I like your coffee pot analogy....it's kinda' like the Christian propensity to take a verse or two from the Bible and assume all kinds of crap from them. You know its not true....but they wish sooo hard that it was.<quoted text>
You know your coffee pot is cracked, you have evidence of that. You don't know how it cracked though, you're speculating on how it happened. Plus, you don't know when it happened, that would also be speculation. Plus, you don't know if the crack started at the top or at the bottom, that is also speculation. The one and only fact that you have is that the glass is cracked, everything else is not a fact.