Snow bunting that visited a disappoin...

Snow bunting that visited a disappointed twitcher.

There are 8 comments on the story from Jan 1, 2009, titled Snow bunting that visited a disappointed twitcher.. In it, reports that:

As a keen birdwatcher, Janet Davies thought nothing of travelling 1,000 miles to Norway to try and catch a glimpse of a rare snow bunting. Snow buntings have bright white plumages and there are only around 70 breeding pairs in Europe. Mrs Davies said: "They are very rare in Britain. It must have been blown off course. This time of year is often good for spotting rarities because of the windy conditions which bring them in". A snow bunting arrived in Mrs Davies' Helston garden in December and happily shared a bird table with more familiar chaffinches.

Join the discussion below, or

Roy W

Hoddesdon, UK

#1 Jan 2, 2009
The bird featured is a partially albino female Chaffinch - NOT a Snow Bunting.
Several people have tried to post comments to this effect on the Daily Mail website but they don't seem to want to admit their mistake.
Nick Derry

Leven, UK

#2 Jan 2, 2009
Roy's comment is correct, the picture in the full article shows an aberrant Chaffinch and not a Snow Bunting. Sorry Janet, but the good side is that Snow Buntings are not as rare as the article would have us believe - a few pairs can be found in the Cairngorms and they are quite easy to see in the winter at a lot of sites on the east coast.
Tony Keene

Zurich, Switzerland

#3 Jan 2, 2009
Spot on the pair of you. As usual, Fleet Street is the extent of the editor's world and anything outside it is lost to them...

Salford, UK

#4 Jan 2, 2009
"there are only around 70 breeding pairs in Europe"

Where do they get this rubbish from? This means I've had almost half the European population of Snow Bunting at my feet in the car park at Salthouse.
Geoff Halliwell


#5 Jan 2, 2009
Upmarket Daily Telegraph has also failed to distinguish partial albino female chaffinch from a snow bunting. Sorry Mrs Davies,that you have been you have been so mis-informed.
John B


#6 Jan 3, 2009
The Times has finally conceded defeat and published comments on the bird's true identity. But the Daily Mail still doesn't want to spoil "a good story". Anyway it's difficult not to feel some sympathy for Mrs Davies - assuming someone has told her by now! I wouldn't want to break the news.
dean smith

London, UK

#7 Jan 3, 2009
seen this in 3 national papers now, and shame on them for not correcting the poor women just for a 'story' and also panning it out with a load of rubbish made up 'facts'

but we all know the mails view on migrants .....
Geoffrey Acklam

Arendal, Norway

#8 Jan 6, 2009
Snow Buntings are everywhere in Svalbard, so I can't imagine how she managed to avoid seeing them there, unless she went at the wrong time of year. And the bird in her garden is certainly a partly albino chaffinch.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Helston, England Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Foot access to Tesco Helston from the Acres Edg... (Oct '14) Feb '15 mike honour 2
News Main image for Somerset flood alerts and warnin... (Dec '12) Dec '12 Jason armentrout 1
News Families evacuated as river rises (Dec '12) Dec '12 Aminu 1
EXIT Local games/dvd/book shop now online! (Nov '09) Nov '09 Julia 1
News PC Derek Cormack with the cannabis plants found... (Sep '09) Sep '09 Gillian Zella Martin 1
News Row breaks out after Devon firm wins prize for ... (May '09) May '09 shaun oates 1
News Cornwall Firefighters Tackle 17 Incidents in Le... (Mar '09) Mar '09 Allen 1
More from around the web