China relentlessly harries Japan in i...

China relentlessly harries Japan in island dispute

There are 41 comments on the Boston.com story from Nov 5, 2012, titled China relentlessly harries Japan in island dispute. In it, Boston.com reports that:

In this Sept. 24, 2012 file photo, Japan Coast Guard vessels, right, and rear, sail along with Chinese surveillance ship Haijian No.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Boston.com.

Since: Mar 08

Portland, OR

#21 Nov 6, 2012
old china wrote:
<quoted text>
I can sell property in the UK that I have title deeds for to the French but simply because they would now own property in the UK would not grant the French sovereignty over it because the sovereignty would still remain with the English Crown. Only nations can transfer sovereignty between themselves, Individuals do not have that power.
If you think it is ironclad then you are grossly misjudging the Chinese resolve.
you don't make sense, Japan had the stronger claim before the purchase and it is only stronger now,

recent Chinese attempts to take the territory of other countries is just making people more resentful of China, especially neighboring countries
Andrez Lopez

El Paso, TX

#23 Nov 6, 2012
Leonard 68 wrote:
<quoted text>
you don't make sense, Japan had the stronger claim before the purchase and it is only stronger now,
recent Chinese attempts to take the territory of other countries is just making people more resentful of China, especially neighboring countries
You do NOT make sense!
old china

Chengdu, China

#24 Nov 6, 2012
Leonard 68 wrote:
<quoted text>
you don't make sense, Japan had the stronger claim before the purchase and it is only stronger now,
recent Chinese attempts to take the territory of other countries is just making people more resentful of China, especially neighboring countries
The Japanese stole the territory off the Chinese in the first place and the Japanese records prove it. They know it and are a nation without honour to persist in their claim. If they don't like the resentment and wish to improve relations with China then they know what they can do about it.

Those who are resentful against China are typically scavengers like the Philippines and expansionists like the Japanese. I shouldn't think they have earned enough respect for the Chinese to care whether they are resented or not.

Either way, China's sovereign territory is NON NEGOTIABLE. Live with it because the Chinese have a long memory and given time or a lack of Chinese patience and these territories will be back fully under Chinese control one way or another. That’s not a threat but a prediction.
bll

Christchurch, New Zealand

#25 Nov 6, 2012
wow, the olde china is a chinese commie right through to the bone, he has been indoctrinated, and probably works for the ministry of truth,,lool.
what a mouthful of propoganda you just spewed out there olde chap

Since: Feb 12

Taipei, Taiwan

#26 Nov 6, 2012
old china wrote:
<quoted text>
The Japanese stole the territory off the Chinese in the first place and the Japanese records prove it. They know it and are a nation without honour to persist in their claim. If they don't like the resentment and wish to improve relations with China then they know what they can do about it.
Those who are resentful against China are typically scavengers like the Philippines and expansionists like the Japanese. I shouldn't think they have earned enough respect for the Chinese to care whether they are resented or not.
Either way, China's sovereign territory is NON NEGOTIABLE. Live with it because the Chinese have a long memory and given time or a lack of Chinese patience and these territories will be back fully under Chinese control one way or another. That’s not a threat but a prediction.
Wah.

Cry harder.

Either take the case to the world court or shut the hell up. Your history means shit since the islands changed hands to much. US had the islands last and they gave it to Japan. You dont like that? To bad.

Since: Mar 08

Portland, OR

#27 Nov 7, 2012
old china wrote:
<quoted text>
The Japanese stole the territory off the Chinese in the first place and the Japanese records prove it. They know it and are a nation without honour to persist in their claim. If they don't like the resentment and wish to improve relations with China then they know what they can do about it.
Those who are resentful against China are typically scavengers like the Philippines and expansionists like the Japanese. I shouldn't think they have earned enough respect for the Chinese to care whether they are resented or not.
Either way, China's sovereign territory is NON NEGOTIABLE. Live with it because the Chinese have a long memory and given time or a lack of Chinese patience and these territories will be back fully under Chinese control one way or another. That’s not a threat but a prediction.
ok time will tell, it worked with Tibet, it worked with Hong Kong, it has not worked with Taiwan, it has not worked with these islands per Japan, it did not work with the recent attempt to grab territory from the Philippines, the dispute with Vietnam? at any rate----the world has given in to land grabs a few times per communist china but will draw a line at some point, continued chinese aggression could lead to very horrible things for the world---including communist china
RayH

Shenzhen, China

#28 Nov 7, 2012
Leonard 68 wrote:
<quoted text>
ok time will tell, it worked with Tibet, it worked with Hong Kong, it has not worked with Taiwan, it has not worked with these islands per Japan, it did not work with the recent attempt to grab territory from the Philippines, the dispute with Vietnam? at any rate----the world has given in to land grabs a few times per communist china but will draw a line at some point, continued chinese aggression could lead to very horrible things for the world---including communist china
Yeah, you're going to end up inundated by Chinese products. Oh, you already are.
old china

Chengdu, China

#29 Nov 7, 2012
StarsplashTaiwan wrote:
<quoted text>
Wah.
Cry harder.
Either take the case to the world court or shut the hell up. Your history means shit since the islands changed hands to much. US had the islands last and they gave it to Japan. You dont like that? To bad.
What is there to cry about? I am not Chinese, Japanese or even Tiawanese so it's no skin off my nose who claims it.

Tiawan has a better claim over it than the Japanese but that assumes (rashly) that Tiawan will one day be an independent nation.
usa is not God

Kowloon, Hong Kong

#31 Mar 3, 2013
Leonard 68 wrote:
<quoted text>
Japan recently purchased the islands to make them officially part of Japan. The private owners sold them to Japan.
Japan had administrative authority which you point out. However, outright ownership was in the hands of private individuals...until they sold them to Japan. So, Japan had the stronger claim since they had administrative authority. And now their claim is ironclad with the official purchase.
sorry, this leonard from portland...but the Diaoyu is really China territory historically....

the japanese private ownership is illegal...the government ownership is illegal....China don't recognize

tibet is part of China.....usa invade mexico and take away the land of california, texas, arizona....

sorry, usa is not God, usa has no right to interfere with other nation territory....

usa should leave alone, the joint defense should not include China own Diaoyu island, you can not include other nation territory in the joint defense...

usa don't own Diaoyu island, japan don't own Diaoyu island, only China own it...
usa is not God

Kowloon, Hong Kong

#32 Mar 3, 2013
Leonard 68 wrote:
<quoted text>
you don't make sense, Japan had the stronger claim before the purchase and it is only stronger now,
recent Chinese attempts to take the territory of other countries is just making people more resentful of China, especially neighboring countries
japan war crime, usa is not God, usa can not interfere with China territory...
snow ducks

Nha Trang, Vietnam

#33 Mar 3, 2013
Leonard 68 wrote:
<quoted text>
ok time will tell, it worked with Tibet, it worked with Hong Kong, it has not worked with Taiwan, it has not worked with these islands per Japan, it did not work with the recent attempt to grab territory from the Philippines, the dispute with Vietnam? at any rate----the world has given in to land grabs a few times per communist china but will draw a line at some point, continued chinese aggression could lead to very horrible things for the world---including communist china
hey 68 tet!! Y keep to xpress yo thinking!! let Victoria Nuland do her job!!! ;-000h, Pentagone poleecy. don't ask & don't tell + don't typing 2much ok!! ;-000
usa is not God

Kowloon, Hong Kong

#34 Mar 3, 2013
StarsplashTaiwan wrote:
<quoted text>
Wah.
Cry harder.
Either take the case to the world court or shut the hell up. Your history means shit since the islands changed hands to much. US had the islands last and they gave it to Japan. You dont like that? To bad.
usa is not God, usa should not interfere with other nation territory.....China lend usa money,...China is usa boss....don't try to command your boss what to do.....China own diaoyu historically, China is diaoyu island boss,.. not usa, not japan

usa is not God, usa has no right to make rules,

usa has no right to decide things for other nation.......period..

usa is not God, usa has no right to decide the destiny and outcome of other nation.......period..

Since: Mar 08

Portland, OR

#35 Mar 4, 2013
usa is not God wrote:
<quoted text>
sorry, this leonard from portland...but the Diaoyu is really China territory historically....
the japanese private ownership is illegal...the government ownership is illegal....China don't recognize
tibet is part of China.....usa invade mexico and take away the land of california, texas, arizona....
sorry, usa is not God, usa has no right to interfere with other nation territory....
usa should leave alone, the joint defense should not include China own Diaoyu island, you can not include other nation territory in the joint defense...
usa don't own Diaoyu island, japan don't own Diaoyu island, only China own it...
Japan's ownership of those islands is completely official now. Everyone outside communist china knows this. The communist government of China can create as many fake maps as they want but it will not change the facts.

There is no question whatsoever that those islands are now fully a par of Japan. They already were part of Japan but the sale made it super, super, ironclad official. There is no doubt whatsoever except in the minds of the brainwashed, indoctrinated Chinese.
usa is not God

Kowloon, Hong Kong

#36 Mar 4, 2013
Leonard 68 wrote:
<quoted text>
Japan's ownership of those islands is completely official now. Everyone outside communist china knows this. The communist government of China can create as many fake maps as they want but it will not change the facts.
There is no question whatsoever that those islands are now fully a par of Japan. They already were part of Japan but the sale made it super, super, ironclad official. There is no doubt whatsoever except in the minds of the brainwashed, indoctrinated Chinese.
you are wrong, the word "official" does not apply to Diaoyu Dao, as a matter of fact, international don't care about japanese ownership or not...in fact, japan does not own...they are illegally occupy...

only ignorant like you will said that the map is fake. there is no fake map..

the island is not part of japan, all their buy and sell activities is illegal.. they are just lies and tricks... China was right, the territory belongs to China, China has the right to surveillance...

usa does not have the right to decide for other nation... usa is not God...

and you don't have the right to say this and that. you know nothing...
kjliojsfajlkj3ko

Nha Trang, Vietnam

#37 Mar 4, 2013
usa is not God wrote:
<quoted text>
you are wrong, the word "official" does not apply to Diaoyu Dao, as a matter of fact, international don't care about japanese ownership or not...in fact, japan does not own...they are illegally occupy...
only ignorant like you will said that the map is fake. there is no fake map..
the island is not part of japan, all their buy and sell activities is illegal.. they are just lies and tricks... China was right, the territory belongs to China, China has the right to surveillance...
usa does not have the right to decide for other nation... usa is not God...
and you don't have the right to say this and that. you know nothing...
do U know what"s god, God, goD, gOd, or GoD?!!;-000
kjliojsfajlkj3ko

Nha Trang, Vietnam

#38 Mar 4, 2013
Leonard 68 wrote:
<quoted text>
Japan's ownership of those islands is completely official now. Everyone outside communist china knows this. The communist government of China can create as many fake maps as they want but it will not change the facts.
There is no question whatsoever that those islands are now fully a par of Japan. They already were part of Japan but the sale made it super, super, ironclad official. There is no doubt whatsoever except in the minds of the brainwashed, indoctrinated Chinese.
hey, OR lame duck;) don't tryin to xplain 2much here if not U Bcome a crispy duck in HK!! ;-000

Since: Mar 08

Beaverton, OR

#39 Mar 4, 2013
usa is not God wrote:
<quoted text>
you are wrong, the word "official" does not apply to Diaoyu Dao, as a matter of fact, international don't care about japanese ownership or not...in fact, japan does not own...they are illegally occupy...
only ignorant like you will said that the map is fake. there is no fake map..
the island is not part of japan, all their buy and sell activities is illegal.. they are just lies and tricks... China was right, the territory belongs to China, China has the right to surveillance...
usa does not have the right to decide for other nation... usa is not God...
and you don't have the right to say this and that. you know nothing...
dum dum they are in fact part of Japan, Japan controls those islands and the world recognizes it, Japan defends those islands, USA has a defense pact with Japan, USA totally considers those islands part of Japan, the islands were sold to Japan and not China, get over it, don't be greedy over some dumb small islands

be happy with Tibet which was a huge land grab of another country, don't be greedy or you will lose more

walk away from the casino with your huge prize (tibet) and don't be greedy
China is Jupiter

Kowloon, Hong Kong

#40 Mar 4, 2013
Leonard 68 wrote:
<quoted text>
dum dum they are in fact part of Japan, Japan controls those islands and the world recognizes it, Japan defends those islands, USA has a defense pact with Japan, USA totally considers those islands part of Japan, the islands were sold to Japan and not China, get over it, don't be greedy over some dumb small islands
be happy with Tibet which was a huge land grab of another country, don't be greedy or you will lose more
walk away from the casino with your huge prize (tibet) and don't be greedy
you are wrong, China own those island,

your logic is wrong, everybody in the world laugh at you,

according to your logic, then usa is a big country already, and usa should give land to mexico, cuba...they are tiny nation

you are completely wrong....loser.....you can not rebuke me....
China is Jupiter

Kowloon, Hong Kong

#41 Mar 4, 2013
Sorry, roman empire can not last forever, so is the spanish, french, british empire.

the united states of america will not last forever, no matter how powerful it is,...the days are number....it is destiny.

China is Jupiter, like it or not, China is the heaviest and greatest player on this planet. China is not usa enemy, usa should learn to live peace with China...

China is Jupiter, China is the elephant, it is normal for China to be powerful, it is normal for China to have big territory....the gravity of Jupiter speaks for all...

China is the sleeping Giant, China is Great even when he is only sleeping...the other nation should not irritate and bark at China like a hayena...

those tiny nation were merely scavenger hayena...they should learn to live peace with China...they are merely asteriod....asteriod should move away from Jupiter's orbit....

live peace with China, the gravity of Jupiter rules the solar system...

a sleeping elephant is mightier than a lion, China is only sleeping or half wake...China is not wake up yet...yet China is the mighty elephant...a sleeping elephant is mightier than a fierce lion....

it is no use at all for those hayena and lion who keeps on barking at China...a China elephant sneeze will blow those tiny creature away....learn to live peace with China....the gravity of Jupiter rules....

Since: Mar 08

Portland, OR

#42 Mar 5, 2013
China is Jupiter wrote:
<quoted text>
you are wrong, China own those island,
your logic is wrong, everybody in the world laugh at you,
according to your logic, then usa is a big country already, and usa should give land to mexico, cuba...they are tiny nation
you are completely wrong....loser.....you can not rebuke me....
in fact, I completely and easily rebuke you lol

ok go visit those islands and you will see who controls your entry---you will be subject to Japananese passport and visa stipulations, Japanese laws, rules, regulations, etc. Those islands have been part of Japan for a long time.

http://www.marsecreview.com/2012/09/japan-buy...

and here are Japanese boats easily chasing China away hah hah hah hah so funny little Japan still owns big dum china hah hah

http://theaseannewsblog.blogspot.com/2012/10/...

leave Taiwan alone
Free Tibet
stop trying to invade Vietnam and the Philippines

so keep dreaming with your ignorant beliefs hah hah hah

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Top Stories - China Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Looking for another sign of a weakened China ec... (Feb '16) Aug 9 mar 2
News Big-mouthed clown? China reacts to Trump Aug 5 mar 3
News China says no more foreign street names like "M... Aug 5 mar 2
News Japan defense papers raises concerns about Chin... Aug 5 mar 2
News How China's Debt Fix Could Make Things Much Worse Jul '16 mar 2
News These are the advanced surface-to-air missiles ... (Feb '16) Feb '16 Yakult 2
News China broadcasts Swedish rights worker's confes... (Jan '16) Jan '16 jeff forsythe 1
More from around the web