Hilary Duff disses Amy Lee

Hilary Duff disses Amy Lee

Posted in the Hilary Duff Forum

First Prev
of 192
Next Last
Antonia

UK

#1 Jan 5, 2007
Before she did this I couldn't care less. I wasn't a hater and I wasn't a fan.

But then... THEN... she goes and insults my FAVOURITE SINGER!!!That is where I draw the line.

What was it that Hilary duff said about her.... oh yeah... Something about Amy Lee being freaky, the music being freaky and the album should be taken off the shelves because it scares little children!

Well hilary I've got news for you:

Your face up-close is enough to mentally scar a small child for life.

But you're probably just jealous because Amy Lee and Evanescence actually got somewhere, were number one in several contries and have had plenty of sold out shows, whereas all you got were the 7-13 year old Teenies who will soon grow up and realize that you are a FAKE SL*T

I'm guessing Hilary's also jealous because Amy Lee can actually sing live, something Hilary would never be allowed to do (It would deafen too many people and concert organizers aren't allowed to make that risk) plus Amy Lee can actually play an instrument, can Hilary? no didn't think so.

What am I forgetting... oh yeah. This is something Hilary has NEVER done in her life...
Amy writes her own lyrics *shock horror* and they have a lot more meaning than Hilary's manufactured pop rubbish that spurts out from her horribly digitally modified voice.

Okay I'm done now. Maybe when you grow a bit then you'll realise how fake and digitally altered everythign on her is.

Oh yeah by the way tell me. Who would you honestly say is more attractive:

http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g208/xXChao...

OR

http://i134.photobucket.com/albums/q93/mv_lay...

And btw hilary THIS is what singing should be:

http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g208/xXChao...

http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g208/xXChao...

Singing with Passion and LOOK she's actually playing an instrument

Singing is not:

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v326/angeli...

'Oh look a camera SMILE'

So please Hilary fans... appreciate the real talent here

Judged:

13

11

6

Reply »
Report Abuse Judge it!
Manderz

Texas City, TX

#2 Jan 25, 2007
Wow. That's probably the most true thing ever said on this site. I didn't mind it when she was just an actress making crappy movies, but when she tries to stay in the spotlight by lying to people, that's when it started to piss me off. Also, something I respect most about Amy Lee, she has one thing she's good at and sticks to it. She loves singing and is incredibly talented. Duff on the other hand is horrible at both. God, I've freaking had it with people like her. Maybe if all their money disappeared someday and they had to live like real people, just maybe they'd understand.
Laura

Elizabeth, NJ

#3 Jan 30, 2007
dude i cannot agree with you more. Amy lee is one of the best singers of all time. Hillary is nothing but a dumb blonde wanna-be. It's a disgrace to Amy to even put her and Hillary in the same sentence. Amy's got real, true talent. Hillary is fake. She even sucks as an actress. AMY LEE RULES
amy lou

Gravesend, UK

#5 Feb 3, 2007
oh and please go on my piczo sit xXx-hand-bag-hunny-xXx.piczo.com ta

“Hilary's the best”

Since: Jan 07

Cluj Napoca

#6 Feb 3, 2007
PEACE!!!!!!!!AMY LEE IS OK IS A GOOD SINGER BUT I LIKE MORE HILARY'S MUSIC :d:d:

Judged:

21

10

9

Reply »
Report Abuse Judge it!
amy lou

Gravesend, UK

#7 Feb 4, 2007
well youre a bit dumb arnt ya amy lee is much better then duff duf

“Hilary's the best”

Since: Jan 07

Cluj Napoca

#8 Feb 4, 2007
than u r a bit dumb cuz hill is much much much better than amy lee

“Hilary's the best”

Since: Jan 07

Cluj Napoca

#9 Feb 4, 2007
Your face up-close is enough to mentally scar a small child for life. Excuse me?????????than PEOPLES ON THIS FORUM PLEAS TAKE A LOOK HERE:http://i57.photobucket.co m/albums/g208/xXChaotic-Kittie Xx/115.jpg

THIS PHOTO CAN SCARE A MATURE 4 life.But this smile http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v326/angeli...

fall in love :D:D:D:D:D:

“Hilary's the best”

Since: Jan 07

Cluj Napoca

#10 Feb 4, 2007
http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g208/xXChao...

she is RLY RLY UGLY IN THIS PHOTO
Antonia

Lincoln, UK

#11 Feb 5, 2007
Are you pyscho or something

Amy Lee and ugly just don't go together and by the way you know the first image you put up (the one of Amy singing LIVE)
It's called singing with PASSION when Amy is up there singing live she doesn't particularly care what she looks like.

Do you want em to show you gorgeous pictures of Amy, well even if ya don't you're gonna:

http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g208/xXChao...

http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g208/xXChao...

http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g208/xXChao...

http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g208/xXChao...

Ok now you try and tell me she isn't pretty

and then give me Hilary Duff pictures that even match up to Amy Lee

Oh and natural photos:

http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g208/xXChao...

http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g208/xXChao...

http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g208/xXChao...

http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g208/xXChao...

http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g208/xXChao...

Now give me some 'Natural' Hilary photo's that are as pretty as this

“Hilary's the best”

Since: Jan 07

Cluj Napoca

#12 Feb 6, 2007
ok i will give u some hilarys photos who are more nice !!!!!!BTW in the natural photos amy lee is rely UGLY!!!!!!!!!!NO OFFENCE but this is the true

“Hilary's the best”

Since: Jan 07

Cluj Napoca

#13 Feb 6, 2007
look here some rly nice photos of Hilary Duff!!!

http://www.lexode.com/galerie/galerie/m/i/mia...

and

http://www.lexode.com/galerie/galerie/m/a/mag...

or

http://www.lexode.com/galerie/galerie/m/a/mag...

and at least

http://www.lexode.com/galerie/galerie/z/z/zza...

How to hate such a beauty like Hilary.Have 2 be STUPID to h8 her
Antonia

Lincoln, UK

#14 Feb 6, 2007
romanianboy wrote:
look here some rly nice photos of Hilary Duff!!!
http://www.lexode.com/galerie/galerie/m/i/mia...
and
http://www.lexode.com/galerie/galerie/m/a/mag...
or
http://www.lexode.com/galerie/galerie/m/a/mag...
and at least
http://www.lexode.com/galerie/galerie/z/z/zza...
How to hate such a beauty like Hilary.Have 2 be STUPID to h8 her
I said NATURAL beauty. Not re-touched, photoshopped, make-up plastered fake people.

Amy Lee is naturally beautiful, she doesn't need the re-touching and even when she dosn;t use make-up she looks fantastic. You are confusing natural beauty with ugliness.

It's people like you who make normal girls feel ugly and worthless, because when you call someone, who has been called beautiful, ugly then it really gives you low self-esteem.

And also Amy Lee can ACTUALLY SING!!! Oh My God!

Don;t say 'Oh Hilary is only young, she has to let her voice develope, Amy Lee has had more experience blah blah blah' because that has to be the worst excuse ever.

Hilary was what... 16 when she sang for the Metamorphisis album right?
So she was 16 when she sang this song right?



urgh... that's all I can say... urgh

Okay now compare it to Amy Lee at 16 years old

http://www.youtube.com/watch...

Now who do you think has the better voice.

Oh and keep in mind that Amy recorded that song in a closet, with no studio-equipment. For the heavier songs Ben and David recorded the guitars and drums in another room and then they put the two clips together. They then sold the album containing this song at a local gigs.

Whereas Hilary had the best studio equipment possible.

So choose the more talented girl
Antonia

Lincoln, UK

#15 Feb 6, 2007
romanianboy wrote:
Your face up-close is enough to mentally scar a small child for life. Excuse me?????????than PEOPLES ON THIS FORUM PLEAS TAKE A LOOK HERE:http://i57.photobucket.co m/albums/g208/xXChaotic-Kittie Xx/115.jpg
THIS PHOTO CAN SCARE A MATURE 4 life.But this smile http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v326/angeli...
fall in love :D:D:D:D:D:
And you think THAT smile makes you fall in love

http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g208/xXChao...

http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g208/xXChao...

Try that smile (Plus it's also natural)
AmyLeeDieHardFan

New Rochelle, NY

#16 Feb 7, 2007
Amy Lee is a true vision of beauty. Hilary duff understands nothing about the dark side, and she probably never will, that chick lives in her own little world, where as Amy Lee lives in the real world where real stuff happens. Amy Lee's music gives us all a haunting and true view of the world, while Hilary just jumps up and down on stage singing about crap that doesnt matter and probably wont matter tomorrow. AMY LEE ROCKS!!!!
Brass shines to the ignorant as gold to the goldsmiths. Hilary = brass lover and Amy = goldsmith

“Hilary's the best”

Since: Jan 07

Cluj Napoca

#17 Feb 7, 2007
Antonia

Lincoln, UK

#18 Feb 7, 2007
romanianboy wrote:
http://i57.photobucket.com/alb ums/g208/xXChaotic-KittieXx/la ugh.jpg
i'm rly scared.She suck
Do you live in a world of rainbows and puppy dogs or something. And how does that piture make her suck? Or is that the only insult you know?

She is having a laugh on a radio show and she just messed up her lines and so she is LAUGHING. It's real not fake like Hilary Duff's 'smile'


See that's called being real and having fun.

And I believe you never commented on their voices, are you so shallow as to only care about appearances?

Figures
Lia

United States

#19 Feb 7, 2007
I kind of agree, but...

I personally don't like Hillary very much. But then again, I don't really pay any attention to her.

I don't think she has that much of a voice, and she's an ok actress. Personally, she's someone who I can stand and go," She's ok." and not, "Oh my god she f-ing sucks." At the same time, I don't really like her music. Maybe that's because at one time it was overplayed. The only song I do like of hers, however, is Why Not, and that's about it.

As for what she said about Amy Lee, I think that's kind of funny. Music= contoversy/lyrics. I mean, if it's freaky, that's her opinion, but to say it should be taken off the shelves because it, "scares little children" is a little far fecthed. I mean, come on there are FAR MORE bands out there with lyrics that are much darker and more explicit than that of Evanescence (not that evanescence was explicit in the first place).

As for looks, I think Hillary is cute. She's not the most beautiful person in the world, but she's certainly not ugly, and to say so would be a little unfair.

I like Amy better however, because she seems more natural. There's just something about her that seems more natural than Hillary. To me,Hillary's voice sounds a little fake (sorry Hillary fans!).

I've heard people say Amy Lee sucks. I'm a huge fan of her music, and even i have to admit, that on the Anywhere but Home DVD, her voice wasn't that great. But, on 10/29/06, I saw her in concert, and she blew me away. Her voice has improved so so much since a few years ago. She sounds pretty much the same as she does on the album, but you can tell there'sa difference. So, to say she sucks now (as in her voice) is a little crazy.

Maybe Hillary and Amy shouldn't be linked together just becasue of their differences in looks, style, personality and music (that's not to say that Hillary has horrible looks, style and music. Isaid she was cute, and her acting was ok, I never said it was horrible).

Maybe Hillary knows that Evanescence has been far more sucessful than she has, and she's a bit jealous (that's just my thinking, I really don't know). I am a little mad that hillary said Amy Lee is freaky looking. I mean, look, Hillary, if you have looks, fame and fortune, and millions of fans, why should you even care what Amy Lee does or what she looks like?

“Hilary's the best”

Since: Jan 07

Cluj Napoca

#20 Feb 8, 2007
http://www.biggeststars.com/a/amy-lee-photo-5...

purely i don't like amy lee Is this a problem??
Antonia

Lincoln, UK

#21 Feb 8, 2007
no that's not the problem.

The problem is you saying that natural photos of a normal-looking attractive woman are ugly... that's the problem.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 192
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Hilary Duff Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Demi Lovato vs. Hilary Duff: Which Ed Sheeran C... (Jun '14) Jul '15 diana 4
i love hilary duff!!!!!!!!!! (Mar '06) May '15 Tasha Tucker 590
i hate hilary duff do you? (Dec '07) May '15 Tasha Tucker 8
News Hilary Duff Calls Off Divorce From Hubby Mike C... (Apr '14) Apr '14 Rihanna 2
News Hilary Duff's sister Haylie announces enagagement (Apr '14) Apr '14 Hilary Duff 1
News Hilary Duff Wears Short Wrap Skirt In Breezy We... (Apr '14) Apr '14 Hilary Duff 1
News 'Hannah Montana' Star Miley Cyrus: Next Duff? (Dec '06) Apr '14 attention seeking... 7,150
More from around the web