Celine Dion vs Mariah Carey vs Whitne...

Celine Dion vs Mariah Carey vs Whitney Houston.... now this is hard

Posted in the Mariah Carey Forum

First Prev
of 165
Next Last
NIa

United States

#1 Nov 25, 2006
Hate It or Love t ,Whitney is on top.Mariah has a better range but whitney voice is stronger and she takes control over her range much better Mariah has a 5 and whitney has a 4. Listen to their song and you'll see that whitney voice stood out more and she sounds better too.Celine doesnt diserve to be in the catigory with these ladies because she is only a good vocalist but whitney and mariah are GREAT vocalist. Celine probably has a 3 octave range barely and she doesnt go as high or low as the both.She is strong but not as strong as these ladies.She sound like Dusty S. And look like her as well.

Judged:

24

10

5

Reply »
Report Abuse Judge it!
mee

Wakefield, UK

#2 Nov 30, 2006
charlotte church blows them three away
Holyboy27

Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

#3 Nov 30, 2006
urmm please? who doesnt noe that mariah doesnt shout as loud as whitney? listen to when you believe and pay attention towards the end.

fact is, celine can shout louder than anyone eben whitney.

whitney might be better at those upper range beltings but mariah is better at both highs and lows.
butterfly

Quezon City, Philippines

#4 Dec 11, 2006
MARIAH IS PREDOMINANTLY THE GREATEST AMONG WHITNEY AND CELINE!!! LET'S ALL ACCEPT THAT MARIAH CAREY IS THE MOST ADMIRED SINGER EVER!!!THEY CAN'T BEAT MARIAH!!!

Judged:

13

12

7

Reply »
Report Abuse Judge it!
nicho

Indonesia

#5 Dec 11, 2006
mariah just bark!! celine dive forever!!
NIa

United States

#6 Dec 28, 2006
well vh1 said that wh9itney has the best voice even though mtv said mariah then whitney. BEt said that whitney is the second best behind aretha and mariah was number 7.
chris

Norway

#7 Dec 29, 2006
whitney is so much better than mc
George

UK

#8 Dec 29, 2006
Believe it or not Whitney is miles better than Mariah in both vocal range and quality. I would bet my money on Whitney...much reliable. As for Celine, I think it will be unfair to compare her with the other two
NIa

United States

#9 Dec 29, 2006
thats how i feel as well george
NIa

United States

#10 Dec 29, 2006
Holyboy27 wrote:
urmm please? who doesnt noe that mariah doesnt shout as loud as whitney? listen to when you believe and pay attention towards the end.
fact is, celine can shout louder than anyone eben whitney.
whitney might be better at those upper range beltings but mariah is better at both highs and lows.
what are you talkin about. celine dion lack volume and she doesnt get as loud as whitney. Mariah struggles all th time to sing live.
salvaretodo

United States

#11 Dec 29, 2006
NLA,,,,,,you are sooooo wrong. Mariah's voice is 100% better than Whitney or any other current recording artist. Just go to youtube and listen to Mariah and Luther sing Enless Love and then listen to Whitney and her brother sing the exact same song. You will see that Mariah's voice is stronger, more soulful, sings with more ease, and transcens deeper emotion than Whitney. Mariah is simply better. Enough said!

Also listen to when you beleive, in the Climax of the song Whitney comes on first with the AAAAAH there can be miracles. Mariah then also does an AAAAAh right after whitney and although they are hitting the exact same note Mariah again sounds stonger, fuller and with more emotion.

Mariah is the BEST.
NIa

United States

#12 Dec 29, 2006
salvaretodo wrote:
NLA,,,,,,you are sooooo wrong. Mariah's voice is 100% better than Whitney or any other current recording artist. Just go to youtube and listen to Mariah and Luther sing Enless Love and then listen to Whitney and her brother sing the exact same song. You will see that Mariah's voice is stronger, more soulful, sings with more ease, and transcens deeper emotion than Whitney. Mariah is simply better. Enough said!
Also listen to when you beleive, in the Climax of the song Whitney comes on first with the AAAAAH there can be miracles. Mariah then also does an AAAAAh right after whitney and although they are hitting the exact same note Mariah again sounds stonger, fuller and with more emotion.
Mariah is the BEST.
how im i worng.its all matter of opinion.No wrong or no right.When they performed the song whitney stood out and whitney voice waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay strongers then mariah. amriah voice is too airy. Mariah voice isnt strong at all. she can just hit high notes. Same for etta james.
eco818

Schaumburg, IL

#13 Jan 18, 2007
well mariah has way many #1's remeber she has 17
so next time u guys talk shit just remeber all of her #1 whitney is cracked out b**ch and celine is okay
Emily

Allentown, PA

#14 Jan 18, 2007
Whitney and Mariah's singing styles are very different. Whitney can belt it out she has a rock solid voice with muscle and soul behind it. Mariah's voice is def. different in pure sound. They're both great and hopefully Whitney will be getting back into the studio soon, the two of them are good friends I think if their OK with eachother both having one of the best voices of our time then I think we should be okay with it too.
NIa

United States

#15 Jan 19, 2007
patti labelle would blow all of them away to me.
Sareta

Scarborough, Canada

#16 Jan 20, 2007
omg.. this question is really hardd. mariah's like celine and whitney put together.Their all good singers. i personally like mariah better. but whiney and celine have very powerful voices too.
Sareta

Scarborough, Canada

#17 Jan 20, 2007
celinee also has a different style of singing
Emily

Allentown, PA

#21 Jan 21, 2007
the 3 of them have 3 different voices 3 different ranges 3 different styles and sing different kinds of songs.
stop trying to compare 3 people simply based on how they're 3 of the greatest singers/divas of our time. No one will ever win this fight.
NIa

United States

#22 Jan 21, 2007
patti would kill them girls.
JimmyH

Llanfyrnach, UK

#24 Jan 22, 2007
Shuttup Emily!

Whitney and Mariah are 'good friends'.....oh yeah they call each other all the time and in fact Mariah has been to visit her and lended her support through her divorce and rehabilitation...yeah right

You know nothing about whether they are good friends...stop reading the Enquirer

go get a life and a f***....you need it!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 165
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Mariah Carey Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News TV networks try to win over the critics Aug 9 K-DJ 2
News Mariah Carey Lands Role As "Kitty" On "Empire" Aug 9 K-DJ 2
News Mariah leaves bra at home Jul '16 Kelly - DJ 2
News Beyonce's Colorist Rita Hazan Reveals Her Rules... Jul '16 kelly 1
News Nick Cannon on the Most ''F--ked Up'' Part Abou... Jul '16 kelly 2
News Mariah Carey Poses In Nothing But Her Sexy Ling... Jul '16 kelly 2
News 6 Can't-Miss Acts at Essence Music Festival 2016 Jul '16 kelly 2
More from around the web