We cant count on PolitiFact to even admit it was wrong tells you everything you need to know about the group. One wag on Twitter once described PolitiFact as 60 percent true, because Politi is 60 percent of the letters in PolitiFact. PolitiFacts Obamacare flip-flopcoming after two presidential elections in which the group came to Obamas defensetells you one, or both, of two things:(1) PolitiFact doesnt know what its doing when it comes to evaluating the truthfulness of claims regarding health policy; and/or (2) PolitiFact bears a left-wing bias that sought to downplay unflattering aspects of the Presidents health-care plan during election years.Politifact:
The Truth-O-Meter Says:
Under Barack Obama's health care proposal, "if you've got a health care plan that you like, you can keep it."
It remains to be seen whether Obama's plan will actually be able to achieve the cost savings it promises for the health care system. But people who want to keep their current insurance should be able to do that under Obama's plan.
His description of his plan is accurate, and we rate his statement True.
Pants On Fire: PolitiFact Tries To Hide That It Rated 'True' in 2008 Obamacare's 'Keep Your Health Plan' Promise
On December 12, the self-appointed guardians of truth and justice at PolitiFact named President Obamas infamous promisethat if you like your health care plan, you can keep itits 2013 Lie of the Year. An understandable choice. But in its article detailing why the Presidents promise was a lie, PolitiFact neglected to mention an essential detail. In 2008, at a critical point in the presidential campaign, PolitiFact rated the keep your plan promise as True. The whole episode, and PolitiFacts misleading behavior throughout, tells us a lot about the troubled state of fact-checking journalism
PolitiFact is an embarrassment to the world of fact-checking, let alone to the world of prediction-checking to which it actually belongs. Their 2008 Pulitzer Prizeprominently mentioned on every PolitiFact web pageowes itself in part to the groups lazy and inaccurate reporting on Obamacare. If PolitiFact were intellectually honest, it would acknowledge that it was undeserving of that prize, reflect on how its work has gone astray, and focus in the future on actual fact-checking instead of prediction-checking.
Heres my prediction: they wont. And thats all you need to know about the epistemological legitimacy of PolitiFact.