Yes, if you shut down government, Soc...

Yes, if you shut down government, Social Security checks don't get sent

Posted in the Minnesota Forum

Joan McCarter


#1 Feb 17, 2011
Yes, Rep. Mike Kelly, if you shut down government, Social Security checks don't get sent

by Joan McCarter

There really does need to be an entrance exam to getting your name on a ballot. The latest argument for this is GOP freshman Rep. Mike Kelly (R-PA).

Now, freshmen Rep. Mike Kelly (R-PA) is also parroting the notion of a pain-free shutdown. ThinkProgress caught up with Kelly at last weekendís Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC). Though he stopped short of supporting a government closure, Kelly defended the potential consequences of a shutdown. He argued that even if there is a shutdown, the government is ďnot going to stop, people arenít going to lose their Social Security checks and theyíre not going to lose their access to Medicare and MedicaidĒ:

KEYES: If these cuts, either defunding or dismantling Obamacare, either dies in the Senate or dies at Obamaís veto pen, would you be willing to join Jim DeMint and others who have said that this is worth trying to have a showdown and potentially a government shutdown just to show how serious we are about this?

KELLY: I donít know that you have to have a government shutdown. We can do things with funding. At the end of the day, Congress controls the purse strings. So when you defund and you take the funding away from certain things, you in fact shut down that part. But shutting down the government, nobody wants to hear that. The other thing is, I donít like that terminology of shutting down the government because really, itís a fear factor. People know itís not realistic. The government is not going to shut down, itís not going to stop. People arenít going to lose their Social Security checks and theyíre not going to lose their access to Medicare and Medicaid. I think we have to be careful when we use that kind of talk. I think what weíre talking about is, look, we control the funding, letís make sure weíre doing the right thing for the people.

KEYES: So even if that were to happen, theoretically, it wouldnít be as bad as people make it out to be?

KELLY: No, I donít think so. I really donít....

Kellyís assertions are simply not true. One need look no further than the federal government shutdown of 1995 for proof. During the nearly four-week shutdown, Social Security checks were not mailed and Medicare/Medicaid reimbursements were disrupted.

Now, what could happen is that every member of Congress and all of their staff are put to work doing the jobs of the Social Security and Veterans Administration employees who are shut out of their jobs, making sure that those checks go out. Short of that, it doesn't happen. And, yes, Rep. Mike Kelly is still an ingoramus.

Edinboro, PA

#2 Feb 22, 2011
Kelly is right Social securiity checks will keep on coming, as will military pay. Joan McCarter is not very smart.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Minnesota Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News 11 Things to Know About Chase and Brock Jurgensen 59 min Sarah 2
News Somalis in Minneapolis on defensive after polic... Jul 23 Hostis Publicus 14
News Police Shooting During Traffic Stop Leaves Minn... (Jul '16) Jul 18 Well Well 46
Why Wisconsin Sucks (Apr '10) Jul 13 Pretty Girl 154
News In western Minnesota town of Dawson, a Muslim d... Jul 8 Jim 2
News Jeronimo Yanez, Minnesota officer in Philando C... Jun 28 slick willie expl... 82
News Romney on minimum wage: 'We ought to raise it' (May '14) Jun '17 Backroom healthcare 30
More from around the web