Vladimir Putin's czarist folly

There are 30 comments on the The Miami Herald story from Apr 7, 2014, titled Vladimir Putin's czarist folly. In it, The Miami Herald reports that:

Oxford, England - Russian school textbooks praise Peter the Great as an industrializer and cultural visionary who turned his country into a European power.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at The Miami Herald.

First Prev
of 2
Next Last

Since: Oct 08

Location hidden

#1 Apr 7, 2014
Russian school textbooks praise Peter the Great as an industrializer and cultural visionary who turned his country into a European power. Russia became feared but also respected by its neighbors, and Peter is the official czar-hero of Russian history.

Vladimir Putin himself is much more like another czar, Nicholas I, who stumbled into military conflict with the British and French and rejected calls for the basic reforms needed to enable Russia to compete with the world powers of the day. Nicholas had a cramped perspective and arrogant personality. Always attentive to the armed forces and the secret services, he overlooked the broader necessity to modernize Russia’s economy and society. His country paid dearly for this when his army was humbled in the Crimean War of 1853-56.

Russian foreign policy under Mr. Putin displays an equally gross lack of foresight. On Ukraine, he made much of the threat to ethnic Russians from West Ukrainian “fascists” who were influencing political developments in Kiev. It is true that Ukraine’s right-wing coalition known as the Right Sector includes some decidedly insalubrious extremists. But not every partisan who waged the war of independence against the Soviet Army in the 1950s was a fascist; and by seizing the Crimean peninsula, Mr. Putin has set up a classic temptation for Russian patriots to extend to the whole of Ukraine.

One-eighth of the Crimean population, moreover, consists of Tatars, whom Joseph Stalin deported to Central Asia in 1944 and who were allowed to return to their native peninsula only in the late 1980s. They largely abstained from voting in the recent referendum on incorporation in the Russian Federation. Most are Muslims, and some of their young people could now become recruits for a jihad against Russian imperialism.

By snatching 4.5 percent of Ukrainian territory, Mr. Putin has performed the unlikely feat of wrecking his own dream of forming a “Eurasian Union” under Russia’s leadership. He once planned to keep President Viktor F. Yanukovych as his puppet ruler in Kiev. Now Mr. Yanukovych is a refugee somewhere in Russia, and Ukraine’s government is strengthening cooperation with the European Union.

This is a disaster for Mr. Putin’s foreign policy. Although he is concealing this from the public through his control of TV channels, he will not be able to fool all the people all of the time.

His biggest miscalculation is about Russia itself. The emergency over Ukraine has jolted the Russian superrich to ship even more of their wealth to the West. Up to $70 billion has left the country this year alone.

Mr. Putin prided himself on bringing stability after the tumultuous years of Boris N. Yeltsin’s rule. Capital flight on this scale tells a different story. The World Bank is sounding the alarm about a halving of Russia’s growth rate if Mr. Putin continues with his Ukrainian obsession.

Just as worrisome for the Russian president should be the phenomenon of human flight. Hundreds of thousands of the brightest young Russians have packed their bags and left for Silicon Valley, New York and London. This has been happening since the collapse of Communism, but Mr. Putin has done nothing to arrest the trend.

Young people leave out of exasperation with bully-boy administrators and violent entrepreneurs. They want to live in a meritocracy where talent alone is what counts. Their model is Google’s Sergey Brin, not the seedy ministers and businessmen of Mr. Putin’s court.

For the expatriates to want to go back to Russia, things have to change — and this is the true test of Mr. Putin’s effectiveness as a president. First elected in 2000, he has done little to clean up corruption. He spectacularly punished a handful of so-called oligarchs, only to redistribute their fortunes to political cronies. The rule of law is feebly enforced whenever the men of power see their interests at risk.

Since: Oct 08

Location hidden

#2 Apr 7, 2014
Nor has Mr. Putin done enough to diversify and open up Russia’s economy. For years — indeed, since Mikhail S. Gorbachev’s perestroika period — Russian and foreign economists have highlighted the need for the country to move beyond its reliance on the petrochemical exports. Prime Minister Dmitri A. Medvedev has always understood this, but he lacked the authority to rectify the situation.

Russia needs to pump out high-technology goods, not just oil and gas. And the rival power it ought to keep in sight is not to the west but to the south. Since the mid-1970s, China’s rulers have prioritized the diversification of their economy. This would be the minimal requirement to ensure Russia’s status as a Eurasian power. Instead, the Chinese are set to become a superpower while the Russians fall away.

Moscow’s opportunities to compete have always depended on cooperation with Western states with advanced technology. Mr. Putin’s impulsive action in tiny Crimea has rendered this a distant prospect. He has lost his place at the Group of 8 industrialized countries.

There was always skepticism about Mr. Putin’s good intentions in Eastern Europe; now there is outright hostility. Even Germany’s reliance on Russian gas imports has not stopped Chancellor Angela Merkel from rebuking Mr. Putin. The European Union is actively considering how to wean itself off dependency on Russian fuel.

Mr. Putin started the year with a display of Russian “soft power” at the Sochi Winter Olympics, where the closing ceremony presented a country of stylish, inoffensive sport and culture. The very next day, he sent troops to Crimea. And now the World Bank suggests Russia may suffer economic recession by the end of the year.

The signs are that Mr. Putin and Foreign Minister Sergey V. Lavrov are starting to appreciate the implications of their self-inflicted geopolitical blunder. Mr. Lavrov has at least begun to talk to Secretary of State John Kerry.

Western powers are not going to start a second Crimean war, but they have more opportunities to exert pressure on Russia than Mr. Putin imagined. He would do well to consider the precedent of Czar Nicholas I.
COLLAPSE in MOSCOW

Surrey, Canada

#3 Apr 8, 2014
"This is a disaster for Mr. Putin’s foreign policy. Although he is concealing this from the public through his control of TV channels, he will not be able to fool all the people all of the time.

His biggest miscalculation is about Russia itself. The emergency over Ukraine has jolted the Russian superrich to ship even more of their wealth to the West. Up to $70 billion has left the country this year alone.

Mr. Putin prided himself on bringing stability after the tumultuous years of Boris N. Yeltsin’s rule. Capital flight on this scale tells a different story....."

Yep.

Putin has set Russia back by DECADES!
Habsburger

Austria

#5 Apr 8, 2014
Peter the great was of german heritage and he married Katharina, a german Prinzess.
He stopped the war with the prussians because he was an absolute fan of Friedrich dem Großen.

this german princess became KATHARINA THE GREAT (murdered her husband Peter) and annexed crimea.

so a german princess made it first, an austrian Diktator did it too, and now the Story has an end.

USA we won the war.
Cold as He ll

Mosjøen, Norway

#6 Apr 8, 2014
Fu kk the ruskis, they now balance on the eggs. Nato show your strength for once

Down with russia
PROUD TO BE SERB

Australia

#7 Apr 8, 2014
Cold as He ll wrote:
Fu kk the ruskis, they now balance on the eggs. Nato show your strength for once
Down with russia
Down with NATO & America .
NATO & America a baking from a safe distance
Hau Hau Hau & more Hau Hau Hau. Lol
NATO & America lost Thai balls in Afganistan .
Will be no show from NATO & America . Lol.
Cold as He ll

Mosjøen, Norway

#8 Apr 8, 2014
PROUD TO BE SERB wrote:
<quoted text>
Down with NATO & America .
NATO & America a baking from a safe distance
Hau Hau Hau & more Hau Hau Hau. Lol
NATO & America lost Thai balls in Afganistan .
Will be no show from NATO & America . Lol.
Funny guy arent you?
Cold as He ll

Mosjøen, Norway

#9 Apr 8, 2014
Give NATO one week, and the poor ruskis would be a....ruin
PROUD TO BE SERB

Australia

#10 Apr 8, 2014
Cold as He ll wrote:
Give NATO one week, and the poor ruskis would be a....ruin
Hahahahahahaha . Please don't make me laughing so loude. You little boy.

Long live RUSSIA I SRBJIA
Cold as He ll

Mosjøen, Norway

#11 Apr 8, 2014
PROUD TO BE SERB wrote:
<quoted text>
Hahahahahahaha . Please don't make me laughing so loude. You little boy.
Long live RUSSIA I SRBJIA
Hahaha long live the West and NATO u little poor and unsecure boy.

How is your new lada from 89 lolllllllllll
Cold as He ll

Mosjøen, Norway

#12 Apr 8, 2014
Or maye it is a moscowitch or a stole car for the West lol
PROUD TO BE SERB

Australia

#13 Apr 8, 2014
Cold as He ll wrote:
<quoted text>
Hahaha long live the West and NATO u little poor and unsecure boy.
How is your new lada from 89 lolllllllllll
I drive ""BLACK VOLGA""
PLEASE don't have a collision with me.
You will look like a pancake. Lol.
Cold as He ll

Mosjøen, Norway

#15 Apr 8, 2014
PROUD TO BE SERB wrote:
<quoted text>
I drive ""BLACK VOLGA""
PLEASE don't have a collision with me.
You will look like a pancake. Lol.
yea right

SWG

Since: Feb 10

Houston, Texas

#16 Apr 8, 2014
Cold as He ll wrote:
<quoted text>
Funny guy arent you?
No Cold, as barney Fiffe would say..."He's a NUT!!!"
PROUD TO BE SERB

Adelaide, Australia

#17 Apr 8, 2014
I spy with my little eye. And I see nothing, and I
Hear nothing.
We're is NATO & America . No where to be seen.
Lol.
JBH

Delta, Canada

#18 Apr 8, 2014
The pendulum of the new world has changed and is swinging against US and NATO.
Despite there are less US-born talents while 50% working in US research, bigger companies and technology firms are educated foreign-born people, the new world has more talents than US.
Among scores of teenagers in tests of solving problems, intelligence rating, reading and comprehension, US ranks only at the 18th spot.
It is a foreseeable future that US will have immense problems and difficulties facing the uprising world.
China and India have more Ph. D.s in the ratios of 8 times and more.
Real talents stay in Russia and many other countries where they were born at, which would pose the jeopardy of US future on the planet.
By the year 2023, so many countries and North Korea will have devices that can reach to US, such AS THE HYPERSONIC GLIDE VEHICLE.
Although US has THE HYPERSONIC GLIDE VEHICLE already, China also has it, while Russia, North Korea, India and some other nations are also developing it -- this means US military is of no use (including on defense) to act on US policies around the world, that US and NATO will easily suffer serious defeats.
These facts ascertain that US is under the critical damaging direction by facing the new emerging uprising world.
Yet, those who still think US and NATO are mighty, just don't know the real world these days as It is totally different from the past, including the cold war days.
US and NATO look powerless in regard to the Ukraine crisis and Crimea matter with their sanctions. But, there are still more uprising and protests in East Ukraine which will give US and EU more detriments.
Thus, US and NATO will look for more destruction and damages when times moves on.
This new world changes to give the view that US is merely a loser, when the emerging new-age planet surges up, that indeed, the pendulum of the new world is swinging against US and NATO.
I can read

Edinburgh, UK

#19 Apr 9, 2014
The real question is:

Is putin more dangerous than George bush was?

Both are mental cases with severely delusional ideas and both seem to get off on killing people, both have access to large numbers of nukes.
PROUD TO BE SERB

Australia

#20 Apr 9, 2014
JBH wrote:
The pendulum of the new world has changed and is swinging against US and NATO.
Despite there are less US-born talents while 50% working in US research, bigger companies and technology firms are educated foreign-born people, the new world has more talents than US.
Among scores of teenagers in tests of solving problems, intelligence rating, reading and comprehension, US ranks only at the 18th spot.
It is a foreseeable future that US will have immense problems and difficulties facing the uprising world.
China and India have more Ph. D.s in the ratios of 8 times and more.
Real talents stay in Russia and many other countries where they were born at, which would pose the jeopardy of US future on the planet.
By the year 2023, so many countries and North Korea will have devices that can reach to US, such AS THE HYPERSONIC GLIDE VEHICLE.
Although US has THE HYPERSONIC GLIDE VEHICLE already, China also has it, while Russia, North Korea, India and some other nations are also developing it -- this means US military is of no use (including on defense) to act on US policies around the world, that US and NATO will easily suffer serious defeats.
These facts ascertain that US is under the critical damaging direction by facing the new emerging uprising world.
Yet, those who still think US and NATO are mighty, just don't know the real world these days as It is totally different from the past, including the cold war days.
US and NATO look powerless in regard to the Ukraine crisis and Crimea matter with their sanctions. But, there are still more uprising and protests in East Ukraine which will give US and EU more detriments.
Thus, US and NATO will look for more destruction and damages when times moves on.
This new world changes to give the view that US is merely a loser, when the emerging new-age planet surges up, that indeed, the pendulum of the new world is swinging against US and NATO.
The war in SRBJIA is finish: NATO & USA .

Long live SRBJIA I RUSSIA
rio

London, UK

#21 Apr 9, 2014
Habsburger wrote:
Peter the great was of german heritage and he married Katharina, a german Prinzess.
He stopped the war with the prussians because he was an absolute fan of Friedrich dem Großen.
this german princess became KATHARINA THE GREAT (murdered her husband Peter) and annexed crimea.
so a german princess made it first, an austrian Diktator did it too, and now the Story has an end.
USA we won the war.
George Bush had German ancestry as well. So had Eisehower...

If I was you, I wouldn't brag about that!
BREADLINES of MOSCOW

Surrey, Canada

#22 Apr 9, 2014
James wrote:
Russia has not counted for anything as a world power since the early 1980s.
True!

Russia's economy is only slightly larger than Italy's or Canada's; countries with a fraction of Russia's population! A declining, second-rate regional power, as Obama said.

And Putin's Big Adventure is going to destroy what little Russia has left!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 2
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Oxfordshire County, England Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News David Cameron in election battle with a muppet ... Apr '15 Christshariahns 1
News Willmett Solicitors believed to be in administr... (Dec '09) Feb '15 Rezilliant 1,211
News Canadian IT company headed by 'Shark Tank' co-s... Feb '15 Laura 1
News The Fox and Goat at Tiddington has been given a... (Nov '14) Jan '15 Tiddington resident 3
News Too many children's social worker posts are unf... Dec '14 Eleanor 1
News Who is David Oyelowo? Dec '14 Mr Wadi 4
News Why are French women sexier than the British? (Jun '10) Dec '14 andreas mathiszik 117
More from around the web