Roman Catholic church only true churc...

Roman Catholic church only true church, says Vatican

There are 653608 comments on the CBC News story from Jul 10, 2007, titled Roman Catholic church only true church, says Vatican. In it, CBC News reports that:

The VaticanA issued a document Tuesday restatingA its belief that the Roman Catholic Church is the only true church of Jesus Christ.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at CBC News.

Since: Feb 12

Location hidden

#476141 Sep 12, 2013
Dust Storm wrote:
<quoted text>
The standard response to the facts. Now post youtube links and make jokes and play your games with insults and pretend you are not a hypocrite. You, You You Constante-ist. lol I think I got the Gif spelling right?
I think being saved means you attack Catholics. Long before they came Orthodox sites that were on par were posted to refute accusations. I guess it was done to attack you so you would actually make a stand for your faith other than attacking Catholics on every issue even if its from your church. It is obvious you both go to great lengths to attack Catholics. Obvious to everyone but you, thus the Chesterton quote on hypcorisy was very suitable.
What was that about Indians in some forest again? They arent really Christians right? lol I couldnt believe the bigotry coming from you. Well, actually I could.
I NEVER SAID INDIANS IN A FOREST WERE NOT CATHOLIC.What I said was what do a bunch of uneducated Indians in a jungle know about the catholic faith(.Something like that) I never said they weren't Christians.How deep would they understand the faith? That's what I meant
And you are one of the people our priest was talking about when he mention about argueing with someone.If you want to remain in sin gooooo right ahead....I am Done with you....

Since: Feb 12

Location hidden

#476142 Sep 12, 2013
correction...christians
Dust Storm

Minneapolis, MN

#476143 Sep 12, 2013
Seraphima wrote:
<quoted text>You need anger management...your personal attacks are unbecoming.Would you behave this way if your priest was here?
Its really funny that you think I am upset. I have never received a response of anything that resembled something of substance from either of you. Here is the post again.

The standard response to the facts. Now post youtube links and make jokes and play your games with insults and pretend you are not a hypocrite. You, You You Constante-ist. lol I think I got the Gif spelling right?

I think being saved means you attack Catholics. Long before they came Orthodox sites that were on par were posted to refute accusations. I guess it was done to attack you so you would actually make a stand for your faith other than attacking Catholics on every issue even if its from your church. It is obvious you both go to great lengths to attack Catholics. Obvious to everyone but you, thus the Chesterton quote on hypcorisy was very suitable.

What was that about Indians in some forest again? They arent really Christians right? lol I couldnt believe the bigotry coming from you. Well, actually I could.

Your hypcrisy is not a personal attack it is a fact. I didn't change anything when a priest was here. However, Herme did make accusations against him and then Apologized for his typical knee jerk reaction scholarship. Father Dye 'The Filthy Drunk" who gratiously accepted the title from Preston asked what was so anti-orthodox.

Now what are you doing right now? Are you sick? Are you an idol and Mary worhsipper? Are you a Constanteist? If you have something intelligent to say then do so. I have to work so I dont have time for your nonsense. If you have something of value to say let me know when I am around.
Dust Storm

Minneapolis, MN

#476144 Sep 12, 2013
Seraphima wrote:
<quoted text>I NEVER SAID INDIANS IN A FOREST WERE NOT CATHOLIC.What I said was what do a bunch of uneducated Indians in a jungle know about the catholic faith(.Something like that) I never said they weren't Christians.How deep would they understand the faith? That's what I meant
And you are one of the people our priest was talking about when he mention about argueing with someone.If you want to remain in sin gooooo right ahead....I am Done with you....
Now why on earth would a bunch of uneducated Indians in a jungle accept the faith if they didnt know anything about it? Isnt the Good News for the whole world? If they dont know anything about the faith then does that mean they arent really Christians or do I go with the many Protestants in here who say Catholics arent really Christians and are going to hell?

Now why did you say that about Indians in a Jungle? Are they not really Catholic then? Which Jungles are we talking about here and are there no signs of intelligent life form there? If they become Protestant or Orthodox then what would they know? lol Im going to bed. You can keep digging your rabbit holes.

Since: Dec 11

Location hidden

#476145 Sep 12, 2013
Dust Storm wrote:
<quoted text>
Now why on earth would a bunch of uneducated Indians in a jungle accept the faith if they didnt know anything about it? Isnt the Good News for the whole world? If they dont know anything about the faith then does that mean they arent really Christians or do I go with the many Protestants in here who say Catholics arent really Christians and are going to hell?
Now why did you say that about Indians in a Jungle? Are they not really Catholic then? Which Jungles are we talking about here and are there no signs of intelligent life form there? If they become Protestant or Orthodox then what would they know? lol Im going to bed. You can keep digging your rabbit holes.
History: When the Catholic Church took in the Barbarians most of them were Arians, and others kept their mythic Gods and attached Catholicism.Rose's point is correct. Now run to your Catholic site and look for a denial or minimization of this piece of history.

Since: Feb 12

Location hidden

#476146 Sep 12, 2013
Dust Storm wrote:
<quoted text>
Its really funny that you think I am upset. I have never received a response of anything that resembled something of substance from either of you. Here is the post again.
The standard response to the facts. Now post youtube links and make jokes and play your games with insults and pretend you are not a hypocrite. You, You You Constante-ist. lol I think I got the Gif spelling right?
I think being saved means you attack Catholics. Long before they came Orthodox sites that were on par were posted to refute accusations. I guess it was done to attack you so you would actually make a stand for your faith other than attacking Catholics on every issue even if its from your church. It is obvious you both go to great lengths to attack Catholics. Obvious to everyone but you, thus the Chesterton quote on hypcorisy was very suitable.
What was that about Indians in some forest again? They arent really Christians right? lol I couldnt believe the bigotry coming from you. Well, actually I could.
Your hypcrisy is not a personal attack it is a fact. I didn't change anything when a priest was here. However, Herme did make accusations against him and then Apologized for his typical knee jerk reaction scholarship. Father Dye 'The Filthy Drunk" who gratiously accepted the title from Preston asked what was so ant time for myi-orthodox.
Now what are you doing right now? Are you sick? Are you an idol and Mary worhsipper? Are you a Constanteist? If you have something intelligent to say then do so. I have to work so I dont have time for your nonsense. If you have something of value to say let me know when I am around.
I have nothing to say to you! I have nothing of value for you and your gifted brain. You make no sense to a simple person as myself.If indeed you don't have time for my nonsence THAN DONT RESPOND TO ME. Its that simple so stop lying!You thrive on the thrill of the kill.

Since: Feb 12

Location hidden

#476147 Sep 12, 2013
Dust Storm wrote:
<quoted text>
Now why on earth would a bunch of uneducated Indians in a jungle accept the faith if they didnt know anything about it? Isnt the Good News for the whole world? If they dont know anything about the faith then does that mean they arent really Christians or do I go with the many Protestants in here who say Catholics arent really Christians and are going to hell?
Now why did you say that about Indians in a Jungle? Are they not really Catholic then? Which Jungles are we talking about here and are there no signs of intelligent life form there? If they become Protestant or Orthodox then what would they know? lol Im going to bed. You can keep digging your rabbit holes.
okie dokie nite nite Mr.Mean Jeans

Since: Jun 10

Location hidden

#476148 Sep 12, 2013
Where are the catlicks!!!!!????

The Vatican is ready to open a discussion about whether Catholic priests should be required to remain celibate, the Vatican's newly appointed secretary of state said in an interview with a Venezuelan newspaper.

Question to catlicks....If that requirement is supported by Scripture, and the Word of God does not change, how, then, can they make a change in this requirement and claim it is also supported by Scripture????!!!!

Since: Feb 12

Location hidden

#476149 Sep 12, 2013
Dust Storm wrote:
<quoted text>
Now why on earth would a bunch of uneducated Indians in a jungle accept the faith if they didnt know anything about it? Isnt the Good News for the whole world? If they dont know anything about the faith then does that mean they arent really Christians or do I go with the many Protestants in here who say Catholics arent really Christians and are going to hell?
Now why did you say that about Indians in a Jungle? Are they not really Catholic then? Which Jungles are we talking about here and are there no signs of intelligent life form there? If they become Protestant or Orthodox then what would they know? lol Im going to bed. You can keep digging your rabbit holes.
The problem here is that your over thinking....its really simple to understand my point.

Since: Dec 11

Location hidden

#476150 Sep 12, 2013
Dust Storm wrote:
<quoted text>
Now why on earth would a bunch of uneducated Indians in a jungle accept the faith if they didnt know anything about it? Isnt the Good News for the whole world? If they dont know anything about the faith then does that mean they arent really Christians or do I go with the many Protestants in here who say Catholics arent really Christians and are going to hell?
Now why did you say that about Indians in a Jungle? Are they not really Catholic then? Which Jungles are we talking about here and are there no signs of intelligent life form there? If they become Protestant or Orthodox then what would they know? lol Im going to bed. You can keep digging your rabbit holes.
----------
Isnt it wonderful that you would have such passion defending "Indians in the Jungle" but not be able to carry out one civil dialogue with another person in Topix.

Since: Feb 12

Location hidden

#476151 Sep 12, 2013
Nickie Honey...can you take me to the vets for my shots.I am due....rufffff
hojo

Minneapolis, MN

#476152 Sep 13, 2013
Dust Storm wrote:
<quoted text>
I think being saved means you attack Catholics.
As a former bible only Protestant, it is obvious that "fundies" use the expressive egostistical (lingo), "I am saved", do so with the sole intent on attacking the faith of Catholics!---Ha, Ha, I'M SAVED AND YOU'RE NOT!!....It, again, only proves that Protestant fundamentalism CANNOT EXIST on its own doctrine of belief, WITHOUT
attacking, judging and condemning the TRUTH of the TRUE GOSPEL of Jesus Christ and HIS One True Apostolic Catholic Church!!
Clay

Detroit, MI

#476153 Sep 13, 2013
OldJG wrote:
<quoted text>
You are unteachable and ignorant. You quote Scripture and know absolutely nothing about it. Nothing!
James 5:14 has nothing to do with extreme unction
You believe this is speaking of purgatory? You have no clue!
Revelation 21:27, "But nothing unclean will ever enter it, nor anyone who does what is detestable or false, but only those who are written in the Lamb’s book of life."
"But nothing unclean will ever enter it, nor anyone who does what is detestable or false," This is speaking of the unsaved. Yes, the unsaved WILL NOT enter heaven. But only those written in the Lamb's book of life, those saved and have professed Jesus as their Lord and Savior, will enter into heaven. Totally clean and washed in the blood of the Lamb.
You said, quote, "What happens if we are not 'clean enough' to go straight to Heaven and be in the presence of God, but are not filthy enough to go to Hell? 1cor 3:15 Paul says, "he will suffer loss, though he himself will be saved, but ONLY AS THROUGH THE FIRE"." End quote.
You knowledge of Scripture is the pinnacle of stupidity. If you have professed Jesus as Lord and Savior and have been washed in the blood of Lamb you are forever clean and will enter heaven. In the future before you expose your ignorance do yourself a favor, find a true Christian, go over the Scripture and educate yourself before you place your foot in your mouth. No doubt you suffer from hoof and mouth disease.
You calling someone ignorant, is like a poop telling a vomit he stinks.

I thought you said scripture interprets itself?
So what are you doing interpreting it?

James 5:14 describes last rites.+ I gave you evidence of how a Church father viewed it in 250 AD. Did Christianity get corrupted at that point vs Constantine 100 yrs later??

Rev 21: 27 describes Heaven, not Purgatory. Yes we are washed clean by Christ, but we still have accountability. Those in Purgatory will be in Heaven, not hell. They first need to be washed but only through the fire as Paul describes in Cor 3:15.

I gave you scripture and you have no business telling me I'm wrong. You're not an authority on our sacred scripture.
1stHALFofTRIB

AOL

#476154 Sep 13, 2013
.

BIBLE's "Silence in Heaven" ID's RAPTURE timing >



.

Since: Feb 12

Location hidden

#476155 Sep 13, 2013
hojo wrote:
<quoted text>
As a former bible only Protestant, it is obvious that "fundies" use the expressive egostistical (lingo), "I am saved", do so with the sole intent on attacking the faith of Catholics!---Ha, Ha, I'M SAVED AND YOU'RE NOT!!....It, again, only proves that Protestant fundamentalism CANNOT EXIST on its own doctrine of belief, WITHOUT
attacking, judging and condemning the TRUTH of the TRUE GOSPEL of Jesus Christ and HIS One True Apostolic Catholic Church!!
But isn't that the same thing that your doing?
hojo

Minneapolis, MN

#476156 Sep 13, 2013
Seraphima wrote:
<quoted text>But isn't that the same thing that your doing?
Not at all!! The Catholic Doctrine of Faith can and has always been "grounded,and supported, standing on its own TRUTH by over 2000 years of the TRUTH of the TRUE interpretation of the bible, the authenticated proven TRUTH of TRUE Church History and the TRUE SPOKEN words of Jesus Christ HIMSELF in Matthew 16:13-21.... The Catholic Church and its Doctrine of Faith, doesn't need to prove ANYTHING because it has already been proven over and over and over again as THE TRUTH!!!....Protestant denominations, especially bible only beliefs ALL are ALWAYS having to "prove something" because none of what they believe has ANY biblical or historical proof to back up what they believe!!!
Clay

Detroit, MI

#476157 Sep 13, 2013
Seraphima wrote:
<quoted text>Well Clay, that part of you that thinks that nick and I were "not prepared to learn the Biblical and the historical thruths of the catholic faith: particularly the Papacy" IS WRONG!!!Question for you.....do you enjoy getting little digs and insults in when ever you can to justify always wanting to be correct? You know as well as I know that the Orthodox views of church history is NOT THE SAME AS YOUR VIEW....now, I could take this as an insult or I can take this as you don't know what your talking about. Which is it?? Were insecure in our faith because we don't know the catholic church history????? are you serious ?? That's a stupid remark!
My intention wasn't to insult you. You not knowing about the CC isn't a reflection of lack of education. I'm Catholic and I still do not understand everything about the Church (nor do I need to)

I just said what I said because most people are surprised when they hear the Catholic side of the story. They react differently.
All I know is that you and Herm were different last year. You were really warm towards Catholicism. Not focused on the many similarities we have - which far outnumbers the non similarities. Now you two seem to focus on the negatives, even making minor differences seem worse than they actually are.
Clay

Detroit, MI

#476158 Sep 13, 2013
@Sera and Herm....
I'm also puzzled why you two never stand up for truth when the fundies attack us. You believe in the Eucharist. You believe in Confession to a Priest. You believe in Baptism with water.
Yet you sit idle why they mock the Eucharist? They are in reality, mocking Jesus Christ who said, "This is my body". Therefore that is a call for you to stand up for the Lord.
I know that no Catholic on this thread would ever stay silent if these guy poke fun at YOUR belief in the Eucharist.
Saban fan

Decatur, AL

#476159 Sep 13, 2013
Clay wrote:
@Sera and Herm....
I'm also puzzled why you two never stand up for truth when the fundies attack us. You believe in the Eucharist. You believe in Confession to a Priest. You believe in Baptism with water.
Yet you sit idle why they mock the Eucharist? They are in reality, mocking Jesus Christ who said, "This is my body". Therefore that is a call for you to stand up for the Lord.
I know that no Catholic on this thread would ever stay silent if these guy poke fun at YOUR belief in the Eucharist.
Just reminding you again, Christians are Priests, Clay. There is no such thing in the scriptures as the 'middle-man' priests your denomination has created through its man-made doctrine. Apostacy is the rule of your denomination, Clay. It does not resemble the church of the 1st century that Jesus died for and created. Your denomination is a "mockery" of the 1st Century church.

Since: Dec 11

Location hidden

#476160 Sep 13, 2013
Clay wrote:
@Sera and Herm....
I'm also puzzled why you two never stand up for truth when the fundies attack us. You believe in the Eucharist. You believe in Confession to a Priest. You believe in Baptism with water.
Yet you sit idle why they mock the Eucharist? They are in reality, mocking Jesus Christ who said, "This is my body". Therefore that is a call for you to stand up for the Lord.
I know that no Catholic on this thread would ever stay silent if these guy poke fun at YOUR belief in the Eucharist.
Again you are "confused". I have explained this many times.I have seen zero zero zero persons change their view because they dialoged here with someone with different views.Sorry, but I dont see the purpose of arguing the same points with people for 7 years with no result.Especially blasting in someone's face for 7 years how you are the "True Church".Noone is sticking up for Christ by acting like a jerk and verbally abusing people here.A Catholic calling someone a hypocrite and an idiot etc etc and strutting with pride has nothing to do with defending the Holy Eucharist.It has to do with saying I am the best, my team is the best- in other words pride and ego.I try to go beyond dogma to the heart. I try to connect with people heart to heart.Christ is in the heart.I have never once betrayed Orthodoxy here. People know what I believe.Christ is in the heart. You want to be a defender of Christ. Conduct Spiritual Warfare within yourself. Believe me , there is enough in all of us to battle.Its a lot harder than strutting around here.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Pope Benedict XVI Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News United House of Prayer for All People: Bishop's... (Apr '08) Mon Married in 10,204
News Pope Francis wades into transgender debate, lam... Aug 17 TerriB1 1
News Pope Francis' Remarks Disappoint Gay and Transg... Aug 4 Leon 2
News The Pope s War Aug 2 The Proclaimer 1
News Franklin Graham rebuts pope on Islam: - This is... Aug 1 Bob 1
News Pope Francis: 'Trump is not Christian' (Feb '16) Jul '16 make Donald Drump... 47
News Holding the left responsible (Sep '15) Jul '16 Crusader 4
More from around the web