Roman Catholic church only true churc...

Roman Catholic church only true church, says Vatican

There are 653901 comments on the CBC News story from Jul 10, 2007, titled Roman Catholic church only true church, says Vatican. In it, CBC News reports that:

The VaticanA issued a document Tuesday restatingA its belief that the Roman Catholic Church is the only true church of Jesus Christ.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at CBC News.

truth

Mount Lawley, Australia

#479070 Sep 29, 2013
I don't liked liars..i have to much in my life.

Now you try pretend.
First I don't need choose chat on my son computer.

I make great mistake.

As well i make mistake why i don't move from this country much more early.

“GOD SO LOVED US”

Since: Aug 08

He Gave His SON,JESUS Christ

#479071 Sep 29, 2013
Husker Du wrote:
<quoted text>Why are you on a Catholic forum? Do you want to come back to the faith or do you want to harass Catholics?
Actually I CAME BACK to this forum ..I had a friend I liked here ..She does NOT post ..But Preston knows her .

Besides that ..I learned things here .

And until the last few months,I honestly thought as I DID then..That there was common ground .. we live the SANE JESUS CHRIST KNIT ..

I DOn't know why ..we can't just talk and try to understand beliefs,.

I was a Catholic...I learned a lot..though evidently some if the things are NOT taught the same ..

AND I THOUGHT at least on this forum people would remember the Saviuor they represent

Just because we worship differently . Does not mean we don't love
HIM ..it have to act like this is a playground ...

IMO
hojo

Saint Paul, MN

#479075 Sep 29, 2013
Concerned in Brasil wrote:
<quoted text>
This is not a Catholic Forum.
WRONG! The title indicates IT IS a Catholic Forum that Protestants, agnostics and atheists are on here for ONE PURPOSE--and ONE PURPOSE ONLY!!!!! To attack the Faith and Salvation in Jesus Christ, of Catholic Christians, the Doctrine/teachings of the Catholic Faith, and the Catholic Church itself...... If the title of this forum said
Protestant "bible only" Churches are the only true churches", you wouldn't find ONE Catholic on here! WHY?? Because we (as Catholics) wouldn't waste our time, FULLY KNOWING that there is no biblical or historical truth to back up this statement!!...I/we as Catholics have believed, followed,worshipped and adhered to the TRUTH of Jesus Christ ever since Our Lord established, formed and intiated HIS ONE TRUE UNIVERSAL CHURCH in Matthew 16:13-21 over 2000 years ago. We don't need to "seek out" a Protestant forum to discuss, argue or debate ANYTHING!!!---Because there is NOTHING to debate, NOTHING to discuss and NOTHING to argue over. The TRUTH of the TRUE GOSPEL of Jesus Christ and HIS One True Catholic Church has ALL been established, proven, substantiated, and verified over and over and over again---for centuries!!!
Dust Storm

Minneapolis, MN

#479076 Sep 29, 2013
RoSesz wrote:
<quoted text>
PEACE
I'm not posting about your Church ..BELUEVE what you want .And it wasn't you ..

Yes you are and arrogantly and sarcasitcly as you admitted. You also did put me as saying you were never a Catholic. I do question that you ever had a deep understanding. I believe you went through the motions and with hojo you indicated this. When you were wandering did you seek, study and delve deeper into the church for answers or did you wander? You wandered as you said.

I still don't get AnyoneAnyone would lie,on it .

We do too, yet it happens alot along with numerous sock pucppets.

The site I posted Baltimore CATECHISM 1 No you posted a site where anyone can contribute. I said you probably had the baltimore catechism which can be found with scriptural reference.

Now,..while I'm content ..You all keep your history as you like ...
O DO not like being called a,liar because Your Church taught differently hernia was a child ..it's bearing false witness..

It didn't teach differently in the way in which you portray. Limbo was theologium it was not a Dogma that anyone was required to believe. I do suggest you dont know the difference between Dogma, Doctrine, Disoiplines, Holy Traditon vs tradition and theologium. You have demonstrated that.

Did the Nuns tell you how old the earth was? Did the Nuns tell you that you had to believe 6 days meant 6 24hr. periods? Did the Nuns explain to you the process of how the earth was created or did they teach you the story of Genesis and said you had to literally interpret every word? Did they say the Pope saves you not Jesus? No Did they tell you how the books of the bible were determined and when? Did you read the early Fathers and the history of the church? Did you seek deeper knwoledge and understanding? Did the Nuns explain to you the other rites of the church or did you even know or do you now know they exist? Did you know about the Russian Orthodox? Did you know and understand what an indulgence is. Do you know all about the Inquistion, to whom it applied and why? Your comments show not at all. Do you know what Pope means? Do you know the role in history, the biblical basis, the massive documentation. Do you know what infalliblity entails by the churches definition? Your comments show you do not and never did. So while you may have been a Catholic you were a nominal one at best who lacked deeper knwoledge and understanding including the mass itself. Your flawed perceptions are not reality yet you insist we must believe that you are the expert on all the church tuaght changing infallible stuff all the time. lol Give it a rest Rose. The correct title of the Orthodox is Russian Orthodox. All Orthodox are Russian Orthodox and All Protestants are Lutherans since you insist the church is just Roman Catholic the correct title. Rather than insisting what we always believed and changed it you could perhaps humble yourself ever so slightly and accept some reality rather than demand we believe you have final say on what the church taught from your flawed perceptions, misiunderstandings and lack of depth.

in my state,we took diocesan exams ..got straight As in religion .
It's my history ..I loved the nubs who helped raise Me..
One if hose ladies even says I'm lying about how long I've been on Topix .
Again. I don't lie...And it's hurtful to be called one .
You all believe as you like ..But I darn well know what the RCC taught in the fifties .
Why is it sarcastic to assert what I KNOW TO BE TRUE ..
I don't get it ..You HAVR the same commandments,we do ..yet your people,..not all ..attack on he bad is I'm lying ..I'm not
Find an old priest and ask ..it your grandparents ..before bearing false witness ...not you ..

Since: Dec 11

Location hidden

#479077 Sep 29, 2013
marge wrote:
<quoted text>
Your baby Christians at best Hermi, love you enemies remember.
==========

On 9/28/13 #478998 Marge posted to Herm:
And from what I've seen you and Seri both need to share some of that love Jesus showed you to Regina.
I really do sometimes think you two are fake Christians!

On 9/26/13 #479007 Marge posted to Herm:
Your baby Christians at best Hermi, love you enemies remember.

But on 12/18/11 #321022 Marge posted to Herm (icxc)
Icxc enemy too, enemy to the Gospel.

Since: Feb 12

Location hidden

#479078 Sep 29, 2013
Husker Du wrote:
Rosey, you came on this forum just to try to discredit Catholics.
Rose doesn't have to try to discredit you all. You are doing a great job all by yourselves!!

Since: Jan 08

Location hidden

#479079 Sep 29, 2013
Hermeneutics Smutics wrote:
<quoted text>==========
On 9/28/13 #478998 Marge posted to Herm:
And from what I've seen you and Seri both need to share some of that love Jesus showed you to Regina.
I really do sometimes think you two are fake Christians!
On 9/26/13 #479007 Marge posted to Herm:
Your baby Christians at best Hermi, love you enemies remember.
But on 12/18/11 #321022 Marge posted to Herm (icxc)
Icxc enemy too, enemy to the Gospel.
don't pay any attention to marge, she tries to be a "alpha male" and run things on this forum.

but she has been a troublemaker ever since she came on this forum
Clay

Saint Paul, MN

#479080 Sep 29, 2013
RoSesz wrote:
<quoted text>
Plus,one theory fir he apparent age,remains,...in the flood the waters,came NOT ONLY FROM.THE SKY ...But he fountains DEEP WITHIN the earth erupted ..can you imagine how hat would mess up he layering .
I never thought of JUST HOW,LONG were they there .
I choose to believe what God told us,as well and what I was taught in school by the nuns ..several decades,ago
You were not taught by the nuns that the earth was 5,000 yrs old. I had nuns too. They were old and likely were around when you went to grade school. In 7th grade science I learned about dinosaurs being millions of yrs old.
Concerned in Brazil enjoys calling everyone an idiot because he's one himself. I don't doubt that his educational level isn't above average. But his requirements of forced stupidity just to be a Bible alone evangelical means he's an idiot.
God gave you a brain. You know in your mind that dinosaurs lived millions of yrs ago. Yet, you make a concourse decision to be dumb in order to hold on to the false doctrine of Sola Scripture and attempt to navigate your own way through Christianity.
Fundies absolutely embarrass all of Christianity with their forced ignorance and it sucks for the rest of us when we try to convert atheist and other non Christians, because they put us in your category.

“GOD SO LOVED US”

Since: Aug 08

He Gave His SON,JESUS Christ

#479081 Sep 29, 2013
Seraphima wrote:
http://theorthodoxchurch.info/ blog/news/2013/09/a-global-sla ughter-of-christians-but-ameri cas-churches-stay-silent/
GOD HELP US,ALL ...every Christian should see this as personal .

Our Gov is,silent in the Sudan ..Darfur ...

http://www.aish.com/ci/s/52292422.html...

The second half talks about why 're our Pres

http://www.aish.com/ci/s/48918992.html...

Who is,speaking out here ??

Samaritans,Purse has been there a long time .

No this horror ...we should say as,do he JEWS NRVER AGAIN..GOD BLESS THEM
Clay

Saint Paul, MN

#479082 Sep 29, 2013
Husker Du wrote:
<quoted text>If you think being called a liar is hurtful , then you shouldn't call us liars, right? You know Christ didn't come for the saved, but for the sinner. Please answer the question I posted to you.
I remember Husker du when I was growing up. It was a punk band from Saint Paul. Is that who your named after? I'm a huge punk fan and I'm certain I saw them play one time. Maybe '89 when I was 15?
ReginaM

Bloomfield, NJ

#479083 Sep 29, 2013
marge wrote:
<quoted text>
hey Regina please settle down, no one is without blame here so forgive and move forward with love already. Blessings
You're right, Marge. Thank you.

“GOD SO LOVED US”

Since: Aug 08

He Gave His SON,JESUS Christ

#479084 Sep 29, 2013
HEAVENLY FATHER .

WE commend the souks of these and ALL MARTYRS for your Son to your keeping

No matter their denomination..

And pray Your Hand will protection others who love you

We know this is fulfillment of prophecy ..But it saddens us

Help us to realize ALL EH O PROFESS YOU AS SAVIUIR AND LORD. ARE YOUR BELOVED...And please,ease the bad feelings,between us that I know,...SADDen YOU ..

IN the bug picture these martyrs should be an example of FAITH..present in was,ChRistian heart

In Jesus,name ..AMEN

In Jesus,

“GOD SO LOVED US”

Since: Aug 08

He Gave His SON,JESUS Christ

#479085 Sep 29, 2013
Husker Du wrote:
<quoted text>If you think being called a liar is hurtful , then you shouldn't call us liars, right? You know Christ didn't come for the saved, but for the sinner. Please answer the question I posted to you.
Umm.You asked why I was Here ..I.answered why I CAME BACK HERE ..
Concerned in Brasil

Aberdeen, UK

#479086 Sep 29, 2013
hojo wrote:
<quoted text>
WRONG! The title indicates IT IS a Catholic Forum that Protestants, agnostics and atheists are on here for ONE PURPOSE--and ONE PURPOSE ONLY!!!!! To attack the Faith and Salvation in Jesus Christ, of Catholic Christians, the Doctrine/teachings of the Catholic Faith, and the Catholic Church itself...... If the title of this forum said
Protestant "bible only" Churches are the only true churches", you wouldn't find ONE Catholic on here! WHY?? Because we (as Catholics) wouldn't waste our time, FULLY KNOWING that there is no biblical or historical truth to back up this statement!!...I/we as Catholics have believed, followed,worshipped and adhered to the TRUTH of Jesus Christ ever since Our Lord established, formed and intiated HIS ONE TRUE UNIVERSAL CHURCH in Matthew 16:13-21 over 2000 years ago. We don't need to "seek out" a Protestant forum to discuss, argue or debate ANYTHING!!!---Because there is NOTHING to debate, NOTHING to discuss and NOTHING to argue over. The TRUTH of the TRUE GOSPEL of Jesus Christ and HIS One True Catholic Church has ALL been established, proven, substantiated, and verified over and over and over again---for centuries!!!
No you are wrong
From the top of the Web page you will find.

Topix > Roman Catholic Church > Forums & Polls > Roman Catholic church only true church, says Vatican

Fist indicator is Topix
A secular run Public forum with many threads of which Religion is one of which one is Christianity of which this thread is in.

It is not run by the RCC nor any officially sponsored Catholic organization. PERIOD

It is no different then going to a Public square in the heart of Chicago and setting up a box and saying RCC not the one true church as Pope Benny says and asking who disagrees.

This is not A catholic forum it is a secular forum about the RCC and the official press release from Vatican city in 2007 that was picked up by AP and then CBC.

Like RC and their knowledge of their dogmas you RC's have no clue to that which you assert.

Truth Matters you don't post any.
Dust Storm

Minneapolis, MN

#479088 Sep 29, 2013
Clay wrote:
<quoted text>
You were not taught by the nuns that the earth was 5,000 yrs old. I had nuns too. They were old and likely were around when you went to grade school. In 7th grade science I learned about dinosaurs being millions of yrs old.
Concerned in Brazil enjoys calling everyone an idiot because he's one himself. I don't doubt that his educational level isn't above average. But his requirements of forced stupidity just to be a Bible alone evangelical means he's an idiot.
God gave you a brain. You know in your mind that dinosaurs lived millions of yrs ago. Yet, you make a concourse decision to be dumb in order to hold on to the false doctrine of Sola Scripture and attempt to navigate your own way through Christianity.
Fundies absolutely embarrass all of Christianity with their forced ignorance and it sucks for the rest of us when we try to convert atheist and other non Christians, because they put us in your category.
Clay, it would be hard to believe her first language is English. I do believe that she in a nominal way was helped tremendously in her youth, but she did lack a deep understanding. It is good to see a renewal of deeper teaching in the church. It only takes one generation to become lax and knowledge of the truth dissipates. It happened in Israel as well. The church of Ephesus in Revelation no longer exists. What Rose doesnt understand is that she is indirectly calling Catholics liars by demanding the church changed her perceptions and assigning infallibility to theologium.

We all know that Limbo was not a dogma, but she insists that the church changed that as an infallbable teaching. G.K. Chesterton one of the greatest intellectuals known to the world when he crushed Clarence Darrow in debate long before Rose was born did not insist the church demands a literal 6 days or that Genesis be literal. He understood and had a much more intellectual and deeper understing of the churches position. The church is not a science or history book. So when Rose demands that we changed her flawed perceptions. Chesterton is just one glaring example of how rigid and flawed her position is. It would seem a waste of time though. Rather than learn or even try to understand or accept any explanation one must conclude that all are liars except her as sad as that is. She only seeks that which will further her view not truly try to understand another position but assign new perceptions and make false statements and claim everyone bears false witness against her. She is just responding with emotion rather than intellect. I doubt she will ever go to catholic answers as her propensity has been to garner anti-catholic pamphlets and make her own conclusions with no balance. Pray for her, because I think in her heart she doesnt really mean harm, but anger takes over and pushes to further seperation and darkness.

This article was given to me from a Jewish friend if you are interested.

ABSTRACT: For the past century, the Biblical Creation story has come under considerable scrutiny and derision by the scientific community. Much of the controversy centers around the length of the Biblical Creation Day. While many Fundamentalist Christians insist that a Creation Day must span the traditional twenty-four hours, mainstream science has determined that the age of the Earth is over 4.5 billion years old. Consequently, for the Bible and science to be reconciled, a Creation Day would have to span longer periods of time. This article will demonstrate that long Creation Days are not only possible but with a clearer understanding of the arguments the Biblical text virtually mandates them.
http://thebibleandscience.webs.com/articles/c...

“GOD SO LOVED US”

Since: Aug 08

He Gave His SON,JESUS Christ

#479089 Sep 29, 2013
Husker Du wrote:
<quoted text>In your way, you called Catholics liars and wrong. You have called me many terrible names and said I was a stalker. You threatened me with pulling up posts from another thread. You have learned well from the pro aborts. In fact you act much like them.


You have stalked me ..bringing posts,from another thread Here ..

Show me where I EVER INSULTED YOU OR YOUR FAMILY ..

I did not threaten anything ..I said,I could prove what I said .because I don't lie .Did I ??? Lost your nasty comments ..No

I choose not to post bad things here ..this is a Christian forum..

Please stop THIS.

And For the very last TIME. Leave me alone ..I'll do the same ..I pray to forgive you as this nonsense is nit good for my soul.

I have proven I have Been on Topix ..I've said What was taught me ...

Please lady ..agree to disagree and move on .

I cannot do anything else ..except pray for Peace here .

Have a nice life ..And God bless

“GOD SO LOVED US”

Since: Aug 08

He Gave His SON,JESUS Christ

#479090 Sep 29, 2013
Dust Storm wrote:
<quoted text>
I'm not posting about your Church ..BELUEVE what you want .And it wasn't you ..
Yes you are and arrogantly and sarcasitcly as you admitted. You also did put me as saying you were never a Catholic. I do question that you ever had a deep understanding. I believe you went through the motions and with hojo you indicated this. When you were wandering did you seek, study and delve deeper into the church for answers or did you wander? You wandered as you said.
I still don't get AnyoneAnyone would lie,on it .
We do too, yet it happens alot along with numerous sock pucppets.
The site I posted Baltimore CATECHISM 1 No you posted a site where anyone can contribute. I said you probably had the baltimore catechism which can be found with scriptural reference.
Now,..while I'm content ..You all keep your history as you like ...
O DO not like being called a,liar because Your Church taught differently hernia was a child ..it's bearing false witness..
It didn't teach differently in the way in which you portray. Limbo was theologium it was not a Dogma that anyone was required to believe. I do suggest you dont know the difference between Dogma, Doctrine, Disoiplines, Holy Traditon vs tradition and theologium. You have demonstrated that.
Did the Nuns tell you how old the earth was? Did the Nuns tell you that you had to believe 6 days meant 6 24hr. periods? Did the Nuns explain to you the process of how the earth was created or did they teach you the story of Genesis and said you had to literally interpret every word? Did they say the Pope saves you not Jesus? No Did they tell you how the books of the bible were determined and when? Did you read the early Fathers and the history of the church? Did you seek deeper knwoledge and understanding? Did the Nuns explain to you the other rites of the church or did you even know or do you now know they exist? Did you know about the Russian Orthodox? Did you know and understand what an indulgence is. Do you know all about the Inquistion, to whom it applied and why? Your comments show not at all. Do you know what Pope means? Do you know the role in history, the biblical basis, the massive documentation. Do you know what infalliblity entails by the churches definition? Your comments show you do not and never did. So while you may have been a Catholic you were a nominal one at best who lacked deeper knwoledge and understanding including the mass itself. Your flawed perceptions are not reality yet you insist we must believe that you are the expert on all the church tuaght changing infallible stuff all the time. lol Give it a rest Rose. The correct title of the Orthodox is Russian Orthodox. All Orthodox are Russian Orthodox and All Protestants are Lutherans since you insist the church is just Roman Catholic the correct title. Rather than insisting what we always believed and changed it you could perhaps humble yourself ever so slightly and accept some reality rather than demand we believe you have final say on what the church taught from your flawed perceptions, misiunderstandings and lack of depth.
in my state,we took diocesan exams ..got straight As in religion .
It's my history ..I loved the nubs who helped raise Me..
One if hose ladies even says I'm lying about how long I've been on Topix .
Again. I don't lie...And it's hurtful to be called one .
You all believe as you like ..But I darn well know what the RCC taught in the fifties .
Why is it sarcastic to assert what I KNOW TO BE TRUE ..
I don't get it ..You HAVR the same commandments,we do ..yet your people,..not all ..attack on he bad is I'm lying ..I'm not
Find an old priest and ask ..it your grandparents ..before bearing false witness ...not you ..
I know,what I learned ..as a young person...believe as you like .

God knows I'm not lying ..
Gods R Delusions

Orlando, FL

#479091 Sep 29, 2013
Clay wrote:
<quoted text>
You're awfully concerned about what we Catholics believe, why is that? I have to assume you're atheist with a name like yours, so what's your motive? God isn't real, right? Why are you trying to take down something that isn't real??
This is a message board. I promote reason and logic over mysticism and superstition.

Obviously, I do so in a manner that troubles you.

Good. Truth is better for society than mysticism.

“GOD SO LOVED US”

Since: Aug 08

He Gave His SON,JESUS Christ

#479092 Sep 29, 2013
Clay wrote:
<quoted text>
You were not taught by the nuns that the earth was 5,000 yrs old. I had nuns too. They were old and likely were around when you went to grade school. In 7th grade science I learned about dinosaurs being millions of yrs old.
Concerned in Brazil enjoys calling everyone an idiot because he's one himself. I don't doubt that his educational level isn't above average. But his requirements of forced stupidity just to be a Bible alone evangelical means he's an idiot.
God gave you a brain. You know in your mind that dinosaurs lived millions of yrs ago. Yet, you make a concourse decision to be dumb in order to hold on to the false doctrine of Sola Scripture and attempt to navigate your own way through Christianity.
Fundies absolutely embarrass all of Christianity with their forced ignorance and it sucks for the rest of us when we try to convert atheist and other non Christians, because they put us in your category.
I'm talking religion
Never learned about he afraid dinosaurs
I never heard about evolution as a child .
IT WAS THE FIFTIES...a the time the,secularists were not everywhere trying o disprove God ..I font think even public schools taught it ..But on that not sure
I learned God created the earth in six days,..the morning and he evenin
Etc .
I had no reason to doubt any of this..
THE NUNS who taught me were old when I was,8. I doubt they were around when you were in school .
And kin d of each decade will teach whatever
the,CHURCH TELLs THEM TO
why on earth is it so important to tell me what I did or did not learn
Why is it such a big deal hat your Church changed what it taught ..IT DID .
we also sang Latin ..had mass in. Latin ..That changed too ....so what
Patriot

Brighton, CO

#479093 Sep 29, 2013
FYI AMERICA - PREPARE

Truckers Convoy to D.C. Oct. 11-13

The strike, the report said, will be coordinated with an invasion of Washington.

“The protest calls for truckers to make their way to Washington, D.C., in a massive convoy in an effort to call attention to, among other things, the Benghazi cover-up, the recent attack which killed 25 members of Seal Team 6, ever rising fuel prices, and claims that 'President' Obama has engaged in treasonous crimes.”

One advocate wrote: The American People are bleeding out with no relief in sight. It is time to change the news. Let us show our elected officials that we are 100 percent fed up with corruption and the blatant disregard of the Constitution that they swore to Uphold.

Blog author Mac Slavo noted:“The corruption and need for real change in America’s government has transcended political lines. If the hundreds of thousands of truckers across America who keep our delivery systems running efficiently were to join together and stop hauling freight for even a week, the impact would be devastating and could not be ignored. There’d be no food on the shelves, no fuel at our gas stations, and no medical supplies at our pharmacies and hospitals...

Support these truckers and America - if you own a business, close the doors for those 3 days, do not shop, travel or buy gas on those 3 days unless absolutely necessary. GOD Bless!

http://www.wnd.com/2013/09/now-truckers-convo...

http://tenthamendmentcenter.com/category/foun...

---

P.S.

'The EPA Takes an Ax to Self-Sufficiency: Most Wood Burning Stoves Will Soon Be Illegal

September 28, 2013

http://www.activistpost.com/2013/09/the-epa-t...

- AND were you Aware that the EPA operates Illegally within Our country?(Created by 'tptb' to help 'regulate' Freedom out of existence.)

http://www.libertyroundtable.com/2011/02/04/e...

***You might also find this interesting:

Groups Promoting A Globalist
Anti-American Satanic Agenda

http://www.theforbiddenknowledge.com/hardtrut...

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Pope Benedict XVI Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Pope Francis wades into transgender debate, lam... Wed South Knox Hombre 2
News United House of Prayer for All People: Bishop's... (Apr '08) Aug 22 Married in 10,204
News Pope Francis' Remarks Disappoint Gay and Transg... Aug 4 Leon 2
News The Pope s War Aug 2 The Proclaimer 1
News Franklin Graham rebuts pope on Islam: - This is... Aug 1 Bob 1
News Pope Francis: 'Trump is not Christian' (Feb '16) Jul '16 make Donald Drump... 47
News Holding the left responsible (Sep '15) Jul '16 Crusader 4
More from around the web