Can it be Zeppelin without Robert Plant?

[mats]

zeppelin need`s MR Robert plant Yeeeeeeeaaaaaa!

[Soush]

Led Zep without Plant would be unthinkable, replacing John Bonham was only possible by getting his son in to do the job (and well he did it!) but each member is integral to the band and the whole on stage relationship.
Anyway, has nobody learned the lesson from Queens' reformation?
As much as I would give an arm, leg and testicle to see Led Zep play live today if it wasn't with the proper line up then I say let it remain sacred the way it was.

[Get a Grip]

of course not....hello

[marcus68]

Soush wrote:

Led Zep without Plant would be unthinkable, replacing John Bonham was only possible by getting his son in to do the job (and well he did it!) but each member is integral to the band and the whole on stage relationship.
Anyway, has nobody learned the lesson from Queens' reformation?
As much as I would give an arm, leg and testicle to see Led Zep play live today if it wasn't with the proper line up then I say let it remain sacred the way it was.

"sacred"????? that is way loony. if they dont get back together a Led Zeppelin, with or without plant it will be the biggest waste of human and musical potential i can think of.

[ZepAddict]

Plant can't sing anymore. End of story!

Everyone needs to take a chill pill and let the professionals get on with it and over him.

Replacements? Grohl would be a poor choice and bad for his own career. Jack White's voice is too whiney. Can't imagine listening to him for more than 2 songs before thinking..Guitar solo, please!

Apparently lead singer from "Altered Bridge" has been tapped as the replacement. Any truth to that?

[Mr Jammy Pige]

I don't care if Iggy Pop gets the job... as long as Plant doesn't get it; he has turned his back on Led Zeppelin for the last time.

They may be called something else... but we all know who they are.

Bring on The Mighty Zep!!!

[KissandTell]

Mr Jammy Pige wrote:

I don't care if Iggy Pop gets the job... as long as Plant doesn't get it; he has turned his back on Led Zeppelin for the last time.
They may be called something else... but we all know who they are.
Bring on The Mighty Zep!!!

That's right! There is only one and only Robert Plant and there is no other!!!

[KissandTell]

KissandTell wrote:

<quoted text>
That's right! There is only one and only Robert Plant and there is no other!!!

If it's Led Zeppelin, then it must be with Robert Plant- nobody else!!!

[I love the idea]

Zep would sound much better without that Katherine Hepburn impersonator wailing "bay bay bay bay bay..."

Just imagine how huge Zep could have been if they'd had a GOOD singer.

[zepforever]

I love the idea wrote:

Zep would sound much better without that Katherine Hepburn impersonator wailing "bay bay bay bay bay..."
Just imagine how huge Zep could have been if they'd had a GOOD singer.

What?Hepburn impersonator???
Robert is the best singer i have heard in my life!
your comment is completly idiot about the Golden God

Bulsh!!!t

[mint jelly enema]

They sucked with him,they will suck without him.