I Quote:''Hilary Duff didn't diss Amy...

“whatever”

Since: Mar 08

san frasisco

#21 Mar 20, 2008
im sorry but amy lee has said that hilary has said that crap about her and if it wasnt true their wouldnt be so many sites saying it is and considering all the crap shes done i wouldnt be suprised if she said that about amy and hilary tries to dress like amy and act and listen and sing music that is the same as her so i know darn well she knows who they are u arent a lawyer get a life
Dee

Canada

#25 Apr 7, 2008
Stanton Stein wrote:
Another rumore formed by a person who's scheming to destroy celebrities. Please be kind and don't try to give disortions about things that weren't even said. Have you no dignity? You should be ashamed for thinking Hil would even diss Amy Lee, she doesn't even know who Evanessence is. Therefore for you to have a theory that Hil ''dissed'' Amy just for a good rumor merely is ridiculous. You should not make 'smart' remarks about a sensitive subject, which is very hard to deal with within the music world. You're visibly seen to be as having made an advancement of defamation of character against my client Hil. If you do not remove the topic, there will be more substantial evidence to fault you for the destruction of a well organized persona. You aren't just ruining her reputation, but you're also doing a great deal of damage to ms. Lees. Both parties do not wish to state what was overhead by my ear, I cannot futhermore tell you what to do with these senseless bashing acts. Amy did state that if you're to use her name,''Get my name the f*ck out your personal torture.'' With that said. I leave with a brief message. Read what Ms. Lee has said.
Hahaha whoever you are, you are a complete idiot. "Ms.Lees."?? your "client" Hil?? hahaha You can't even spell, I seriously doubt you represent a celeb, even if it's just some fluff celeb like Hilary. How are you going to take legal action against someone posting on the net? Where are you going to get the address from? Haha, man do I hate overzealous fans that try to act all professional to try to spare their favorite hollywood star some internet drama. lmao.
EPIC FAIL ON YOUR PART!
Dee

Canada

#26 Apr 7, 2008
ps,'rumore'?? is that spanish for rumor by chance??
HAHAHAHAHA XD
an EX-duff fan

UAE

#27 Apr 10, 2008
i really used to like and admire hilary duff-honestly. i thought it was awsome how she didnt become a promsicuous crazy drunk like the rest of hollywood. but then she dissed amy lee.
AMY LEE IS THE QUEEN OF MUSIC> she is absolutely amazing. her music contains such emotion and depth unlike anythig else, and duff has no right to critisize it and say its 'freaky', i mean, for christs sake - HILARY DUFF WHEN OUT WITH JOEL MADDEN! who is she to say amy lee is creepy??
am i the only person who thinks somethings not right in this story?
an EX-duff fan

UAE

#28 Apr 10, 2008
*anything. my bad - typing mistake.
an EX-duff fan

UAE

#29 Apr 10, 2008
*went. another typing mistake. when im angry i tend to type fast. thereby making many mistakes. which makes me really mad.

point is amy lee is awsome.

so there hilary duff.

shove that up ur *ss. ;p
shayma

Australia

#30 Apr 23, 2008
wow hilary duff shes just another
bitch like those other celebs!!!
Hilary Duff

Australia

#31 Apr 23, 2008
hey guys whats up please stop that gossip
its not gonna wreck the celb world!!!!!!!!
jalaina

Yakima, WA

#32 Apr 23, 2008
Stanton Stein wrote:
Another rumore formed by a person who's scheming to destroy celebrities. Please be kind and don't try to give disortions about things that weren't even said. Have you no dignity? You should be ashamed for thinking Hil would even diss Amy Lee, she doesn't even know who Evanessence is. Therefore for you to have a theory that Hil ''dissed'' Amy just for a good rumor merely is ridiculous. You should not make 'smart' remarks about a sensitive subject, which is very hard to deal with within the music world. You're visibly seen to be as having made an advancement of defamation of character against my client Hil. If you do not remove the topic, there will be more substantial evidence to fault you for the destruction of a well organized persona. You aren't just ruining her reputation, but you're also doing a great deal of damage to ms. Lees. Both parties do not wish to state what was overhead by my ear, I cannot futhermore tell you what to do with these senseless bashing acts. Amy did state that if you're to use her name,''Get my name the f*ck out your personal torture.'' With that said. I leave with a brief message. Read what Ms. Lee has said.
you do realize that every attempt you've made at sounding professional is wasted. if you were professionaly you wouldn't call the above parties "hil" or "amy". you would've called them by their professional names, "ms. duff," and "ms. lee." and you cannot claim destruction of a well organized persona" as their wasn't any solid evidence done to ms. duff's or ms. lee's reputation. ms. duff, however, can claim a false employment and representation against you.

also, a lawyer in defense of his/her client would have issued a public statement, not simply posted on an annoymous website.
Mel287

South Yarra, Australia

#33 Apr 25, 2008
gabrielle wrote:
hilary duff is the best amy lee is not face the facts hilary duff is way anybody espeacally amylee end of story she is the best
What the hell was that,seriously?Do you actually speak like that?I'd be scared.Certainly you're entitled to your own opinion but if you can't even say it properly what's the point?
Mel287

South Yarra, Australia

#34 Apr 26, 2008
Why would Duff say that anyway?Does it somehow boost her reputation in the music business to insult someone who has been far more successful than her musically(Sorry,face facts Hilary fans)?
And about my last comment,sorry if i insulted you,i just hate it when i see mistakes in writing.
Maithe

Netherlands

#35 Apr 27, 2008
I love amy lee.
and hillary wasn't supposd to diss her. Because amy lee is really awsome. Why did she did it? Because amy is a way better artist then her. so she didn't have the right to do it!

“SUPER-EXCITING!! !!”

Since: Apr 08

The Moon

#36 Apr 27, 2008
Maithe wrote:
I love amy lee.
and hillary wasn't supposd to diss her. Because amy lee is really awsome. Why did she did it? Because amy is a way better artist then her. so she didn't have the right to do it!
You seem to be making a good point there.Maybe she did criticise Amy for the simple reason Amy has been more successful in the music business then her.Of course Hilary did have a right to do it.Its freedom of speech.
Beyond Birthday_BB

Toronto, Canada

#37 Aug 30, 2008
Ya first baka Evanessence is really spelt Evanescene and Amy Lee is nice and doesn't judge people i used to like Hilary Duff but know after listening to Amy Lee Hilar Duff sucks.Amy lee has meaning to her music and Hilary's music is a mary sue jumping in a field of flowers. By the way you can't turn the goverement againt a writer. it is a free counrty. baibai baka
Beyond Birthday_BB

Toronto, Canada

#38 Aug 30, 2008
sorry legal action and SlipKnoT - Psychosocial is a good might add it
Beyond Birthday_BB

Toronto, Canada

#39 Aug 30, 2008
she did this song in choie Amy Lee it is goo and sorry i'm in a crabbie mood not like you know what i said hehe

“My CONDOLENCES, God dang...”

Since: Jun 07

Texas

#40 Aug 31, 2008
they're a good choir, but... I want to hear more of amy lee if were gonna post vids about her. lol.
Beyond Birthday_BB

Toronto, Canada

#41 Sep 1, 2008
okay no problem opps XD
Beyond Birthday_BB

Toronto, Canada

#42 Sep 1, 2008
Beyond Birthday_BB

Toronto, Canada

#43 Sep 1, 2008
good enough ya that ia real flames

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Hilary Duff Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Demi Lovato vs. Hilary Duff: Which Ed Sheeran C... (Jun '14) Thu diana 4
i love hilary duff!!!!!!!!!! (Mar '06) May '15 Tasha Tucker 590
i hate hilary duff do you? (Dec '07) May '15 Tasha Tucker 8
Hilary Duff disses Amy Lee (Jan '07) Feb '15 Jacob katoa 3,836
News Hilary Duff Calls Off Divorce From Hubby Mike C... (Apr '14) Apr '14 Rihanna 2
News Hilary Duff's sister Haylie announces enagagement (Apr '14) Apr '14 Hilary Duff 1
News Hilary Duff Wears Short Wrap Skirt In Breezy We... (Apr '14) Apr '14 Hilary Duff 1
More from around the web