TV Tuesday - A New "Idol" Judge? No T...

TV Tuesday - A New "Idol" Judge? No Thanks, Dawg.

There are 3 comments on the Post Tribune story from Aug 26, 2008, titled TV Tuesday - A New "Idol" Judge? No Thanks, Dawg.. In it, Post Tribune reports that:

"American Idol" needs to do something to fight off sliding ratings. But adding a new judge shouldn't be it.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Post Tribune.



#1 Nov 14, 2008
The comments from the judges have become boring. I am sick of Ryan's attack and obnoxious smart mouth remarks to Simon. These make Simon appear quite likable in comparison. So shut Ryan's attitude down. He appears to think he is the star now. Paula always likes everybody's performance once the top ten is chosen. Randy used to give constructive suggestions for improvement to all contestants...He was my favorite because of that but he no longer does. Seems to not care anymore.


#2 Nov 14, 2008
As for a new judge added, I think a different guest judge each week would work better. To add a new one permanently appears to be a desperate attempt to put some spark back into the competition. It is my opinion the popularity of the show dropping is because the show has changed too much from the original. The talent is not as exciting to watch and it doesn't make me want to be sure I don't miss it each week. The last couple of years if something else came along to do, I just didn't watch it. It didn't matter a lot.

Garden City, NY

#3 Nov 17, 2008
NOPE to that new judge gay gay gayyyyyy!!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Hey Paula Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Brooke White leaves 'Idol' on a high note (May '08) Apr '12 popper 2
News Paula Abdul: A Timeline Of The Former 'Idol' Ju... (Aug '09) Aug '09 Kym 1
News Can 'American Idol' still be a star without Paula? (Aug '09) Aug '09 WTF 1
News Paula and Idol doing plenty of posturing (Jul '09) Jul '09 Lori 1
News Abdul poised to leave 'Idol' (Jul '09) Jul '09 Gayle Freeze 1
More from around the web