Is Obama’s Advance Clemency for Illeg...

Is Obama’s Advance Clemency for Illegal Aliens Constitutional?

Posted in the Tucson Forum


United States

#1 Jun 17, 2012
The Constitution does not mention the word “immigration,” but in Article I, Section 8 it clearly limits naturalization to Congress. Immigration is the preliminary, qualifying stage for naturalization; that is, for becoming a foreign-born citizen of the United States.

Naturalization comes under Title III of the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1952. It follows Title II of that Act, which is titled “Immigration.” This Act was passed by Congress (not by executive order) on June 27, 1952. It became law on December 24, 1952 after Congress overrode a veto by the President Harry Truman. The fact that Democrat President Truman unsuccessfully tried to stop the Act from becoming law by veto is prima facie evidence that immigration laws fall exclusively within the purview of Congressional authority. Although there have been amendments to the Act, it is basically the same as it was in 1952 as regards the qualifications for naturalization.

In order to become naturalized, an immigrant must first be LAWFULLY ADMITTED to the United States. This means that he/she must first comply with Title III of the Act. Among the qualifications: The applicant must complete a period of LEGAL residence (normally five years); must be proficient in English, U.S. History and not have any felony convictions.

Clearly, Obama’s executive order, granting advance clemency to aliens illegally in the United States, is an attempt to abnegate Title III of the Immigration and Nationality Act.

Obama’s advance clemency for illegal aliens, before any charges of deportation have been filed against most of them, is clearly a step to help them circumvent our immigration and naturalization laws. Its timing says it all, as for as Obama’s motive is concerned. The Supreme Court is expected to rule as early as Monday, June 18, 2012 as to the Constitutionality of Arizona’s law regarding State enforcement of immigration laws. Joe Arpaio, Sheriff of Arizona’s most populous county, Maricopa, says that he will begin enforcement of Arizona’s law as soon as it is declared Constitutional. It is inconceivable the AZ law would be declared unconstitutional, since there is a federal law already on the books authorizing state and local law enforcement officers to arrest illegal aliens. See title 8, United States Code 1357(g), or simply 8 USC 1357)g).

Obama’s illegal clemency act for illegal aliens is obviously a measure to garner support of the so-called Latino community. His, and the Democrats’ concept of the “Latino,” lumps them all into one group. It ignores that most of them have complied with our laws and want to be able to compete for jobs in the U.S. as tradition al law-abiding citizens without being discriminated against because of their Hispanic surnames. Obama’s act will have a negative impact for law-abiding U.S. citizens with Hispanic surnames. He fallaciously assumes that radicals, who are self-appointed spokespersons for illegal aliens, speak for ALL Hispanics in the U.S., when in fact they are self-serving political activists who are seeking more political power for themselves and more government handouts and grants for their organizations.
Tammy Gonzales

Crested Butte, CO

#2 Dec 15, 2012
I think that people are people GOD made us all equal and I think we should be ashamed of ourselves for thinking that any part of the beautiful earth that God gave us belongs only to someone born there. As well as we should be ashamed to think that a hard working person should not be allowed into our communities just because they did not go through the lengthy and expensive process to become legal. I think that if they have been paying taxes and lawabiding [with the exception of course of being an illegal] that clemency is a no brainer they already have paid their dues by paying taxes.
Caged Rage

Durham, NC

#3 Sep 17, 2013
Tammy, I agree with people being equal, but the fact of the matter is that most illegal aliens do NOT pay taxes, and still collect government welfare, which wastes citizen taxes.
car mat

Lexington, KY

#4 Oct 17, 2013
338 billion dollars a year to keep up all the illegals in america and obuma is for it

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Tucson Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Gregory A Bottoni - Murderer, Child Molester, h... Wed ConcernedParent 1
Review: A Gob's Towing (Jul '09) Mar 18 Little Danny 5
Best area to move to in Tuscon. (Apr '17) Mar 11 Vic 15
Personal Loan in a Tight Spot Needed! (Jul '17) Mar 8 mark 3
Shawn miller Mar 4 Just saying 1
News Agents find 12 illegal aliens held in mobile home Mar 3 ONLYONETERM 12
tweeker chick needed Feb 28 myserty mann 1

Tucson Jobs

Personal Finance

Tucson Mortgages