Self-proclaimed experts exploit ignor...

Self-proclaimed experts exploit ignorance of Islam

There are 63 comments on the The Indianapolis Star story from Apr 4, 2007, titled Self-proclaimed experts exploit ignorance of Islam. In it, The Indianapolis Star reports that:

The local Muslim community is very concerned about Robert Spencer's invitation from the local FBI office to talk about Islam and terrorism.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at The Indianapolis Star.

First Prev
of 4
Next Last


#64 Apr 7, 2007
reader wrote:
<quoted text>
Murder of any innocent person must be condemned. I have not seen Van Goh's film and donot know anything about it. Those who committed Van Goh's muder must be treated as criminals.
Let me emphasize that arranged marriages are very common in Asia and Africa. It cannnot be judged from the Wetern eye. There are pro-and con- arguments for any social institution. Although I donot wish to pass any judgment on the dating system (supposedly freedom to chose spouse),there is very little divorce in arranged marriage system. It is for the people of the culture to accept or reject a particular social institution of their culture. Outsiders should not judge that institution from their eyes.
Did Hirsi Ali exploit the ignorance of arrange marriage system in the West for her personal gain?
So if you didn't see the film, how can you accuse the filmmakers of being "opportunists"?

And, I'm not as fake diplomatic as you are. Arranged marriages are barbaric affronts to civilized society. The reason there's very little divorce in that system is because unhappy, oppositional, and otherwise wayward spouses are usually killed by their husbands, with the full sanction of the state. The rise in so-called "honor killings" in Europe is quite alarming in fact.

However, once again, has any assertion Ali and the late Van Gogh made about the subjugation of women in radical Islam been proven false? All of these tangential objections you are raising serves the purpose of stifling an honest debate on the actual topic that got Van Gogh butchered and Ali forced into hiding.


#65 Apr 7, 2007
reader wrote:
<quoted text>
Did Hirsi Ali on C-Span not too long ago claim to be a practicing Muslim and was only interested in reforming Islam?
Then again, on Colbert Report on Commedy Channel,just about 10-12 days ago, she claimed that she was an atheist. Which one of her statements is true?
There are some people in this world who would sell their souls for material gains--people who know they can land good jobs or get a high standard of living. Such people know what will sell in the West and how to exploit the climate for personal gain. People, who are deeply anti-Islam are willing to accomodate such people for it fits their agenda.
I frankly don't believe your assertions. Would you care to provide actual video evidence that Ali said these things on C-Span and Colbert? Dates? Verifiable transcripts?

Hamilton, New Zealand

#66 Apr 9, 2009
inshallah of da person's username koran reader sooo true may allah bless u

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 4
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

The Tavis Smiley Show Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Karen Grigsby Bates (Jan '11) Jan '11 Fora 1
News Talk-show host Tavis Smiley tackles Obama and race (Jul '08) Dec '10 Mombasa Bay 59
News Prince opens up to public TV's Tavis Smiley (Apr '09) Apr '09 Gloria Carter 1
News Rahm Emanuel grilled by NBC "Meet the Press" ho... (Feb '09) Mar '09 John M 4
News Tavis Smiley's Big Weekend: The State of the Bl... (Feb '09) Feb '09 Da 9th Element 9
News Radio Host Says Tavis Smiley May Have Left Show... (Nov '08) Nov '08 TARA WALTON 1
News Talk-show host Tavis Smiley tackles Obama and race (Jul '08) Jul '08 Question Authority 7
More from around the web