Tax Commission Changes Credit For Ele...

Tax Commission Changes Credit For Electric Cars

There are 2558 comments on the News on 6 Tulsa story from Sep 18, 2009, titled Tax Commission Changes Credit For Electric Cars. In it, News on 6 Tulsa reports that:

A lot of Oklahomans scrambled to buy electronic cars after they learned they could get some for practically free thanks to state and federal tax credits.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at News on 6 Tulsa.


United States

#2541 May 27, 2012
Jack, Thanks for the information, I had backed away from this and had not caught it in any news reports.

I wonder how much money and how many man hours the OTC cost the rest of us by their actions? I am sure they have justified keeping their jobs, unlike being in the private sector where someone would be fired for wasting this much money and time.

Enid, OK

#2542 May 27, 2012
Without digging into a bunch of my tax stuff, i cant even remember whats owed to me. Am I safe assuming its 50% of the vehicle purchase price, plus interest? Or is there more to the math based on my tax situation?

Crescent, OK

#2543 May 28, 2012
@Enid -- as long as you tagged & insured the vehicle, then you would get 50% of the purchase price plus interest. I am not sure how they will get the refund to us -- probably sending out checks which will take several weeks to get thru all the Tomberlin claims.

@ Club Car owners -- this should "open the flood gates" on the remaining vehicle claims. Was Club Car involved in the lawsuit? If so, the remaining vehicles should have decisions soon.

@Cherokee235 -- I never heard anything on television news about this and the story was "buried" in the Enid newspaper. I agree that OTC jobs should be lost over this whole mess and that the Governor should re-evauluate the commissioners and appoint 3 new ones that know what they are doing. The ones we have now cost the State a lot more than if they had just let the credits go thru in 2009.(man hours, interest, legal expenses, ect)

Portland, TX

#2544 May 29, 2012
Any tips I can give my accountant? Should I contact the OTC and ask for the refund or does my accountant need to file an ammended return? Any help/tips would be appreciated!

Crescent, OK

#2545 May 29, 2012
@ Enid -- lawyers are advising NOT to call the tax commission. The OTC will be going thru all of the Tomberlin claims and re-processing them to get us our credits. There are over 700 to go thru. As long as you claimed the credit, you should be in line for your credit. See the link below for the news story:

Good thing we are good at waiting, since we will have to wait a little while longer. OTC isn't supposed to be able to appeal this ruling.

Haslet, TX

#2546 May 30, 2012
Does anyone know the interest rate and how long it will be before we will receive the check.

Hennessey, OK

#2547 May 30, 2012
This was posted on the lawyers facebook page today:

"....While appeals from the Tax Commission are filed in the Oklahoma Supreme Court, every appeal is subject to assignment by the Oklahoma Supreme Court to the Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals.

Our cases were so assigned, and the Court of Civil Appeals ruled in our favor on Friday. The Tax Commission can ask for a rehearing by the Court of Civil Appeals, within 30 days following the ruling by the Court of Civil Appeals.

The Tax Commission also can ask the Oklahoma Supreme Court to review the decision of the Court of Civil Appeals, if they file their request within the same 30 day time period.

This process is similar to an appeal, but the Oklahoma Supreme Court can choose whether to review or not to review the ruling by the Court of Civil Appeals. We will know within twenty days whether the Tax Commission is seeking rehearing or review by the Oklahoma Supreme Court."

** this means more waiting for us, but we are getting very good at waiting. Hopefully OTC will stop spending time and tax money trying to continue this. We will know in 30 days what they decide, so all credits are on hold at least until the end of June. It's important to remember that now 4 different judges have ruled in our favor (Hladik and the three appeal judges) I am hopeful for a positive outcome!

Portland, TX

#2548 May 31, 2012
Email I received this morning from AEC:

From: Tammy Byrd
To: [email protected]
Sent: Thursday, May 31, 2012 8:55 AM
Subject: AEC vs OTC

Well, don't start the party yet: it appears that the OTC has 30 days to appeal the Okla. Court of Civil Appeals decision directly to the Okla. Supreme Court (if they choose). So, if the OTC uses all of their allotted time, we may have to wait another 30 days before we will know for sure if the OTC is going to accept the NON-BIASED third party decision (this time) or spend more tax payers money, precious time and effort by appealing the decision again. It doesn't make sense (to me or other prudent folks) that the OTC would continue to fight when the facts are so clear and after those facts have been heard and reviewed by six (6) disinterested judges, in three different venues, and after ALL of these judges who "did not have a dog in the hunt," found that the tax credits on the OTC disallowed LSV's should be allowed. This whole case is not just about Okla. tax credits, but also about truth, justice, fairness, and ethics in politics and government.

We will keep you posted,

Roger Gaddis, CPA/CFP®

Portland, TX

#2549 May 31, 2012
@Bobby I've heard/read 18%. Can anyone confirm?

I believe 18% is what the Ruff-n-Tuff owners got. That would mean 18% x 2 years for Tomberlin owners, if correct.
Star 48

Berryville, AR

#2550 May 31, 2012
I can confirm that the interest rate owed the taxpayes by the OTC is 1.5% per month, i.e. 18% per year.

It works the same way should the taxpayer owe the OTC.

At that interest rate, I say let them keep your money for another year or so.

Rational Tulsans

Tulsa, OK

#2551 Jun 5, 2012
I DON'T GIVE A DAMN about electric cars. But I do give President Obama credit for the OUTSTANDING work he has done in order to give us an alternative energy source other than fossil fuel. MAN, WE HAVE A GREAT PRESIDENT!!!!!!!!!!

United States

#2552 Jun 5, 2012
I wonder how much that "Outstanding Work" cost each present and future tax payer? But seeing that we only have a couple hundred years of "bad" energy efficient fossil fuels available in the US soil, I guess someone has to take the lead. It is just a shame the OTC rejigging like they have on this tax credit for totally efficient cheap electric cars will have a negative effect for any thing like this again. They have lost my trust of promoting anything.
E-merge Owner

Tulsa, OK

#2553 Jun 5, 2012
Star 48 wrote:
I can confirm that the interest rate owed the taxpayes by the OTC is 1.5% per month, i.e. 18% per year.
It works the same way should the taxpayer owe the OTC.
At that interest rate, I say let them keep your money for another year or so.
I am a lawyer. Does anyone have a copy of a letter awarding interest or have a cite to Oklahoma law so I can look it up. I would love to have that information. I think the OTC will appeal to the Supreme Court but they will almost certainly lose.
Robert - Grand Lake area

Jay, OK

#2554 Jun 5, 2012
Question - I bought the Club Car and have handled my own case with the OTC without the aid of a lawyer. I did it by the book, providing all requested information and responding in the proper manner to each request made by the OTC. I used the templet from a link I saw on this board. I included exhibits, tax and tag info and so on. The question is, if the Club Care is found to be entitled to the credit, will I receive it just as someone who was part of the group using the law firm? Thanks for your thoughts

“The one who knows”

Since: May 12

Location hidden

#2555 Jun 5, 2012
Rational Tulsans wrote:
I DON'T GIVE A DAMN about electric cars. But I do give President Obama credit for the OUTSTANDING work he has done in order to give us an alternative energy source other than fossil fuel. MAN, WE HAVE A GREAT PRESIDENT!!!!!!!!!!
And the weird thing is, President Obama doesn't even know who you are, nor does he care.
Club Car

Montgomery, AL

#2556 Jun 6, 2012
@Robert I am in the same boat as you, and did exactly the same. The OTC is still trying to collect taxes due with interest, and have had to call twice to inform them that I am disputing the electric car credit. I came close to paying the balance just to close the appeal. I glad that I did not pay, because there seems to be some hope of collecting our money.

Portland, TX

#2557 Jun 15, 2012

June 15, 2012

We received the OTC's request to the Supreme Court yesterday asking them to review the decision made by the Court of Appeals.

We have 14 days to respond. Once we respond to the OTC's request to the Supreme Court, they will review the OTC's request and make a ruling on whether or not they will review the case themselves or have the decision from the Court of Appeals stand.

The Supreme Court has no timeline on making their ruling on the OTC's request.

We will have to wait until the Supreme Court rules on this request from the OTC before we will be able to move forward with the tax credits and the other LSV models that have not been heard.

Thank you in advance for your patience.
GKU Sued Me Too

Edmond, OK

#2558 Jul 2, 2012
Sued by GKU wrote:
It looks like GKU served papers on 3 people so far. One has been dismissed.
I just received a letter from Derryberry et al. What was your outcome from your March lawsuit?

Haslet, TX

#2559 Jul 26, 2012
Has anyone heard anything new? Or do we know when to expect more news?

Since: Jul 12

Oklahoma City, OK

#2560 Jul 27, 2012

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Oklahoma Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Republicans battle over taxes in Kansas, other ... 19 hr Tea Bag Residue C... 1
Election OK Health Care Freedom Amendment, State Questio... (Oct '10) Wed treason watch 83,936
News Oklahoma Senate panel passes bill protecting di... Tue fromworm 1
News OK Bill Seeks To Eliminate 'Incompatibility' As... Tue godsydrome 1
News Oklahoma Gov. Mary Fallin says she's willing to... Tue vetoed 1
News Don't Hit the Brakes on Uninsured Motorist Cove... Tue worstination 1
More from around the web