'Breaking Amish': Amish go to NYC in new reality show

There are 20 comments on the Sep 7, 2012, Philly.com story titled 'Breaking Amish': Amish go to NYC in new reality show. In it, Philly.com reports that:

Kate, a bishop's daughter from Lancaster County, stars in a new reality show about five Amish kids finding their way in New York City.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Philly.com.

First Prev
of 2
Next Last
caro

Blairsville, PA

#1 Sep 16, 2012
who is kates real father
Eric Simmons

Dunedin, New Zealand

#2 Sep 16, 2012
This is pretty much like the Amish TV series called "World's Squarest Teenagers", who went to Britain to see the outside world.
caro

Blairsville, PA

#3 Sep 19, 2012
how would an amish person who has never been outside of puxsatawney pa know to request an additional bed in her room-hmmm this is all bogus
Mother

United States

#4 Sep 23, 2012
caro wrote:
how would an amish person who has never been outside of puxsatawney pa know to request an additional bed in her room-hmmm this is all bogus
Maybe because They said if you need anything call the front desk?!?! DUH!!!
American InnKeeper

Newport, AR

#5 Oct 30, 2012
caro wrote:
how would an amish person who has never been outside of puxsatawney pa know to request an additional bed in her room-hmmm this is all bogus
Film crew may have had to get a rollaway in their rooms? There would have been alot of logistics & contracts to sign before the show. Its not like they kidnapped them.
Anonymous

Whittier, CA

#6 Nov 18, 2012
Rebecca's not the sharpest tool in the shed. She doesn't think a guy who wants to marry her needs to know if she's been married before?!

What an idiot.
ILoveRebeccaByle r

Altoona, PA

#7 Nov 19, 2012
I think Rebecca is hot, hot, hot, definitely the prettiest girl ever in Punxsutawney, she is just so doggone sexy, and has a fantastic body and smile, to bad she married that loser Abe......
mary

Punxsutawney, PA

#8 Nov 19, 2012
ILoveRebeccaByler wrote:
I think Rebecca is hot, hot, hot, definitely the prettiest girl ever in Punxsutawney, she is just so doggone sexy, and has a fantastic body and smile, to bad she married that loser Abe......
can we say stalker,,,,,,
Anonymous

Pico Rivera, CA

#9 Nov 19, 2012
mary wrote:
<quoted text> can we say stalker,,,,,,
I would say hard up, if he thinks Rebecca is hot. LOL!!
ILoveRebeccaByle r

Altoona, PA

#10 Nov 19, 2012
mary wrote:
<quoted text> can we say stalker,,,,,,
I'm sorry Honey, I didn't think you would see my posts on here.....

Since: Oct 12

Location hidden

#11 Nov 22, 2012
This is all madeup BS....if they even, ever were amish, they haven't been for years....NBC's pointy heads are trying to attract viewers from, Nat/Geo's excellent series about Ex-Amish.....
haa

Punxsutawney, PA

#12 Nov 27, 2012
i like theatgeos versinon... some of his fake but they miht do 1 moe show out of them 2...
haa

Punxsutawney, PA

#13 Nov 27, 2012
ahh my keyboard sucks

Since: Oct 12

Location hidden

#14 Nov 27, 2012
Yeah sure, the tall girl is really hot, especially for amish....and yes, we would like to boink her ears off.....what?
ky girl

Salyersville, KY

#15 Dec 4, 2012
ILoveRebeccaByler wrote:
I think Rebecca is hot, hot, hot, definitely the prettiest girl ever in Punxsutawney, she is just so doggone sexy, and has a fantastic body and smile, to bad she married that loser Abe......
man u must be hard up to think that come on surely thier r prettier women than that if not god help u single men u need to move
amw

Ellicott City, MD

#16 Aug 18, 2013
Now breaking Amish got a new cast one is pregnant.

Since: Oct 12

Location hidden

#17 Aug 19, 2013
tHESE ARE NOW...fAKE REALITY SHOWS....
Candy

Richmond, VA

#18 May 13, 2014
Here they come ,back again,what bologna will they try to sell this time?
amw

New York, NY

#19 May 13, 2014
Is kate still amodel
Rebecca is pregnant 2nd time
Who is the father of Sabrina baby
Candy

Richmond, VA

#20 May 14, 2014
Yes ,I saw the promo.the old women sure gets under my skin.i just don't like her.i don't think any of them are very bright,but why bring her into this?

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 2
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Drama Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Jon Bon Jovi Will Ponder Alternate Life in New ... 4 hr MGJoeViterbo 8
News Author/Actor Raymond E. Lumsden Gets Thumbs Up ... (Mar '09) 5 hr pathetic 1,814
News South Yorkshire police accused of missing 'inte... 12 hr Belle Sexton 1
News Terri Schiavo's Painful Deprivation of Food and... (Mar '09) 14 hr hornback12 1,217
News Www.CoryandTopanga.Com No Longer Exists, Consid... (Aug '07) 19 hr NotAFreak 43
News In the Search for an Alternative to God, One Ra... (Mar '11) Thu Joy Joy 696
News Endangered Species': Christianity at the Brink ... Thu SpaceBlues 19
More from around the web