It's the Guns, Stupid

It's the Guns, Stupid

There are 103296 comments on the Truthdig story from Apr 20, 2007, titled It's the Guns, Stupid. In it, Truthdig reports that:

“And that's the end of the issue”

Why do we have the same futile argument every time there is a mass killing? Advocates of gun control try to open a discussion about whether more reasonable weapons statutes might reduce the number of violent ... via Truthdig

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Truthdig.

levi

United States

#98370 Jan 24, 2013
That should of read, I am 'now' the proud owner etc.
Dr Freud

Bethnal Green, UK

#98372 Jan 24, 2013
levi wrote:
That should of read, I am 'now' the proud owner etc.
For your own personal protection, I would admonish you to NEVER tell anyone what you are going to do, and NEVER tell anyone what you have done.
STOP, and consider —at length— that advice.
Anymore, it seems that people are given to 'brag' about their achievements, acquisitions, etc., perhaps as a means of 'one-upping' others.
But such revelations can, and indeed may, be a means of bringing about one's downfall, by informing one's enemies of certain information which they would not have otherwise.
So, do you have guns? Tell no one. And, when asked, you ask right back: Why do YOU want to know?
KEEP ASKING 'WHY?' until you are left alone.
Dr Freud

Bethnal Green, UK

#98373 Jan 24, 2013
jase wrote:
The terriost of 9/11/2001 did not have guns.
Well, yes, they DID have guns, but they were sitting in comfy chairs, as they watched the events of that terrible day unfold.
levi

United States

#98374 Jan 24, 2013
Dr Freud wrote:
<quoted text>
For your own personal protection, I would admonish you to NEVER tell anyone what you are going to do, and NEVER tell anyone what you have done.
STOP, and consider —at length— that advice.
Anymore, it seems that people are given to 'brag' about their achievements, acquisitions, etc., perhaps as a means of 'one-upping' others.
But such revelations can, and indeed may, be a means of bringing about one's downfall, by informing one's enemies of certain information which they would not have otherwise.
So, do you have guns? Tell no one. And, when asked, you ask right back: Why do YOU want to know?
KEEP ASKING 'WHY?' until you are left alone.
The government already knows, the guns are registered. Our govt also know they will have hell to pay if they try to take them either by force or by passing laws. We americans love our country, our constitution, but we will not stand by and let a bunch of socialist bleeding hearts destroy our constitution, even if it means war against the govt. But I understand what you're saying, and its good advice, thank you.

“shirley you cant be serious ”

Since: Oct 12

Location hidden

#98375 Jan 24, 2013
Dr Freud wrote:
<quoted text>
For your own personal protection, I would admonish you to NEVER tell anyone what you are going to do, and NEVER tell anyone what you have done.
STOP, and consider —at length— that advice.
Anymore, it seems that people are given to 'brag' about their achievements, acquisitions, etc., perhaps as a means of 'one-upping' others.
But such revelations can, and indeed may, be a means of bringing about one's downfall, by informing one's enemies of certain information which they would not have otherwise.
So, do you have guns? Tell no one. And, when asked, you ask right back: Why do YOU want to know?
KEEP ASKING 'WHY?' until you are left alone.
paranoid nutjob ha ha haa

“shirley you cant be serious ”

Since: Oct 12

Location hidden

#98376 Jan 24, 2013
Dr Freud wrote:
<quoted text>
Well, yes, they DID have guns, but they were sitting in comfy chairs, as they watched the events of that terrible day unfold.
conspiracy nutjob ha haa
Guppy

Bloomfield Hills, MI

#98377 Jan 24, 2013
A child or teen dies from guns every three hours in America.

Since: Dec 10

Perth, Australia

#98378 Jan 24, 2013
Armed Veteran wrote:
<quoted text>
You are calling Fast And Furious a "conspiracy theory"??? Right. That's why Oblunder used his magical powers to block any of the paperwork and other correspondence from being released to the justice department so they can properly investigate Eric Holder. You truly are daft.
And the vast majority of the rifles seized by the Mexican officials are rifles we have given to the Mexican govt that were sold to the cartels by the Mexican soldiers, or from soldiers who defected to the cartels because they pay much better than the govt does.
Try again, oh clueless twit.
I am saying that you conjure up conspiracy theories at the drop of a hat...in regards to Fast and the Furious failure the intentions was to catch the straw buyers so the intention was a good one just badly executed......and when there is 68000 guns flooded across the Mexican border from the US 2000 guns though a failure is a drop in the ocean had it succeeded and barely noticed if it didn't.....get real.....if it had have suceeded everyone would be singing the praises of the ATF....stings sometimes fail....and they did manage to recover 700 of the 2000....albiet without a result but the glass is always half empty eh!
Guppy

Bloomfield Hills, MI

#98379 Jan 24, 2013
There is a recognition that Second Amendment rights, like First Amendment and other rights, come with responsibilities and limitations.

RW
Tm Clmns

Victoria, Canada

#98380 Jan 24, 2013
Wally1 wrote:
I don't think Obama has any clue on what he started by signing exeutive orders that are cleary not allowed to infringe on the 2nd amendment. I think lit the fuse leading to a powder keg, Law abiding gun owners are not going to stand for this first assault on their rights. It's time to stand and fight for your rights, because obviously at the federal level your representatives are not doing their job. Last week, gun and ammunition sales were the highest rate ever! I also must commend the Sheriffs and Police chiefs (most western states)who have announced they will be abiding by their oath to uphold the constitution and not enforcing Obama's illegal executive orders. Remember this simple quote: Without guns, people against them, would not exist.
Fantastic ideas.... just all go and blow yourselves to bits... It is your 2nd Amd. right...

Just continue the old civil war... It ain't over... obviously

Since: Jan 12

Where The Wild Things Grow

#98381 Jan 24, 2013
spider1954 wrote:
<quoted text>
I may be mistaken,,but I think the confusion may lay here.
Whilst no one has a right to protection, all normal parents defend and protect their children as a matter of course.
I think what Sarila is trying to say is this. When we place our children in the care of others (at a school for instance) then those children should be afforded a similar level of protection as if the parents were there, if the school doesen't provide a level of service to match a potential danger, then parents would be justified in removing their children from school.
An armed guard would be akin to having an armed parent present.
Thank you, that is right, I am a teacher, schools have a duty of care, to be exercised at all times, within the school, whilst on excursions and even outside of school hours, if the school has knowledge of circumstances where a student's well-being may be compromised. Students do have a right to protection, parents have a right to expectation of that protection and schools have an obligation to provide such protection - as is required in the circumstances. If it has come to the stage where school shootings present a known and substantial risk - then provide those who can respond to that risk professionally - you don't leave children to try and protect themselves, that is negligent and morally wrong.
Dr Freud

Bethnal Green, UK

#98382 Jan 24, 2013
levi wrote:
<quoted text> The government already knows, the guns are registered. Our govt also know they will have hell to pay if they try to take them either by force or by passing laws. We americans love our country, our constitution, but we will not stand by and let a bunch of socialist bleeding hearts destroy our constitution, even if it means war against the govt. But I understand what you're saying, and its good advice, thank you.
If you were smart enough to NOT have purchased your guns through a dealer, and instead purchased them from a private source, then your property won't have been 'registered.'

Since: Feb 11

Cambridge, UK

#98383 Jan 24, 2013
tinydropthestickgooddog wrote:
<quoted text>
paranoid nutjob ha ha haa
Is throwing out pointless, ill informed insults, really the best you can come up with.
Dr Freud

Bethnal Green, UK

#98384 Jan 24, 2013
Guppy wrote:
There is a recognition that Second Amendment rights, like First Amendment and other rights, come with responsibilities and limitations.
RW
DO TELL: Precisely WHERE is the term 'limitation' mention in any amendment to the U.S. Constitution for the United States?

Since: Feb 11

Cambridge, UK

#98385 Jan 24, 2013
tinydropthestickgooddog wrote:
<quoted text>
conspiracy nutjob ha haa
Yep,,it would seem that's all you have.
Tm Clmns

Victoria, Canada

#98386 Jan 24, 2013
Face the Facts wrote:
<quoted text>
And looks like they will be doing everything possible to cause those weapons to be used.
It sure looks as if the Obama people are trying to push the USA into a bloody revolution.
b

Don't be stupid.. That is the NRA's job on behalf of the Republican corporatists.

Once you eliminate yourselves with the millions of guns, they will just bring in Chinese to take over your property and then they will work for US companies forever for $2 a day.

Buy more guns... get mad... shoot your neighbours.. especially the Liberals. Let the Mexicans and Chinese take over their houses...
Dr Freud

Bethnal Green, UK

#98387 Jan 24, 2013
sairla wrote:
<quoted text>
Thank you, that is right, I am a teacher, schools have a duty of care, to be exercised at all times, within the school, whilst on excursions and even outside of school hours, if the school has knowledge of circumstances where a student's well-being may be compromised. Students do have a right to protection, parents have a right to expectation of that protection and schools have an obligation to provide such protection - as is required in the circumstances. If it has come to the stage where school shootings present a known and substantial risk - then provide those who can respond to that risk professionally - you don't leave children to try and protect themselves, that is negligent and morally wrong.
" If it has come to the stage where school shootings present a known and substantial risk - then provide those who can respond to that risk professionally - you don't leave children to try and protect themselves, that is negligent and morally wrong."

According to yourself, at precisely WHAT age should children be allowed to protect themselves from physical attack?
Do NOT forget to put YOURSELF in THEIR place, when YOU reply!

Since: Dec 10

Perth, Australia

#98389 Jan 24, 2013
spider1954 wrote:
<quoted text>
A gun thread,,, REALLY,,, well thanks for pointing that out,,I had been kind of wondering why you hadn't shared your culinary skills lately.
Turtles ?????? who mentioned turtles,,you feeling ok.
Sooo you want to talk about easy access to guns,,tell me this then, as the UK is an island, with a natural barrier twenty one miles wide at its narrowest point,a far easier border to police than most countries enjoy, how come fire arms are so easily available to anyone who cares to buy one on the black market. After all, most guns are banned here, yet tere is no problem in obtaining one if you want one. The ownership of guns amongst law abiding UK residents has allways been low, since the more recent ban it is virtually non existent. Strange is it not that fire arms so easily find there way into criminal hands.
The UK death rate is minimal...below that of most of all other countries even lower than New Zealand
Up to 30-40% of crimes in the UK involve replica's that is toy guns made to look like the real thing....70% of murders in the UK involve converted weapons these are blank firing(athletic firing weapons and CS gas guns, or high pressure air pellet firing weapons and air guns made to look like the real thing and legally obtained through Europe...they are cheaper alloys but these can and are being converted or re-engineered to fire real bullets, though are very unstable and often blow up in their faces....So the UK are aware of people importing these weapons legally, and they are endeavouring to alter the laws to prevent them easy access into the UK...

Note where the UK sits on death by gun in comparrison to the majority of other countries...they have no where near the gun deaths of other worldly nations and that is due to their extremely strict gun control laws that have worked by seeing a major reduction in gun deaths.......

The idiocy of you including a country like the UK who have clearly reduced their death to below that of equal the lowest in the civilised world is clutching at straws...and the gun deaths are committed with replica guns able to be sourced legally from Europe and some converted (at great risk) to kill or maim.......

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countrie...

http://www.channel4.com/programmes/dispatches...
Teaman

Abingdon, VA

#98390 Jan 24, 2013
Dr Freud wrote:
<quoted text>
DO TELL: Precisely WHERE is the term 'limitation' mention in any amendment to the U.S. Constitution for the United States?
Above that, what other right requires a registration.
Guppy

Bloomfield Hills, MI

#98391 Jan 24, 2013
Americans are 20 times more likely to be killed by a gun than residents of other developed countries.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

US News Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Barack Obama, our next President (Nov '08) 1 min RoxLo 1,547,685
News Russian hackers targeted election systems in 21... 2 min old_moose 8
News BARACK OBAMA BIRTH CERTIFICATE: Suit contesting... (Jan '09) 2 min huntcoyotes 241,537
News Plurality of Americans think Trump is failing 3 min MayDay 6,625
News Watergate pales next to Trump scandals, ex-US i... 4 min bad bob 587
Election 'Fox News Sunday' to Host Kentucky Senate Debate (Oct '10) 4 min Burn Notice 274,096
News Trump claims witch hunt, says he's most hounded... 9 min bad bob 974
News POLL: Americans Trust James Comey Over Trump 36 min Toxic Repub Toxins 473
News Dems say they'll slow Senate work over secretiv... 1 hr Lawrence Wolf 182
News John McCain: Otto Warmbier 'murdered by the Kim... 1 hr slick willie expl... 55
More from around the web