Clay says.....<quoted text>
Actually, it was a very good question I asked. And one you can't answer.
Its reasonable to think Joseph had children from his first marriage. Its also reasonable...that Joseph (being a devout Jew) would not venture into the Holiest of Arks.
Mary gave birth to Jesus- God made manifest. I can't imagine Joseph thinking its ok to procreate with Mary after God already had.
.....Its reasonable to think Joseph had children from his first marriage.
Michael says..Come on Claypool!....Its all SPECULATION! and WISHFUL THINKING! ONLY! because it doesn't jibe with catholic ONLY teachings.
...the bible doesn't say that does it Clay?
....But the bible often mentions her other siblings, St Paul says James was the brother of the Lord, but you don't want to believe that.
Remember your own catholic fathers wrote all this stuff.