.
2 A man wears a revolver belt. But, the then Japanese soldiers don't wear it, since they didn't use a revolver. Also, he doesn't wear a saber but a parade sword. But, in war, a parade sword has never been used.
(Part3)
3 Chinese inhabitants in the film are in shirts with half sleeves in the cold wintertime. A piece of paper which says 'Three People's Principles' is on the chest of a woman who is being buried alive, but Japanese do not have such a way of thinking. On the other hand, this custom was still observed in the 1930s in China. The whole things are forged pictures!

9heads
■(Part1)One of the photos shows nine people's heads stand in a line side by side on ground. This photo is used as purported evidence of Nanking Massacre victims, but there was no such custom of gibbeted heads among the Japanese after the 1870s. Among the Chinese, however, this custom was still observed in the 1930s, and several photos of gibbeted heads appeared in cities of China in those days.
(Part2)There was also a case of gibbeted heads in the French Concession in Shanghai on February 12, 1938. Most historians allege that these were the heads of bandits or political criminals killed in the Chinese civil war. Iris Chang's The Rape of Nanking has the same photo with a background behind the heads on page 113. Looking at the larger photo, those who had experienced Nanking testified that the background is not of Nanking.

■A photo has displayed at the Nanking Massacre Museum. The caption said, "The Japanese rounded up thousands of women. Most of them were gang raped or forced into military prostitution. But this photo appeared in the Asahi Graph, a weekly photo journal, published in Japan on Nov 10, 1937, about one month before Nanking battle. The explanation says, "A group of women and children from the Rising Sun Village returning from the fields, guarded by our soldiers."
Nana

Osaka, Japan

#244 Jul 25, 2013
■Photographs purported to be evidence of a massacre in Nanking are on display at the Nanjing Massacre Memorial Hall, at other exhibitions, and in printed publications. However, recent scientific research has revealed that there are no photographs attesting to a massacre in Nanking. At least 143 pictures are distorted, are fabricated, or are used for the Nanking Massacre pictures which were from different areas and different times by Chinese government.

naziflag
■(Part1)The 'Nanking Massacre' in which the Prosecution claims the 'massacre of 300,000', has never been so proved. However, any other unjustifiable killings by Japanese troops are regarded as punishable war crimes during the battles against the Chinese Army, and these should be processed under the international humanitarian law. On the other hand, in case of Germany, they were not fighting the war against the Jewish people.
(Part2) The large-scale slaughters targeting all the Jewish people, including the killings of Jewish people who had German citizenship, committed by the Nazi Germany were systematically planned killings based on the specific ethnic ideology which had no direct connection with the war. Those killings were, indeed, the 'crimes against humanity', and those crimes are fundamentally different from the 'war crimes' which the Japanese troops were said to have committed.
(Part3) Not only so, Japanese must say that there existed the crucial fact that the then Japanese government sternly refused the persecution policy against the Jewish people which the Nazi Germany was implementing, even though Japan had amicable relations with Germany by means of concluding the Anti-Comintern Pact during that time when the battle of Nanking occurred.
(Part4)In December 1938, almost one year after the battle of Nanking, the Japanese Government decided the policy that 'based on the spirit of racial equality which we have insisted on for many years, we will treat the Jewish people with fairness, in the same manner as we treat other foreigners and we will not take special measures to reject them.

hospital
■(Part1)In Chinese history, Chinese soldiers destroyed the homes and fields of their own civilians in order to wipe out any possible supplies or shelter that could be utilized by the over-extended enemy troops. This strategy is called "The Clean Field Strategy" by China. In fact, Chinese soldiers killed 30,000 their own people in cold blood in Changsha in 1938 under this strategy in spite of the fact that the Japanese didn’t attack the city.

(Part2)The Chinese government has announced that all of these victims were massacred by the Japanese even though they killed many Chinese people. The Chinese government used a clever trick which was called Chinese propaganda during the war. They are an expert on lies, Ralph Townsend said.

800px-Hanjian_poster_in_Nankin g
■(Part1)Traditionall y in Japan, Samurai warriors lived inside walls of castle, and farmers and merchants outside the walls. Civilian cities were not walled. A war was a fight only among warriors, and they never killed civilians. While, in China, farmers and merchants lived inside a walled city and in wars the inhabitants including the farmers and merchants inside the walls were often all slaughtered with warriors.

(Part2)In Chinese chronicles, we often read such massacres. The Chinese language has the word which writes slaughtering castle and means slaughtering all people within the city. It was a Chinese culture. The Japanese never had such a culture. Nanking was a walled capital city, and the idea of massacring all inhabitants was Chinese, not Japanese.
Nana

Osaka, Japan

#245 Jul 25, 2013
■(Part1)The 228 Massacre was an anti-government uprising in Taiwan that began on February 27, 1947 and was violently suppressed by the Kuomintang (KMT) government. Before the 228 massacre was broke out, the mood of the crowd, which had already been harboring many feelings of frustration from KMT rule, reached breaking point. The KMT troops who came from mainland China were highly undisciplined, looting, stealing, and contributing to the overall breakdown of infrastructure and public services.

(Part2)Estimates of the number of deaths vary from ten thousand to thirty thousand or more. According to the New York Times on March 29, 1947, an American said,“Troops from China arrived at Taiwan on March 7 and indulged in three days of indiscriminate killing and looting. For a time everyone seen on the streets was shot at, homes were broken into and occupants killed. In the poorer sections the streets were said to have been littered with dead.

(Part3)There were instances of beheadings and mutilation of bodies, and women were raped.” This is the Chinese inherent characteristics. The Nanking Massacre might have been have caused by KMT soldiers. In fact, R.J Rummel claims that Chinese peasants often had no less to fear from their own soldiers than they did from the Japanese. Moreover, KMT soldiers in the Nanking castle in their mad rush to discard their military uniforms and put on civilian clothes.

(Part4)In a number of incidents, killed civilians to obtain their clothing in Nanking city in 1937 before the Japanese troops entered to the Nanking castle. James Espy, the vice American Council at Nanking, reported to the American Embassy. Go back to the 228 massacre story, Chen Yi, the ROC authorities, had jailed or killed all the leading Taiwanese organizers he could identify and catch.

(Part5)His troops executed between 3,000 and 4,000 people. Chen Yi was later quoted by TIME magazine in April 7, 1947 as saying: "It took the Japs 51 years to dominate this island. I expect to take about five years to re-educate the people so they will be happier with Chinese administration." This fact shows they were mind controlled by the Chinese government? The Nanking Massacre was a fake story. In fact, Chinese school kids have learned anti-Japanese education.

■(Part1)Chinese government created many Japanese testimonies after the WW2 finished intentionally. After WW2, many Japanese soldiers who were dispatched China returned to Japan temporarily. However, they were caught by Chinese government as criminals. Many Japanese were in Chinese jails after finished the WW2, and they were tortured by them. The Japanese were forced to write what they did in China. In short, they had to write false diary stories which were directed by the Chinese.

(Part2)Definitely, the Chinese government needed Japanese evidence about committing many massacres in China. After the Japanese wrote in the diary which shows Japanese raped many Chinese women and killed many civilians, they could be free and go back to Japan. From the perspective of psychology, if people are forced to write false stories for long time, the false stories could be true memories.

(Part3)The Chukiren is a group which composed Japanese soldiers that came back from China has told these stories. A confession obtained by asking leading questions or torture is not recognized by the courts. These days, the Chinese government has still used these false stories for diplomatic cards between Japan and China. However, the Japanese were smart because they wrote another troop name which never has stayed in China.
Nana

Osaka, Japan

#246 Jul 25, 2013
■(Part1)There were more than 100 Japanese news correspondents besides the troops, who entered Nanking city during the six weeks when the Chinese claim that the 'massacre' occurred. YAMAMOTO Osamu, the then correspondent of the Osaka Asahi Shimbun (Shanghai Branch Office) says, "I never witnessed nor heard of such a thing.”
(Part2)Also, MAEDA Yuji who was a correspondent of the Domei News agency said, I was totally shocked with the news about these crimes occurred within the Nanking city. All other Domei's correspondents who used to diligently cover inside the city in those days have never encountered any incidents of brutality that occurred after restoring the public order. If any unlawful things like that had happened, some of us or any correspondent must have caught that.

tributegifts
■(Part1)When the Japanese troops entered Nanking on Dec 13, 1937, more than 100 press reporters and photographers entered together with them. The press corps was not only from Japan, but also from European and American press organizations, including Reuters and AP. However, none of the press corps reported the occurrence of a massacre of 300,000 people. Paramount News (American newsreels) made films reporting the Japanese occupation in Nanking, but did not report the occurrence of a massacre.
(Part2)The British newspaper North China Daily News, which was published in China in English on December 24, 1937, eleven days after the Japanese occupation of Nanking, carried a photo taken in Nanking by their photographer. The photo was entitled "Japanese distribute gifts in Nanking." In the photo are Japanese soldiers distributing gifts, and Chinese adults and children receiving the gifts and rejoicing. Is this the scene of a massacre?

rapeofnankingbook

■(Part1)Recently, a Chinese American named Iris Chang wrote a book entitled, The Rape of Nanking. It tells about the brutal massacre by the Japanese in Nanking. It became a bestseller in the USA and other countries, and spread the lie of the Nanking Massacre. Later, Chang’s book was much criticized by many other authors.
(Part2)It has been pointed out that what she wrote and the photos in her book were not related to the so-called Nanking Massacre. She shot herself by pistol and died in 2004. The London Economist magazine commented that she had committed suicide perhaps because her book was much criticized and she was deeply depressed about it.

Since: Feb 08

Kagoshima, Japan

#247 Oct 2, 2013
Stalin Was Obviously Japanese Agent

http://park.geocities.jp/jpcdebate/0103/p031....

It is Japan's particular strategy to employ camouflaged Japanese in other nations.
Truth

Nagoya, Japan

#248 Jan 3, 2014
waytogo

Harbin, China

#249 Jan 3, 2014
earth would be a better place if there were no such country called japan...
RESISTANCE IS FUTILE

Richmond, Canada

#250 Jan 3, 2014
Japanese are getting old and dying out,..

payback will be when these old japanese will have to rely on younger Chinese to take care of them

frankly I dont think Chinese will be as cruel as the Japanese were
AAA

Sandy, UK

#251 Jan 3, 2014
Nana wrote:
■(Part1)There were more than 100 Japanese news correspondents besides the troops, who entered Nanking city during the six weeks when the Chinese claim that the 'massacre' occurred. YAMAMOTO Osamu, the then correspondent of the Osaka Asahi Shimbun (Shanghai Branch Office) says, "I never witnessed nor heard of such a thing.”
(Part2)Also, MAEDA Yuji who was a correspondent of the Domei News agency said, I was totally shocked with the news about these crimes occurred within the Nanking city. All other Domei's correspondents who used to diligently cover inside the city in those days have never encountered any incidents of brutality that occurred after restoring the public order. If any unlawful things like that had happened, some of us or any correspondent must have caught that.
tributegifts
■(Part1)When the Japanese troops entered Nanking on Dec 13, 1937, more than 100 press reporters and photographers entered together with them. The press corps was not only from Japan, but also from European and American press organizations, including Reuters and AP. However, none of the press corps reported the occurrence of a massacre of 300,000 people. Paramount News (American newsreels) made films reporting the Japanese occupation in Nanking, but did not report the occurrence of a massacre.
(Part2)The British newspaper North China Daily News, which was published in China in English on December 24, 1937, eleven days after the Japanese occupation of Nanking, carried a photo taken in Nanking by their photographer. The photo was entitled "Japanese distribute gifts in Nanking." In the photo are Japanese soldiers distributing gifts, and Chinese adults and children receiving the gifts and rejoicing. Is this the scene of a massacre?
rapeofnankingbook
■(Part1)Recently, a Chinese American named Iris Chang wrote a book entitled, The Rape of Nanking. It tells about the brutal massacre by the Japanese in Nanking. It became a bestseller in the USA and other countries, and spread the lie of the Nanking Massacre. Later, Chang’s book was much criticized by many other authors.
(Part2)It has been pointed out that what she wrote and the photos in her book were not related to the so-called Nanking Massacre. She shot herself by pistol and died in 2004. The London Economist magazine commented that she had committed suicide perhaps because her book was much criticized and she was deeply depressed about it.
Well done, the more I scan through your posts the more I feel it was justifiable for the Yanks to nuke Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Well done to North Korea if Kim wants to have a go at Tokyo. Well done to God for Fukushima. Because of trash like you, any effort for the right winger Abe to attain sympathy will simply go down the drain. Really, you are undermining the effort of the more sensible Japanese who try to move on by making peace with the neighbours and acknowledging Japs' past atrocities.
AAA

Sandy, UK

#252 Jan 3, 2014
Truth wrote:
http://www2.biglobe.ne.jp/~rem nant/nankingm.htm
http://www.ne.jp/asahi/unko/tamezou/nankin/al...
Nanking Massacre is fake!
Another trash....are you getting too much radiation from Fukushima or are you a mutant kid from Hiroshima? You right winger are just disgrace.
MT Chan

Canada

#253 Jan 4, 2014
On Lok Chuen Massacre in Fanling, Hong Kong during Japanese occupation:

http://www.topix.com/forum/world/china/T0SFSB...
RayH

Shenzhen, China

#258 Apr 26, 2014
RESISTANCE IS FUTILE wrote:
Japanese are getting old and dying out,..
payback will be when these old japanese will have to rely on younger Chinese to take care of them
frankly I dont think Chinese will be as cruel as the Japanese were
No worries, they still got Bill-tard, a total force of ONE retard.
John

Flushing, NY

#261 May 11, 2014
China always want to push the subject of Nanking but refuses to talk about the atrocities against their own people during the Communist Revolution. Millions were killed, raped , tortured or starved to death.
Geming Junren

Princeton Junction, NJ

#262 May 11, 2014
John you are damned liar. The New Democratic Revolution of 1949 liberated billions of Chinese from destitution and exploitation.

Yes a famine did happen, but the CPC is not to blame. The famine occurred due to both western and soviet imperialism which sought to contain and isolate China.

China was struggling to rebuild after 8 years of war. Mistakes were inevitably made at the policy level, but to call Mao a "mass murderer" is an ugly lie and you know it.

Stop falsely vilifying the CPC!
USaWorld bully War monger

United States

#263 May 11, 2014
John wrote:
China always want to push the subject of Nanking but refuses to talk about the atrocities against their own people during the Communist Revolution. Millions were killed, raped , tortured or starved to death.
You should look in your Own backyard you American holocaust, know about your own Ugly history before you point fingers on other nations
DoNotBlameJapan

Dallas, TX

#264 May 12, 2014
Although this massacre happened during WWII, it's the sub-sequence of the history, when many nations came together to enslave the Chinese people.

Matter of fact there were (08) eight nations involved in this tragedy. They are

1) The United States of America
2) The French
3) The Austria-Hungary
4) The German
5) The Japan
6) The British
7) The Italy
8) The Russia

On August, the 14th of 1900, the army of the above 8 nations defeat the Chinese and occupied Peijing. Empress Dowager Cixi (famous for her high sex life), the Emperor, and high government officials fled the Imperial Palace.

This was believed as a result of the aggressive and arrogant policy of the Chinese toward foreigners in 19 century
DoNotBlameJapan

Dallas, TX

#265 May 12, 2014
This image revealed a foreign soldier executed a Chinese in public - remember this happened long before th Nanking event

Warning : Horrific scene

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/9/9d...

So, bottom line do not blame Japan alone
McQuan

UK

#266 May 12, 2014
DoNotBlameJapan wrote:
This image revealed a foreign soldier executed a Chinese in public - remember this happened long before th Nanking event
Warning : Horrific scene
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/9/9d...
So, bottom line do not blame Japan alone
Pot calling the kettle black, trying to find a partner for the crime?
DoNotBlameJapan

Dallas, TX

#267 May 12, 2014
McQuan wrote:
<quoted text>
Pot calling the kettle black, trying to find a partner for the crime?
Do you ask for being punishment?

It's not Chinese false for being enslaved by 8 nations,

It's their government policy is first to be blamed


Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

China Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
In the 20 years, Vietnam illegally occupied 48 ... 2 hr Yakult 11
tibet better off under chinese rule (Mar '12) 8 hr DEAL WITH IT 2
News Massive carbon sinks detected beneath worlds de... 8 hr Earthling-1 1
News BRICS' New Development Bank launched in Shanghai Tue Yakult 3
News China Arrests The Short Sellers - All Is Well? Tue Yakult 3
News Russia Losing Out on Chinese FDI... Tue Cassandra_ 3
News Taiwan promotes its island claim in South China... Mon TW_sugar_daddio 11
More from around the web