GOP state lawmaker backs gay marriage...

GOP state lawmaker backs gay marriage, says more may join

There are 1 comment on the Chicago Tribune story from Apr 8, 2013, titled GOP state lawmaker backs gay marriage, says more may join. In it, Chicago Tribune reports that:

State Rep. Ed Sullivan Jr. of Mundelein said Sunday he will support a bill to allow gay marriage in Illinois, becoming the second House Republican to do so and first among leadership.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Chicago Tribune.

Robert Klein Engler

Bartlett, IL

#1 Apr 8, 2013

Some argue same-sex/gay marriage is a slippery slope leading to the abolition of all marriage. There is truth in this argument. The real issue, however, hidden behind the smoke screen of same-sex/gay marriage is an attack on the Roman Catholic Church in Illinois.

Furthermore, this attack on the Roman Catholic Church has at it source anti-Semitism. This is the case because the Roman Catholic Church is one of the few institutions in the world that takes Judaism seriously, something some Jews don't even do.

To be in favor of same-sex/gay marriage is to ultimately be in favor of death over life. The logic of this may not be self-evident, but surely the symbolism of the defining act is. Life is the principle value in Judaism, and in turn it is at the root of Roman Catholicism, too. How is life in this world sustained? The common sense answer to this is the symbols inherent in heterosexual love and marriage.

In opposition to this symbolism, same-sex/gay marriage offers us the symbolism of anal intercourse. Instead of the bright new face of a child, we are offered the dark, bottomless hole of sex divorced from procreation. This is the same dark hole into which the Nazis wanted to condemn the Jews.

To be against same-sex/gay marriage is not to be against GLBT people. To be against same-sex/gay marriage is not to be blind to the problems and discrimination GLBT people suffer in the world. Be that as it may, same-sex/gay marriage is not a moral solution to these problems or that discrimination.

Consider the analogy of poverty. Yes, there are poor people with problems. Nevertheless, stealing is not a moral solution to the problem of poverty. The best moral solution to poverty is not communism, but charity and a republic with a constitution and a free economy. Likewise, the best GLBT people can hope for is not an immoral redefinition of marriage, but life in a constitutional republic.

An all powerful, progressive state cannot tolerate religion, especially Roman Catholicism and Judaism. Nothing, especially God, must come between the individual and the government. Such a government will use same-sex/gay marriage to attack and discredit religion. A government that adopts same-sex/gay marriage is by definition anti-Semitic.

Illinois should not join the anti-Semites of the world by adopting same-sex/gay marriage. You say all love is equal, but if same-sex/gay marriage passes into law you will see only what the Nazi upheaval saw--all death is equal.


Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Top Stories - Gay Marriage Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Gay marriage (Mar '13) Feb '18 keeper 61,362
News Aussie anti-gay marriage opponent attends same-... Feb '18 Mullah Pres Elect... 1
News Gay marriage advocates celebrate ahead of Austr... Dec '17 Xstain Mullah Fri... 1
News Australian Parliament resumes gay marriage refo... Dec '17 Imprtnrd 1
News Australians endorse gay marriage in postal survey Nov '17 Gremlin 9
News Australian to soon post ballots in gay marriage... (Sep '17) Sep '17 Gomez 1
News Australian court dismisses challenge to gay mar... (Sep '17) Sep '17 Bella NE 5