Former judge defends choice to return...

Former judge defends choice to return girl

There are 998 comments on the NewsOK.com story from Jun 21, 2007, titled Former judge defends choice to return girl. In it, NewsOK.com reports that:

The former judge in the Kelsey Smith-Briggs case has written a book and Thursday again defended his decision to return the abused child to her mother four months before the 2-year-old died.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at NewsOK.com.

First Prev
of 50
Next Last

“Truth to Power!”

Since: Apr 07

Raleigh, NC

#1 Jun 22, 2007
Nothing like a judge returning a helpless child to the scene of the crime so the criminals can finish the job. Idiot!

To die from "blunt trauma" to the stomach is just unbelievable. The mother and stepfather should be hanged.
IheartLiberals

Oklahoma City, OK

#2 Jan 4, 2008
And nothing like an uninformed reader!
Free_raye_Dawn

New Castle, PA

#3 Nov 12, 2008
Stop Blaming Judge Key ITS NOT HIS FAULT.Kathie briggs isnt so nice as you people think did you know she didnt even go to the Sept 8 trial.Kelsey last court date.Kathie briggs is a lier please go to www.thetruthaboutkelset.com
just me

Oklahoma City, OK

#4 Nov 12, 2008
Free_raye_Dawn wrote:
Stop Blaming Judge Key ITS NOT HIS FAULT.Kathie briggs isnt so nice as you people think did you know she didnt even go to the Sept 8 trial.Kelsey last court date.Kathie briggs is a lier please go to www.thetruthaboutkelset.com
Just a question, what does Kathie Briggs have to do with this thread? This is about the judge and his decision.
Tomboy

United States

#5 Nov 12, 2008
just me wrote:
<quoted text>
Just a question, what does Kathie Briggs have to do with this thread? This is about the judge and his decision.
Post about the judge then and don't ask questions about Kathie.
just me

Oklahoma City, OK

#6 Nov 12, 2008
Tomboy wrote:
<quoted text>
Post about the judge then and don't ask questions about Kathie.
I didn't ask questions about Kathie, someone else brought her up and I just wanted to know why. Wow, didn't know I couldn't ask a question.
NoUse

Tulsa, OK

#7 Nov 15, 2008
What's a "lier"? It is FORMER Judge key's fault, he returned Kelsey to her mother to be murdered. Don't know who the abuser is, so let's just give her back to mommy, who has confirmed abuse already against her and see what happens. yeah, great Judge there....not. You may not like Kathie Briggs and no one really gives a damn, but got a *NEWSFLASH* for ya....KATHIE BRIGGS DID NOT MURDER KELSEY BRIGGS. KATHIE BRIGGS WAS NOT EVEN AROUND KELSEY ON OCT.11, 2005.
Free_raye_Dawn wrote:
Stop Blaming Judge Key ITS NOT HIS FAULT.Kathie briggs isnt so nice as you people think did you know she didnt even go to the Sept 8 trial.Kelsey last court date.Kathie briggs is a lier please go to www.thetruthaboutkelset.com

Valkyrian Ride

“Say hello to my M203 ...”

Since: Jul 07

You wanna play rough?

#8 Nov 15, 2008
So this judge is selling this book and he is making money over his decision to return the child to her mother which resulted in her DEATH???

Valkyrian Ride

“Say hello to my M203 ...”

Since: Jul 07

You wanna play rough?

#9 Nov 15, 2008
Free_raye_Dawn wrote:
Stop Blaming Judge Key ITS NOT HIS FAULT.Kathie briggs isnt so nice as you people think did you know she didnt even go to the Sept 8 trial.Kelsey last court date.Kathie briggs is a lier please go to www.thetruthaboutkelset.com
IT IS HIS FAULT - he returned the child to her mother against the recommendation of the workers of the program that was in place to oversee the child's wellbeing.

Valkyrian Ride

“Say hello to my M203 ...”

Since: Jul 07

You wanna play rough?

#10 Nov 15, 2008
"He said that profits will go to 'people who will help children." What is THAT??? Did he give these people's NAMES??? WHAT people??? He needs to give the names of the people or organizations that he will be giving the profits to!!!
NoUse

Tulsa, OK

#11 Nov 15, 2008
I highly doubt there were any "profits" to send to anyone. The book I heard was being returned by many, and was receiving very poor reviews, it's also under "FICTION" at your local library. It was poorly written and very poorly edited. AND full of lies.

Valkyrian Ride

“Say hello to my M203 ...”

Since: Jul 07

You wanna play rough?

#12 Nov 15, 2008
NoUse wrote:
I highly doubt there were any "profits" to send to anyone. The book I heard was being returned by many, and was receiving very poor reviews, it's also under "FICTION" at your local library. It was poorly written and very poorly edited. AND full of lies.
Why is it under "FICTION" when it is based on an actual event?

Valkyrian Ride

“Say hello to my M203 ...”

Since: Jul 07

You wanna play rough?

#13 Nov 15, 2008
NoUse wrote:
I highly doubt there were any "profits" to send to anyone. The book I heard was being returned by many, and was receiving very poor reviews...
PLEASE try to find out more information ABOUT this book and the "profits" or tell me how to find out. I am now VERY interested in knowing exactly where these "profits" are going TO.

Valkyrian Ride

“Say hello to my M203 ...”

Since: Jul 07

You wanna play rough?

#14 Nov 15, 2008
"The Book is Available OnLine?"
So they want us to go online to buy the book as the only way to find out information about the case and the decision, and the profits will go to "people who will help children," but they won't even give these "people's" NAMES???

Valkyrian Ride

“Say hello to my M203 ...”

Since: Jul 07

You wanna play rough?

#15 Nov 15, 2008
NoUse wrote:
...and was receiving very poor reviews...
I don't care about the "reviews," I care about the book and the profits and where these profits are going to.
Thank you very much for giving me more info.

Valkyrian Ride

“Say hello to my M203 ...”

Since: Jul 07

You wanna play rough?

#16 Nov 15, 2008
NoUse wrote:
I highly doubt there were any "profits" to send to anyone. The book I heard was being returned by many, and was receiving very poor reviews, it's also under "FICTION" at your local library. It was poorly written and very poorly edited. AND full of lies.
Where did you hear this information, in the media (TV, newspaper)? I don't live in Oklahoma so I have never heard anything about this before.
I wonder how the sources of your information knew the book was full of lies, did they read the book?

Valkyrian Ride

“Say hello to my M203 ...”

Since: Jul 07

You wanna play rough?

#17 Nov 15, 2008
NoUse wrote:
I highly doubt there were any "profits" to send to anyone. The book I heard was being returned by many, and was receiving very poor reviews, it's also under "FICTION" at your local library. It was poorly written and very poorly edited. AND full of lies.
Those "profits" are going straight into that judge's POCKET!!!
NoUse

Inola, OK

#18 Nov 15, 2008
My information on the lies in the book come from reading the official documents in this case, the one's without someone's opinions attached. And some of my information comes from others involved in this case. Interestingly enough, this sorry EX Judge is being investigated by the Ok Bar Assoc. and this book is part of that investigation.

To answer your question about where the profits go, I don't think anywhere has he specifically named where or how much, of the profits have actually went to any organization. And no you don't have to purchase that book of lies to learn anything about this case. And you will not learn where any profits go, from purchasing this book of lies.
Valkyrian Ride wrote:
<quoted text>Where did you hear this information, in the media (TV, newspaper)? I don't live in Oklahoma so I have never heard anything about this before.
I wonder how the sources of your information knew the book was full of lies, did they read the book?

Valkyrian Ride

“Say hello to my M203 ...”

Since: Jul 07

You wanna play rough?

#19 Nov 15, 2008
NoUse wrote:
My information on the lies in the book come from reading the official documents in this case, the one's without someone's opinions attached. And some of my information comes from others involved in this case. Interestingly enough, this sorry EX Judge is being investigated by the Ok Bar Assoc. and this book is part of that investigation.
<quoted text>
Somehow that doesn't surprise me...

Valkyrian Ride

“Say hello to my M203 ...”

Since: Jul 07

You wanna play rough?

#20 Nov 15, 2008
NoUse wrote:
My information on the lies in the book come from reading the official documents in this case, the one's without someone's opinions attached. And some of my information comes from others involved in this case. Interestingly enough, this sorry EX Judge is being investigated by the Ok Bar Assoc. and this book is part of that investigation.
<quoted text>
THANK YOU!!! This new information that you have just given me about this topic makes me very happy!!! Thank you!!!
I'm GLAD that the judge is under investigation.
Thank you!!!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 50
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Top Stories Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Prove there's a god. (Mar '08) 2 min Huh 982,358
Virginia man charged with espionage for deliver... 8 min Guy from Latonia 11
News Plurality of Americans think Trump is failing 12 min swampmudd 7,805
The Christian Atheist debate (Jun '15) 24 min Clearwater 123,807
News Roman Catholic church only true church, says Va... (Jul '07) 33 min Michael 681,924
Baiting Up Email For Scamming 6 hr Resist the urge 1
Poll Was 9/11 a conspiracy?? (Oct '07) 7 hr onemale 286,558
More from around the web