Review: Jonny Lee Miller in 'Eli Stone'
Join the discussion below, or Read more at Newsday.
#1 Feb 2, 2008
I take personal affront in a critic assuming that I or anyone else will be too stupid or lack the ability to thread themes together to understand the meaning behind the message. These are the same accusations thrown at "Journeyman" and it has developed a small but very loyal audience. Give people a little more credit to be creative in their thinking and not gulp down the formula crap that the vast majority of networks make available. But if all fails, there is still the History Channel and the networks can go to Hell!!
#2 Apr 23, 2008
You are missing the entire point. It is fun, entertaining, whimsical, even throws you off kilter a bit, but that's the joy of it. The sometimes silly, sometimes touching, sometimes strange dialogue is enjoyable; nothing about the show says anything about trying to be realistic! It's fiction, even if it covers interesting, real-life topics.
What you missed most embarrassingly is the fact that they never try to give a clear-cut answer - each episode presents an interesting topic (or two), and shows the alternative ways of looking at it, without ever trying to resolve or find a conclusion, since most of these debates have no resolution in sight. The show explores the delightful complexities of life as we know it, meanwhile being a (as often said) refreshingly unusual mix and vision. The show over and over brings into question anyone's right to claim a 'slam dunk of righteousness'.
I think being 'all over the map' is an excellent challenge - and having cliche characters doesn't hurt it, since in many other ways the show is trying to create something new, even if it's a hodgepodge type of new. I'm tired of style being so consistent within a show - it's great to only have to watch one show but experience many emotions and styles! Sometimes a mish-mash is fun, and many (including myself) think they've done a lovely job. ABC will be shamed miserably if they do not bring it back for another round.
Oh, and by the way, Miller is great. He plays this extremely unusual and complex (as you yourself wrote) character with gusto and sensitivity. Kudos, but not to you Werts.
Add your comments below
|Angelina Jolie is quite the vixen in long lost ... (May '14)||May '14||Jane||1|
|Benedict Cumberbatch: Sherlock's big in the US ... (Mar '13)||Mar '14||Lilactime||3|
|Jolie Rules Out Marriage to Pitt (May '07)||Jun '12||In the Soup||126|
|Jonny Lee Miller - nude ! (Aug '11)||Aug '11||Sid||1|
|Check Out BBC America's 'Emma' On DVD Feb. 9 (Feb '10)||Feb '11||FEMA solutions||2|
|The ex Mr Jolie speaks (Feb '08)||Jan '10||_Tex||10|
|Jolie's Brad love 'unexpected' (Jun '08)||Feb '09||tex_||252|
Find what you want!
Search Jonny Lee Miller Forum Now
Copyright © 2016 Topix LLC