Parts outshine New Orleans' jazz ense...

Parts outshine New Orleans' jazz ensemble's conventional whole

There are 3 comments on the Chicago Tribune story from Apr 13, 2008, titled Parts outshine New Orleans' jazz ensemble's conventional whole. In it, Chicago Tribune reports that:

Someday, the New Orleans Jazz Orchestra may emerge as a top-notch repertory band.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Chicago Tribune.

ECaro

Violet, LA

#1 Apr 15, 2008
This critic is just that, a critic. There's a vernacular to this form of Jazz that requires a more highly experienced ear than that displayed by this writer. By analogy: imagine being in a juke joint in Leland, Mississippi. The guitar may be out of tune and the drummer stepping in and out of time. This critic would say something like, "well, this band isn't as good as Eric Clapton." In short, there's a difference between Jazz players and the culture of Jazz. NOJO comes from the culture where music is literally made on the streets. You probably saw a performance that was a toned down version of this culture: made palatable to a less adventurous audience.
John Galt

Country Club Hills, IL

#2 Apr 21, 2008
It is great to see some honest reviewing for a change!!! Irvin is definitely the weak link in his band, and his writing is reminiscent of High School pep band compositions. He is smart to surround himself with such amazing soloists. Other impressive players were Barney Floyd (lead trumpet) and Derek Douget (saxophone).
JJWK

United States

#3 Apr 27, 2008
Amen! I have had the frustrating pleasure/pain of hearing NOJO perform on several occasions. And I've been discounted for identifying the same strengths and weaknesses as Mr. Reich and John Galt (above). Mr. Irvin breathed life into the musical culture of a suffering city when this orchestra was organized, but he is neither a gifted nor original composer. Each piece he writes seems so repetitive that, as I leave the auditorium, I often feel as though I'm walking in a strange cadence--one geared to his repetitious rhythms.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

The Orchestra Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Senior Saturday concerts in July (Jul '16) Jul '16 Ttown concerts 1
Phonetic Composition (Mar '16) Mar '16 Jim Hoskins 1
News Parking and traffic plan outlined for St. Augus... (Nov '15) Dec '15 Stinky Fish 4
Zaragemca Top Experience (Jul '14) Jul '14 Gerry Zaragemca 1
News McFall's returns to deliver tango with a twist (Jun '14) Jun '14 Lithuanian Nazi L... 2
zaragemca brief on musical arrangement (Feb '14) Feb '14 Gerry Zaragemca 1
News Doobie Brothers music in Fountain Park (Jul '13) Jul '13 High 2
More from around the web