SGT. SHAFT: Widow upset by what she c...

SGT. SHAFT: Widow upset by what she calls a a Dead Veterana s Taxa

There are 4 comments on the Washington Times story from Jul 17, 2012, titled SGT. SHAFT: Widow upset by what she calls a a Dead Veterana s Taxa. In it, Washington Times reports that:

Although 100 percent disabled, my husband was able to receive both his military retirement pay and his VA disability, thanks to Sen.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Washington Times.

Since: May 11

Location hidden

#1 Jul 17, 2012
The tax payers have supported your husband, why should we be required to support YOU for the rest of YOUR life.?

Did your husband take out life insurance policies to take care of his family in the event of his death? That's what most responsible men do.

Let's remember that this is an all-volunteer military. And, before we go further, I have a stepson in the military leaving for Afghanistan in a few weeks. It breaks my heart that our country has thrown all this men and women into harm's way for nothing.

At the same time, they all chose to join and not all of them for patriotic reasons. I believe every injured vet should be given the best health care available, but the taxpayer should not have to support this person's family for life.

Columbus, OH

#4 Jul 17, 2012
Let's look at this like a Rightie or Libertarian would:

"Although 100 percent disabled, my husband was able to receive both his military retirement pay and his VA disability, thanks to Sen. Harry Reidís bill, S. 170. When he passed away, those concurrent receipt benefits were not passed on to me. Why?"

>>Because you didn't serve in the military, retire from it, or become disabled as a result of said service?

It is only the extension of the dead veteranís benefits that should be continued for his widow.


The Survivor Benefit Plan/Dependency and Indemnity Compensation offset for unremarried military surviving spouses is a ďDead Veteranís TaxĒ that is being imposed on the retired service memberís surviving spouse.

>>So, not receiving government handouts is now to be considered a "tax?" Do you know the meaning of that word? If no, I'd look it up sometime.


Since: Nov 08

Location hidden

#6 Jul 18, 2012
Looks like Senator Reid, also known as "the Douche" forgot one small detail. Too many punches to the head me thinks. A little punch drunk for sure.

Mount Laurel, NJ

#7 Jul 18, 2012
Before you read this please note I am an Army brat, Navy Vet and Air Force spouse. My mother traveled all over the world with my father after he voluntarily joined the Army. He spent 22 years and earned his retirement pension. When he retired, he opted to pay for Survivor's benefits. It was taken from his retirement and put aside so my mother could draw it when he passed. HE EARNED his retirement and being married for 22 to a traveling man (they moved every 3-4 years) earned her the right to receive his pension (at a reduced rate) after sacrificing part of his pension for it. He was disabled after 2 tours in Vietnam and came home a different man. My mother was not disabled and felt she had no claim on that money. Nor do I. The retirement was enough.
My sister served 22 years in the Navy and nows receives a pension and disability. When she dies, it stops and no-one can draw it because she isn't married and you can not assign it to a child.
I did not serve a full 20 so I will not receive a pension from my service. My husband on the other hand has 27 years at this point and will receive a pension. I will draw his pension after he dies because we elect to do survivor's benefit. If he becomes disbaled I will enjoy the extra money with him while he is alive. When he passes, it will cease. I am not the one disbaled and there is no reason for the government to pay me as a disabled person. Be happy you are getting his retirement. That you may very well have earned if you were married long enough and he chose survivor's benefit but please don't be greedy. You have a whole life without being disabled, be happy about it.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Jim Webb Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Globe Trot: Turkey tries to eradicate growing K... Aug '15 SpaceBlues 1
News Obama smears Iran deal critics and liberals las... Aug '15 Jeff Brightone 1
News Jim Webba s Iowa director really doesna t like ... Aug '15 Max 1
News Jim Webb joins 2016 presidential race Jul '15 Novus Ordo Seclorum 7
News Former Sen. Jim Webb Announces Run For Democrat... Jul '15 Novus Ordo Seclorum 6
News New Hampshire Poll: Sanders Pulling Nearly Even... Jun '15 LeDuped 2
News Jeb Bush tops 2016 GOP field in Virginia (Feb '15) May '15 swedenforever 90
More from around the web