Aaliyah vs Alicia Keys

Aaliyah vs Alicia Keys

Posted in the Beyonce Forum

First Prev
of 9
Next Last
Rana

Australia

#1 Feb 8, 2007
Who'z better?I choose Aaliyah for her versatility and her strong dancing performance.
NIa

United States

#2 Feb 8, 2007
this is a very hard one to even answer because they both have very different talents.
keysha

Amersfoort, Netherlands

#3 Feb 9, 2007
i love alica keys but i have 2 say aaliyah r.i.p baby girl
yallcrazyashell

West Chester, PA

#4 Feb 9, 2007
Thats a damn shame how U can compare 2 talented ass females.Anyway I choose alica keys because she writes her own material nothing against aaliyah,not saying she wasnt a real artist but thats what puts alica keys a step a-head from aaliyah.
and plus the grammy wins.
Jay

Miami, FL

#5 Feb 9, 2007
There is no reason to compare.

Alicia Keys admired Aaliyah,

not only that but they are VERY different.

Alicia Keys is amazing, and so was Aaliyah.

I love them both. Had they done a duet together it would have been sensational.
Jay

Miami, FL

#6 Feb 9, 2007
I would also like to say that when it comes to artisty I believe Alicia Keys is better, but I will NOT discredit Aaliyah, for she was an AMAZING artist with limitless talent.

You have to share love for both of them.

If you love Alicia, you most certainly will like Aaliyah too. If you like Aaliyah, you will certainly like Alicia as well. Both different, both Brilliant.
Nah-nah

West Chester, PA

#7 Feb 9, 2007
Oh please grow up first aaliyah and ciara,now aaliyah and alica keys they are all doing better then us,maybe we should say

Rana vs aaliyah

and yallcrazyashell vs alica keys

and jay vs ciara

I chose aaliyah over rana
ciara over jay
and alica keys over yallcrazyashell

maybe thats why the world is so fucked up because losers always want to compare these artist like thats their loved ones.......shut up because there all better than all 3 of u!
veronica

Philadelphia, PA

#8 Feb 10, 2007
I say alica keys!
Rana

Australia

#9 Feb 11, 2007
Just get back to da subject or don't talk at all Nah-nah(terribl name).
Nah-nah

Philadelphia, PA

#10 Feb 11, 2007
Maybe if yall stop compareing aaliyah to every damn body I would stop.
You act just like since aaliyah died beauty and talent died with her.GROW UP!
Aaliyah is dead and yes her music will live on and on but she wont,probably in your heart she will,but be real there is nothing new with aaliyah because she died 5 yrs ago,so why do she get compared to artist that dont even have nuffin in common with her.

Alica writes her own material
Aaliyah doesnt

Alica is a grammy award winning artist
Aaliyah is not

Alica can produce her own records
Aaliyah didnt

Alica plays the piano
Aaliyah didnt

only thing they have in common is there singing ability so what are U compareing them for?

Im so sick of this shit it gets so fucking annoying.
Jay

Miami, FL

#11 Feb 12, 2007
No one was comparing you moron, she was simply asking who you liked better and why.

You really love to undermine Aaliyah, probably because you are a fan of Ciara who gets irritated at the fact that she is Crap compared to her.

If anything read every comment here and see who started the whole argument, because in actuality it was you. I hate fatuous individuals like you. You make me sick.
Rana

Australia

#13 Feb 20, 2007
"You really love to undermine Aaliyah, probably because you are a fan of Ciara who gets irritated at the fact that she is Crap compared to her"

That's what she is always doing.It's an opinion thread not a direct comparison and a firm tease conclusion.Get that through.
yallcrazyashell

Philadelphia, PA

#14 Feb 21, 2007
@rana

Oh please bitch,shut up!

U know exactly what u were doing.
NIa

United States

#15 Feb 21, 2007
Nah-nah wrote:
Maybe if yall stop compareing aaliyah to every damn body I would stop.
You act just like since aaliyah died beauty and talent died with her.GROW UP!
Aaliyah is dead and yes her music will live on and on but she wont,probably in your heart she will,but be real there is nothing new with aaliyah because she died 5 yrs ago,so why do she get compared to artist that dont even have nuffin in common with her.
Alica writes her own material
Aaliyah doesnt
Alica is a grammy award winning artist
Aaliyah is not
Alica can produce her own records
Aaliyah didnt
Alica plays the piano
Aaliyah didnt
only thing they have in common is there singing ability so what are U compareing them for?
Im so sick of this shit it gets so fucking annoying.
it was against aaliyah's contract to wirte. she help timbaland produce romeo must die soundtrack. aaliyah dances,alicia doesnt, aaliyah has a more versatile voice then alicia,,,, its hard to compare these two because they have 3885dfferent talent.

“QUEEN AKASHA”

Since: Jan 07

Sioux Falls

#16 Feb 21, 2007
NIa wrote:
this is a very hard one to even answer because they both have very different talents.
I know right, they're both very talented and they both have many admirers. I like Aaliyah for her vocal, dance, and acting performances, but Alicia also has vocal and acting skills. I haven't seen her dance or anything, and Alicia just started her acting career. I choose Aaliyah.
Rana

Australia

#17 Feb 21, 2007
"Oh please bitch,shut up!
U know exactly what u were doing"

On this thread it was u and nah-nah that started this shit and now u tell me how to shut my mouth when it was you and her crticising & shit nonstop around.Why don't you just take your own advice for a chance.It might help you reason with logic rather than bull-shit.
yallcrazyashell

Philadelphia, PA

#18 Feb 21, 2007
I have a confession to make,Nah-nah is me,whoa that was hard to say but its over and done and like I said rana u started this whole arguement I just took it to a different level.
nick

Arlington, TX

#19 Mar 2, 2007
yallcrazyashell wrote:
Thats a damn shame how U can compare 2 talented ass females.Anyway I choose alica keys because she writes her own material nothing against aaliyah,not saying she wasnt a real artist but thats what puts alica keys a step a-head from aaliyah.
and plus the grammy wins.
bitch u kno aaliyah iz better den stupid alica keys she did wrote her own stuff when she left r.kelly so get yo facts right b4 u say stupid stuff like dat about her
jay

Miami, FL

#20 Mar 3, 2007
nick wrote:
<quoted text>
bitch u kno aaliyah iz better den stupid alica keys she did wrote her own stuff when she left r.kelly so get yo facts right b4 u say stupid stuff like dat about her
no she didnt.
smiley

Falls Church, VA

#21 Mar 3, 2007
I think ya'll are just saying alice keys because aaliyah past and ya'll aint get to hear her futuer music

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 9
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Beyonce Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Beyonce's influence on Pop culture (Oct '08) Tue Aiyona 7
Beyonce sucks (Dec '08) Tue Real 102
News Former New York mayor Rudy Giuliani slams Beyon... Tue white45yroldeduca... 2
***when will the beyhive receive their codes fo... Tue Laurenmariehill 1
Is Jay-Z cheating on BEYONCE with Rihanna??? (Jun '06) Mon Anon 3,166
News 'El Chapo' Has Been Captured, Mexican President... Jan 27 ima-Ilis Myka Ash... 2
Is beyonce's 'if i were a boy' sexist or offend... (May '10) Jan '16 Insightful_Idiot 3
More from around the web