Celine Dion vs Mariah Carey vs Whitne...
Sebastian Singapore

Singapore, Singapore

#26 Jan 24, 2007
well im totally agree wit Emily..I mean..why must we compare the three of them..we all know that all three are great singers of our time..no doubt about it that they have done great honours in coloring the music industries..on the other side,we as listeners and fans should support them by not adoring one and despising the other..well if that happens..music wont be healthy and well received in the near future...
the great

Philippines

#27 Jan 27, 2007
Exactly coz the three of them has their on style you cant compare the three of them if they dont do the same style of singing.. so i make this topic close cause this topic is non-sense.. ^_^
Emily

Allentown, PA

#28 Jan 28, 2007
hahahah OK jimmy. I happen to know that because in an interview that I watched Mariah said "whitney and I are good friends" I don't know what could have put it more clearly... Don't start and try a pick a fight over an INTERNET BLOG and then proceed to tell me to get a life.
pedro

Lordelo, Portugal

#29 Jan 28, 2007
well mariah carey has the best voice and that is not even commentable..experts say her voice is a medical wonder she is able to do g7 which is known olny from dolphins but she can also do low notes...and celine shouts louder than whitney and that is far perceptible but i prefer whitneys voice. Mariah could sing any song many different ways she couls whisper, whistle, shout, use low notes do anything she wants. whiteny and celine are much more limited as they´re voice has not half of mariah´s variations and that is proved so why should ppl agree or desagree it is simply the truth acept it or not
Know It All

UK

#30 Jan 29, 2007
I used to really respect Mariah becoz shr had such a great range. But it's all about QUALITY of sound and control - both of which Whitley wins hands down. Mariah needs to present her body first before her voice these days which is sad coz she didn't need to when Vision Of Love came out. Anyone with real talent knows they don't have to succumb to this.
Know It All

UK

#31 Jan 29, 2007
I just read what Pedro above me just wrote. Like i said - it's not just about the volume. If that were that were the case then why not discuss Opera singers? They have the best vocal ranges...but I wouldn't say they sound better!
Jigged

Amsterdam, Netherlands

#32 Jan 30, 2007
I think all 3 of them have pretty amazing voices and they are certainly in a league of their own when it comes to vocal prowess. But in terms of versatility Mariah's got the other 2 beat. Her voice has so much more range and she's able to wrap it around any style she chooses, be it AC, gospel, pop, RnB, dance and even jazz music. She can probably sing anything and still make it sound good!
Marioyoshi

Mandaluyong, Philippines

#34 Feb 3, 2007
celine is the top female grosser of all time sorry for mariah and whitney
Marioyoshi

Mandaluyong, Philippines

#33 Feb 3, 2007
Celine Dion has a vocal range of 20 sec
her highest chest note is g5 her highest song is fly. she is called as the queen of love song, she is known to be the ultimate diva (said the Mottola chairman of Sony music) Celine dion is the only diva who can sing many dialects ang languages and take note of this SHE IS THE TOP FEMALE GROSSER OF ALL TIME selling 200 million albums and still counting.mariah has only 80 million sorry to tell...

celine will go on and can sank mariah and even whitney
NIa

United States

#35 Feb 3, 2007
Marioyoshi wrote:
Celine Dion has a vocal range of 20 sec
her highest chest note is g5 her highest song is fly. she is called as the queen of love song, she is known to be the ultimate diva (said the Mottola chairman of Sony music) Celine dion is the only diva who can sing many dialects ang languages and take note of this SHE IS THE TOP FEMALE GROSSER OF ALL TIME selling 200 million albums and still counting.mariah has only 80 million sorry to tell...
celine will go on and can sank mariah and even whitney
stop lying,,,,,madonna is the best selling female ever.
grant russell

South Molton, UK

#36 Feb 4, 2007
i think that whitney is the best singer out of them all her vocal notes are spot on when mariah just screams i would say that celine is 2nd best she can hold a note justa s well but whitneys voica stands out the most she is fabulous
steven

South Molton, UK

#37 Feb 4, 2007
whitneys voice is spetacular wow so is celine dions but i would also have to say mariah is also quite good but not as good as whitney everyone i know says she the best singer in the world even most of the guys i know say shes got to be the worlds best singer
LaDonna06

Las Vegas, NV

#38 Feb 8, 2007
Whitney is better no question. Her voice is so powerful and strong. She can hold notes longer than mariah, mariah can just hit the high notes. Not to say mariah can't hold notes, but whitney was just one of a kind
ISRAEL

AOL

#39 Feb 8, 2007
celine dion, mariah carey, whitney houston? ok? talk about depression. this is like music to listen to to fall asleep.
Steven

UK

#40 Feb 13, 2007
Your all mad! Celine dion is much better now, maybe whitney was once great but she has been so screwed up on drugs that now she is totally rubbish. Celine dion not only has had more international sales than mariah, she is a headliner in vegas! and sounds just as amazing live, plus she can sing in english french spanish and italian, having recieved over ten grammy awards, plus she seems the nicest of them all, the best plus for mariah is her looks and whilst her range is fab celine can sing much more diverse songs see 'you and i''aint gunna look the other way''all by myself''at last''drive all night''je t'aime encore' these cover ballad, jazz, pop, rock, pop/rock, love, foreign languages, she is by far the greatest serenader of all time so please give this a rest! there is no question!
MCFAN4EVA

Lansdale, PA

#41 Feb 16, 2007
JUST PUT IT LIKE THGIS MARIAH WILL ALWAYS BE THE GREATEST AND THATS FINAL!!!!!1
Dylan

Calgary, Canada

#42 Feb 16, 2007
I agree with many of the comments here and disagree with a few too. If we are judging right now in this year, I have to say that Celine Dion is the best vocalist in modern time. If we go back a decade, then i think that Whitney beats Celine. Celine Dion is the best female singer in the world right now.

RIGHT NOW (2000-2007):
1. Celine Dion
2. Mariah Carey
3. Whitney Houston

BACK THEN (1990-1999):
1. Whitney Houston
2. Celine Dion
3. Mariah Carey

Right now, Celine has songs like "I Surrender" that show amazing range and a powerful voice. Back then, her song "All By Myself" mesmerized everybody who has listened to it! And Whitney Houston has sung songs like, "I Will Always Love You" and "I hAve Nothing" that show SUCH POWER!! Now, she has ruined her voice with drugs. Not a good path she has chosen. And finally, Mariah's songs like "Hero" and "We Belong Together" that show soul and a tender voice. They are all amazing singers.

Many other good singers include, Barbara Streisand, Arethra Franklin, Toni Braxton, Christina Aguilera, Tina Turner, Carola, Leona Lewis, Reigne Velasquez and MANY MORE!
ExoticSarah Fan

Roswell, GA

#43 Feb 19, 2007
My favorite singers ever are Lauryn Hill and Sarah Afshar.
spiritual lover

Makati, Philippines

#44 Feb 20, 2007
Regine velasquez of the Philippines( though she is not as popular as the three singers) beats whitney houston and celine dion when it comes to vocal clarity, melodiousness, endurance and most especially chest voice range. REgine hits stratospheric notes effortlessly and melodiously. REgine's popularity in the Philippines may not even come close to the worldwide fame of Mariah Carey but I put them at par with each other. It would be spectacular to see these two together on stage with Mariah showcasing her phenomenal whistle register and regine, her effortless and melodious belting of ultra-high notes -- in chest!
spiritual lover

Makati, Philippines

#45 Feb 20, 2007
hi

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Mariah Carey Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Nick Cannon Responds To Eminem Diss Track (Aug '09) Dec 5 carpe diem 36
Mariah is Conceited and Arrogant (Sep '07) Nov 22 Ross Trovato96 60
News Lambs Be On Alert: Mariah Carey Is Dropping New... (Apr '17) Aug '17 Atlanta Puppeteer 2
she's a meow mewoow. stay away from bad things ... Jun '17 Some Guy Named Th... 1
News Lionel Richie & Mariah Carey Announce Reschedul... (Mar '17) Mar '17 Not gay 2
News Nick Cannon Is Probably Banging A Nicki Minaj P... (Mar '17) Mar '17 Mustang 2
News Carey's New Year's show is latest mishap in the... (Jan '17) Jan '17 Okie 3
More from around the web