Judge Mathis is no judge
First Prev
of 6
Next Last
Melanie

Round Lake, IL

#1 Aug 5, 2008
I like to watch the court shows and I have seen many of them. My favorite is People's Court, I love Judge Milian. The only problem is, Judge Mathis is on before she is. I have unfortunately seen some of his episodes and I don't know who made him a judge but I think that was the worst thing they have ever did. Don't get me wrong, it has nothing to do with race. Judge Milian is Cuban and she is wonderful. Every single show that I watch of hers I agree with her. She is the most fairest judge of all time. Just about everytime I watch Mathis, his rulings are outrageous! I don't get his logic at all. There were these two sisters who were on his show, one of them borrowed the other over $4,000 in loans. He seemed to be on the sister's side who borrowed the money and there was very good proof that any other judge would have ruled for her. Once the other sister said that the one sister made racial remarks his whole demeanor changed and he dismissed the case. He totally changed his demeanor of the sister who should have got her money. Her sister had no defense on why she shouldn't pay her sister back. She just kept on talking crap about her sister, calling her a sex addict and a baby factory and that she is jealous of her (even though she borrowed $4000 from her not the other way around) and that she was racist and made remarks. So she had no defense whatsoever and the other sister had evidence but once the racial remarks came out he dismissed the case. Judge Mathis is supposed to make objective decisions not personal ones because someone made a racial remark and he doesnt like them. What is that?
mikkey

Lutz, FL

#2 Sep 17, 2008
i totally agree with you. i have seen this happen several times.
real

Pensacola, FL

#3 Nov 10, 2008
your just racist thats why youdont like hi>>>growup its 2008!!!!!!!!!!
Lacy

Norman, OK

#5 Jan 22, 2009
I just watched an a court case of Judge Mathis and realize how unfair and racist he is and yes he is a black man! He is the worst judge on TV and should have never ever been given the privilege to make judgments on others lives! On the other end of the spectrum, one of the best judges and most fair is Judge Karen. She listens to every ones stores and makes the most appropriate judgment! She is amazing, fair, and well deserving of her title!
Heather

United States

#6 Jan 27, 2009
I agree. He seems to take an instant dislike to some people and tends to blow them off no matter what. I watched one episode where he waxed elegant on a woman's breast and how pretty she was. Innappropriate. Note...she won the case hands down (what a shocker). He isn't a judge so much as a temperamental actor.
Corella Daville

Dallas, TX

#7 May 8, 2009
Although sometimes he makes me laugh, today was not one of those days. The "Judge" had a white mother and her white daughter on there, and seemed to take pleasure in being the "Superior all mighty man in charge" of their case. I felt he degraded the daughter in front of her mother. He knows nothing about white kids. He ASSumes they are all spoiled little brats that talk back to mommy.
In reality, there is alot of abuse going on in white families -- it is just more swept under the rug EXAMPLE: Caylee Anthony - Who really fathered that child -- I'm just sayin
Why did her father try to commit suicide?
Not saying that is the case there, but some white families have dads sleeping with the daughters,
mothers who are functioning alcoholics, but because they are white families, he just slaps them into the "spoiled white folk" catagory.
Judge Mathis doesn't know a damn thing about white families -- he only assumes like he does.
He only knows HIS life experiences. His life is not everybody's life.
Little White johnie is always spoiled --no, sometimes little white Johnie may have been sleeping with big white daddy --and Little crackhead Suzie may have been raped by hers.
Mr Wilz

Edmond, OK

#8 Jun 26, 2009
You guys are talking about a TV show. What about all the real white racist judges in America who give blacks harsher sentences for the same crimes. And if you don't believe that look it up. Who cares about a TV show, lets talk about the real thing.
Kai

Elkton, MD

#10 Jul 8, 2009
I totally agree with all of you. I am black myself so i do not consider this a racial thing nor am i trying to bring down black people at all or anything but frankly Judge Mathis is completely unfair, bias, and racist. FLAT OUT. My mother watches his show all the time so I have seen plenty of plenty of his shows and each time I spend the thirty minutes pointing out how unjust he really is. Judge Mathis is no judge!
Hellen

Bellaire, TX

#11 Jul 20, 2009
I just watched an episode today,(July 20, 2009), where a white guy was suing a black guy for throwing a brick and breaking his window. Judge Mathis asserted that the white guy was lying because he never asked why the black threw the brick,(even though the white guy kept trying to interject that he had asked the D.A. SEVERAL TIMES!), and that people don't just throw bricks for now reason....GIVE ME A BREAK!!! Ohhh...nooo...people don't throw bricks or stab or rape or even kill for no reason. He awarded the white guy his money,(only because the black guy admitted to the crime, and was proven guilty in a criminal trial), however he also awarded the black guy monies for emotional distress....really?? Give me a freakin' break! Usually in the past, he has made anyone who is suing for Emotional distress bring in proof that they are being treated by a doctor for it!!! Didn't even ask this guy. Just pandered to him. Totally a racist move!!! I was appalled. I really like People's Court-Judge Milian is not a Racist idiot like Judge Mathis!!!!
Darnitchico

AOL

#12 Jul 27, 2009
Judge Mathis is a Raciest Bully.Any White person agreeing to appear as a litigant on his show is doing so at their own legal peril--He is also very disrepectful to many of the litigants and loves to hit them with a verbal barrage of insults as he is ruling unfairly against them, leaving many in disbelief as what just hit them.
I have no racial bones to pick I dislike white
bullys also.
deb

Milton, FL

#13 Aug 5, 2009
mikkey wrote:
i totally agree with you. i have seen this happen several times.
Yes i have notice judge mathis is a racist. I was watching him today and it was about this white lady and black man and the white lady family is racist.(They were together at one time) But, Judge Mathis blame the white lady for her family racisim. He drilled that lady and picked her apart until he could find something to end the case and the black man won. I thought there were rules a judge had to go by before he can make a rule. But, He is very much a racist. I don't know why it is allowed to go on. My husband watches his show. I tell him he should not watch it and support the show since he is racist. But, He keeps watching it. I am not racist at all but i don't support those that are racist black or white.
Mary

Rochester, MI

#14 Aug 6, 2009
I love all the court shows..my favorite judges are Judge Millian, Judge Joe Brown, and of course Judge Judy..However, I cannot stand Judge Mathis..he is a total racist. I cannot believe that his show is still on. If I ever were to sue anyone there is no way I would get a fair chance in his courtroom. I really feel bad for white people who had to stand in front of him when he was a judge in Illinois..Scary.
Lisa

Fremont, CA

#15 Aug 15, 2009
Judge Mathis is a joke to the judicial system. He is a racist, cocky, classless, unethical, narrow minded idiot. Saw that same episode as Hellen, where he actually blamed the victim for not asking why the brick was thrown at him. Really? Are you serious? Judge Mathis does not deserve to have a show, and is in no way a role model to anyone!! BTW...you know he goes around saying stuff like "honky" LOL Judge Mathis....can shove it!!
Mathis is a Racist

Goose Creek, SC

#16 Aug 17, 2009
Hellen wrote:
I just watched an episode today,(July 20, 2009), where a white guy was suing a black guy for throwing a brick and breaking his window. Judge Mathis asserted that the white guy was lying because he never asked why the black threw the brick,(even though the white guy kept trying to interject that he had asked the D.A. SEVERAL TIMES!), and that people don't just throw bricks for now reason....GIVE ME A BREAK!!! Ohhh...nooo...people don't throw bricks or stab or rape or even kill for no reason. He awarded the white guy his money,(only because the black guy admitted to the crime, and was proven guilty in a criminal trial), however he also awarded the black guy monies for emotional distress....really?? Give me a freakin' break! Usually in the past, he has made anyone who is suing for Emotional distress bring in proof that they are being treated by a doctor for it!!! Didn't even ask this guy. Just pandered to him. Totally a racist move!!! I was appalled. I really like People's Court-Judge Milian is not a Racist idiot like Judge Mathis!!!!
I just watched the rerun of this case. I could not believe what I was seeing. The white guy called 911 when the guy threw a brick through his window, but I guess he should have stopped the car and asked him why he threw the brick. What about emotional distress of having a brick come through your car window. Of course he took out some time to make fun of the white guy and to give the black guy advise on having the criminal charges expunged.

Lesson learned: If you are black you can commit random acts of violence against white people and Judge Mathis will reward you $1,500 for your trouble.
ADAM

Auburn Hills, MI

#17 Aug 27, 2009
OKAY ALREADY, THE PERSON WHO STARTED THIS TOPIC IS RACIST iTS CLEAR SHES WHITE. IN ACTUALITY DO A SURVEY ON JUDGE MILLIAN, NoBODY BLACK WINS, MAYBE 3 OUT OF 50..PAY ATTENTION
Jared

Indianapolis, IN

#18 Sep 2, 2009
ADAM wrote:
OKAY ALREADY, THE PERSON WHO STARTED THIS TOPIC IS RACIST iTS CLEAR SHES WHITE. IN ACTUALITY DO A SURVEY ON JUDGE MILLIAN, NoBODY BLACK WINS, MAYBE 3 OUT OF 50..PAY ATTENTION
lol man I'm not even sure where to start with this ignorant garbage...

Ok if topic starter is a racist because of disagreeing with a judges ruling (who is of the opposite race), then WTF does that make you?

You must be a racist calling the topic starter who is calling Judge Mathis an unfair judge by basing his verdict on something other than the actual case.

Where does it end you moron? Guess what black people can be racists also. I deal with it all the time in Indianapolis.

When Judge Mathis wakes up in the morning and puts on his big boy pants and goes to work its his job to view the cases with a fair mind. If I owe some Black panther piece of garbage 10,000 dollars rightfully so...I should have to legally pay that back as well as be found guilty in a court of law. I firmly believe that Judge Mathis is a prime example of why Affirmative action is a joke, because it produces people who don't know what the hell they are doing.

Also, Judge Millan doesn't align herself with race hucksters of the likes of Jesse Jackson, Al Sharpton, and Louis Farrakan(These 3 are the blame whitey for everything coalition). Judge Millan doesn't give long winded pointless speeches about race that have nothing to do with the case. She doesn't always jump on the bandwagon anytime someone of her same race is trouble by someone of X race.

In conclusion....you're a moron and have provided no evidence of anything other than the fact that your CAPS LOCK IS STUCK!!!!
Sakasama

Milwaukee, WI

#19 Sep 17, 2009
real wrote:
your just racist thats why youdont like hi>>>growup its 2008!!!!!!!!!!
oh, the 'MAGIC reply' to everyone who doesn't aggree with a black skinned person... U 'GROW UP'! Everybody in this country is FED UP with people like you screaming RACIST whenever someone disagrees with or critisizes a 'person of color'... u and people like you are the worst racists of them all!
Lisa

Antioch, CA

#20 Oct 8, 2009
HAHA Jared....too funny!! We don't like Judge Mathis...because he's an idiot. Not because he's black. Idiots come in all colors....just happens to be black this time...AND a judge...which is disturbing to some of us. My dislike of Judge Mathis stems from his treatment of people in his courtroom. He does seem to be quite racist. Judges should be morally grounded.... Judge Mathis is NOT!
Blinded for truth

South Africa

#21 Oct 28, 2009
Man you all must be real thick headed, Judge Mathis can be extremeley opinionated at times but he cuts trhough the BS in no time, he observe not only the written facts presented to him but the attidute of the deffendants as well, based on that plus the fact that most of the white people on his show are nothing but white trash, one can only understands why he rules againts them. I am white but I am not blind.
GoBacktoEatingSu bsJared

Ellensburg, WA

#22 Nov 3, 2009
Jared wrote:
<quoted text>

The problem is one of those idiots has a TV show.
Maybe one day you will evolve as a human and see the blatent hypocracy in the African American community.
No- the problem is morons like you who want things both ways. You try to portray yourself as an educated person, yet you reveal your ignorance and bigotry by casually dismissing African Americans as idiots and hypocrites. You overreact to a legitimate point the previous writer made regarding well-documented inequities in the judicial system and end up displaying yourself as someone possessing the very traits you are so critical of.

By the way, you would do a much better job of showing off your pseudo-superiority by actually spelling words correctly.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 6
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Judge Mathis Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Expungement question? (May '15) May '15 cleanliving 1
eviction (Jan '14) Dec '14 Take back america 2
multiple personalities i (Sep '13) Sep '13 Beth 1
judge judy in black (Jul '13) Jul '13 respecteveryone 1
The Plantiff and Defendant from Snellville,... (Apr '13) Apr '13 Sallie Miinor 1
homosexualality (Feb '13) Feb '13 Rhonda 2
News Porn bills were likely motive for slaying of Ad... (Mar '10) Sep '12 GAIL L MOORE 34
More from around the web