Michigan gay marriage case draws scru...

Michigan gay marriage case draws scrutiny, support

There are 7 comments on the Times Herald story from Sep 29, 2013, titled Michigan gay marriage case draws scrutiny, support. In it, Times Herald reports that:

A major legal challenge to Michigan's ban on gay marriage is attracting interest from conservative Christians, the Roman Catholic Church, law professors and civil libertarians as the state defends a 2004 constitutional amendment that defines marriage only as between a man and a woman.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Times Herald.

Since: Mar 09

Location hidden

#1 Sep 29, 2013
Another interesting case to keep up on. I look forward to reading the transcripts.

“Come and get it! ”

Since: Jan 09

Traverse City

#2 Sep 30, 2013
Put me down in the "scrutiny" column.

Since: Mar 07

Location hidden

#3 Sep 30, 2013
Keep those expensive lawsuits coming!

“Marriage Equality”

Since: Dec 07

Lakeland, MI

#4 Sep 30, 2013
I'm amazed that the attorney general's office has the balls to stick up for this obviously unconstitutional ban, especially after the SCOTUS' decision on DOMA.

Sure, the SCOTUS has said that the states get to define marriage, but it ALSO said that the Feds can't discriminate against gay couples. Does the attorney general's office believe that the State of Michigan can trump the SCOTUS?? It appears he does.

Or maybe, and truly pathetically, maybe they know full well that this type of religious-based discrimination is gasping it's last gasps and they're just hoping that legal CPR can keep it alive for a little while longer.

“Headed toward the cliff”

Since: Nov 07

Tawas City, Michigan

#5 Oct 1, 2013
This case is important because we need conflicting rulings from 2 or more appeals courts to ensure the SCOTUS takes up the marriage issue instead of punting once again.

The judge signaled he's likely to rule Michigan's ban is unconstitutional, but the 6th circuit would likely overturn that on appeal.

On the other hand, the 4th circuit (VA case) & the 9th circuit (NV, HI cases) are likely to uphold any such ruling.

That sets up conflicting rulings which makes it much more likely the SCOTUS accepts one or both or all of the 12+ pending federal cases.

“Marriage Equality”

Since: Dec 07

Lakeland, MI

#6 Oct 1, 2013
WeTheSheeple wrote:
This case is important because we need conflicting rulings from 2 or more appeals courts to ensure the SCOTUS takes up the marriage issue instead of punting once again.
The judge signaled he's likely to rule Michigan's ban is unconstitutional, but the 6th circuit would likely overturn that on appeal.
On the other hand, the 4th circuit (VA case) & the 9th circuit (NV, HI cases) are likely to uphold any such ruling.
That sets up conflicting rulings which makes it much more likely the SCOTUS accepts one or both or all of the 12+ pending federal cases.
Any speculation on time-frame? Are we looking at a year or three or more like eight to ten?

Now that it's over, it seems like the Prop 8 case and the Federal DOMA case happened very quickly. I'm hoping these cases do, too, of course.

“Headed toward the cliff”

Since: Nov 07

Tawas City, Michigan

#7 Oct 1, 2013
eJohn wrote:
<quoted text>
Any speculation on time-frame? Are we looking at a year or three or more like eight to ten?
Now that it's over, it seems like the Prop 8 case and the Federal DOMA case happened very quickly. I'm hoping these cases do, too, of course.
Most likely in the 3-5 year timeframe. The Michigan & Virginia cases (among others) are just at the district court level, but the 9th circuit could rule by the end of the year on their cases- HI & NV.

I'd expect the SCOTUS to simply refuse to take any appeal from the 9th circuit until another circuit makes an opposing ruling. So that could get us the rest of the west coast/pacific states by default while we wait.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Michigan Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Election Who's got your vote in the Michigan Senate race? (Oct '14) Sun reality is a crutch 6
News Few complaints since smoking ban began (Oct '10) Jul 4 How is this relevant 8
News WZZM13 WATER COOLER - Weird 'shoe tree' in nort... (May '08) Jul 3 toni 15
Election Michigan Felon Politician Ban Amendment, Propos... (Oct '10) Jun 30 Township one 313
News News Guide: What power plant ruling means for M... Jun 30 SpaceBlues 2
How many Hells Angels chapters in Michigan? (Oct '12) Jun 29 huh 56
News Al Capone's West Michigan ties: Fact or fun-fic... (Jan '06) Jun 29 athenapeach 804
More from around the web