'American Idol' Plucks an Irish Rose - Carly Smithson and Syesh...

[Marie]

I believe,that Brook and Jason should have been in the bottom two. This is like last year, when they had the one girl who always had something sexy on and continues to be on the show. And the one guy, went the crazy hair, that was the only reason he was still on. That was wrong, that was wrong, didn't I say that was WRONG!

[crow fan]

Definitely ! Carly should not have gone yet.

[Conservative Thinker]

Thats right I think Jason Castro is the weakest of all the American Idol contestants.

[Sticks]

Sarah is right. I think Clay very often says "we" when referring to things he's doing or has done in the past, because he's a very humble guy and very appreciative of every part his back-up singers (who he makes an integral part of his concerts), musicians, management team, security, crew and fans play in his success. In concert, he acknowledges and thanks everyone. At the last concert of every tour he thanks his entire crew and has them all come out on stage to take a bow. This includes his tour manager, his hair and clothes stylist, his bodyguard, any stage crew he may have with him, etc.

[J Bird]

So Brook is the candidate for "Vote for the Worst" ?? That explains it. Despite Jason's performance of Memory (I think he figured any ALW song he chose would suck anyway so he did a mockery thing, which I thought was funny, I still love him and his style and would totally buy his album as long as the producers stay true to his style. I was not surprised to see Carly go due to her past record deal or whatever. I love her present look and I think the girl can sing and she's pretty in a realist way. I hope she's more successful with her next album should that happen.