Should Brother + Sister marriages be ...

Should Brother + Sister marriages be legalized ?

Created by Love my Brother on Dec 8, 2007

1,692 votes

Click on an option to vote

YES, it's about time !!

NO, it's against my religion !

Only if they are half-siblings

First Prev
of 41
Next Last
West Coast Guy

San Antonio, TX

#878 Apr 15, 2014
Maybe it's time to get out of the business of saying who can and can't marry by having two rules to satisfy:

1 - Anyone 18 years of age or older may marry anyone else who is 18 years of age or older without regard to any other factor.

2 - Multiple adults may form a plural marriage provided every member of the marriage separately marries every other member of the marriage.

Regulations:

- These rules are not binding on any religion. I.E. You may enjoy a legal civil marriage under these rules but a religion may determine the union to be in some way unacceptable within its faith.

- Bigamy rules will only be applicable in a plural marriage where all are not married to each other and then only if one of the participants files a complaint.

- Sexual intercourse between an adult and a minor or between two minors separated in either case by more than two years of age shall be unlawful statutory rape.

- Sexual intercourse for a fee shall be legal provided it does not constitute statutory rape.
rbt

Chicago, IL

#880 Jun 25, 2014
I love my half sister and i'm not hurting anyone,it's our business for we love one another. Men marry men,the same for the woman,now that quire ass sickly.I love her like a wife for there's no fear,hurt or shame for the love i have for her,we've so much in common like we're meant to be together. I can't help it that i'm in love with her but it sure feels good.
Lab28

Anaheim, CA

#882 Jun 25, 2014
Brilliant! Let's just undo thousands of years of social engineering because I lust after my sister. I'm sure that the only reason incest is wildly taboo is due to prejudice and there can't be any practical reason that it is frowned upon.
Sure, let's legalize prostitution as well, I'm sure that doing that won't cause any kind of lasting social problems for generations to come. Oh yeah, and polygamy... Great idea, I think women have enjoyed some semblance of equality for far too long.
So, I'll let you know how this all works out after my sister and I finish purchasing enough wives to satisfy me and I've fathered a small army. Doesn't sound backwards at all... Sounds exactly like a world I want to live in.

Since: Apr 13

Scappoose, Oregon USA

#883 Jun 26, 2014
I have no desire to marry my brother, recreational FWB with him is one thing. But I'm not walking down the aisle with the guy! LOL

Since: Jan 13

Location hidden

#884 Jun 27, 2014
Lab28 wrote:
Brilliant! Let's just undo thousands of years of social engineering because I lust after my sister. I'm sure that the only reason incest is wildly taboo is due to prejudice and there can't be any practical reason that it is frowned upon.
Sure, let's legalize prostitution as well, I'm sure that doing that won't cause any kind of lasting social problems for generations to come. Oh yeah, and polygamy... Great idea, I think women have enjoyed some semblance of equality for far too long.
So, I'll let you know how this all works out after my sister and I finish purchasing enough wives to satisfy me and I've fathered a small army. Doesn't sound backwards at all... Sounds exactly like a world I want to live in.
Is this in sarcasm font?
Taking that it is.......

wildly taboo for ignorance reasons... people knew of genetic predispostions but didn't have the same knowledge as they do now.... you are no more likely to cause genetic abnormalities between brother sister than anyone else.... unless both have the hereditary gene. And, it became taboo for religious reasons..... probably the fall to blame for that. Some interbreeding of families does increase the likelyhood of genetic damage if overdone... take historical royal families for instances...... but that takes time. so if legalised a careful consideration would need to be made to stop that from happening. sex in families is frowned upon because of potential child abuse ...which is rightly so, but by time we're talking about marriage we're not talking children.
legalisaing prostitution would not cause any social problems lasting generations or at all... it would in fact reduce them..... why taboo something which is going on, has been going on all the time.... legalising it would make everyone safer and corrupt no-one.
polygymy works out alright for many.... some mormans for instance..... like any of these things... it's not for the majority.... but why dictate to a few of what they can or can't do to themselves... it's didadic, unnessesary and patronising

Since: Aug 14

United States

#886 Aug 2, 2014
True freedom is all but impossible as long as laws reflect superstitions & archaic religious dogmas. Believe, say, consume, do what you will but only as far as it doesn't infringe upon another's freedom.
So yes, absolutely. The only "sin" is that governments are being used like mafia enforcers/hitmen for religio-nazis
MLN

Huntsville, AL

#887 Aug 12, 2014
Jenji wrote:
I have no desire to marry my brother, recreational FWB with him is one thing. But I'm not walking down the aisle with the guy! LOL
I find it interesting that you enjoy sex with with your brother. My sis and I loved each other but mores and laws of society prevented marriage. Incest sex is the best.
PDX Dave

Portland, OR

#888 Aug 12, 2014
Yes absolutely it should be legal, just like marriage between any two consenting adults. Blood relation, gender, sexual orientation-none of it makes any difference. And when it comes to a married couple of siblings, I would think their sex life would be terrific! This is because either they would finally be able to give in to long held, but unrequited desires for each other, physically – or they would be remembering and reliving the innocent childhood sex play they enjoyed together growing up.
mohamad

Fremont, CA

#889 Sep 15, 2014
yes.......I love my sister,we have sex with each other.i hope to marry her one day.and have child with her
Dante

United States

#891 Apr 17, 2016
I love my half sister and would like to make her my wife but I just met a few years ago and she kissed me I fell for her right then and have no regrets
mahmud

Bangladesh

#892 May 31, 2016
Im sex with my little sister 3 years..when my sister pregnant.. Our parents told me married my sister..now our married life is happy..so its easy

“Just your average-ish person”

Since: Jun 16

Location hidden

#893 Jun 3, 2016
If two people our in love then they should be allowed to marry no matter what the situation, plus it's no one else's business
Christa1972

Tarpon Springs, FL

#895 Jul 4, 2016
Me and my half-brother are madly in love we never knew each other until I was 19 and he was 22 and we want to get married and I don't see why we can't because I didn't know him his entire life and he didn't know mine and it wasn't until we were in our forties that we were together to be married and besides I had a hysterectomy so there's nothing to do with children

Since: Jul 16

Location hidden

#897 Jul 13, 2016
Really
What

Boston, MA

#898 Jul 13, 2016
Ewwwww
Doctor REALITY

Little Rock, AR

#899 Jul 13, 2016
[QUOTE who="Sibling marriages...if I only had a bahwain"]What's more natural than marriage between Brother and sister ??

----------

They legalized Homosexual marriages, when they should have thought about first legalizing Brother with sister marriages.[/QUOTE] Should God revoke your privilege of having a brain that you don't use??
James

Austin, TX

#900 Jul 22, 2016
Christa1972 wrote:
Me and my half-brother are madly in love we never knew each other until I was 19 and he was 22 and we want to get married and I don't see why we can't because I didn't know him his entire life and he didn't know mine and it wasn't until we were in our forties that we were together to be married and besides I had a hysterectomy so there's nothing to do with children
You are experiencing genetic sexual attraction. This kind of thing happens a lot when a brother and sister are separated when they are young, then meet up later and fall in love. One website which offers support for people in situations like yours. It's called Kindred Spirits and you can find it by doing a google search for kindred spirits jane doe, then click on the listing that starts with ks2016.
Be sure and read the Announcements section and the Introductions sections. The site was started by two women who are in long-term relationships with their brothers and they live with each other as husband and wife.
prof knows it

Lithonia, GA

#903 Jul 3, 2017
consentual sexual behavior between pre and early teen siblings is not an indicator that they would want to marry.
sexual behavior at this age is most commonly motivated by curiosity and developing sexual desire and it does happen with higher frequency than is reported.
the overwhelming majority of these behaviors remains in that period of developement.
there are rare casrs that a child is produced as a result of the behavior and there is no evidence of a higher incident of abnormality than in any random setting.
KarenK

United States

#904 Jul 5, 2017
Jenji wrote:
I have no desire to marry...
When we were kids my brother and l did watch porn together a few times when we we alone together in the house which eventually lead us to have sex.
We both enjoyed it very much and it has always been our deepest secret but we never thought about getting married to each other.
bill

Atlanta, GA

#907 Oct 5, 2017
yeah... let them get married...
in time the only ones that will end off winning will be .... divorce lawyers

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 41
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Top Stories Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Plurality of Americans think Trump is failing (Mar '17) 10 min wherearethegods 41,698
Prove there's a god. (Mar '08) 18 min wherearethegods 989,716
Anyone gay in Massachusetts Boston to talk or c... 19 min Zackgay 1
gay guys for skype?? (Jun '14) 32 min Zackgay 2
News Roman Catholic church only true church, says Va... (Jul '07) 58 min Rosesz 690,354
Who Will Save The Dying Democrat Party? 1 hr Decency 7
used cars dealer and finance Dallas/FTW 4 hr used car 1
Bring the jobs back to the USA! 10 hr Paul is dead 541
More from around the web