Carcharodontosaurus v.s Giganotosaurus

Posted in the Dinosaur Forum

First Prev
of 15
Next Last
Dark Goth Boi65

Irvington, AL

#1 Sep 5, 2007
In a battle tell me who you think would survive out of Carcharodontosaurus or Giganotosaurus if they had lived together.
max taptiklis

Nelson, New Zealand

#2 Sep 7, 2007
i reakon giganotosaurus would win because he worked in packs and usually pack hunters are very
intelligent so my theory is that gignotosaurus would kick butt!
and he was much heavier so again giganotosaur would
beat the heck out of carcharodotosaur!
max, age 8

“Apology Accepted”

Since: Aug 07

United States

#3 Sep 13, 2007
Close one. I'm betting on Giganotosaurus simply because *all* Giganotosaurus specimens have been at least 40 feet long, and Carcharodontosaurus' size is debatable. It may have been the same size as Giga. It could have been slightly smaller. It could have been considerably smaller. We don't really know.

“Controversy creates discussion”

Since: Jun 07

Hidden Valley, Saskatchewan

#4 Sep 16, 2007
I got a better one: Who would win in a fight, Daniel Abercrombie or his dad's fist?
I can't figure out if your 8 or 38 but eitherway, you need a beating from your parents to put your insane questioning in check.
Fred

Perth, Australia

#5 Nov 15, 2007
SupremeOppressor wrote:
I got a better one: Who would win in a fight, Daniel Abercrombie or his dad's fist?
I can't figure out if your 8 or 38 but eitherway, you need a beating from your parents to put your insane questioning in check.
Why do you care? if they wanna talk about Fantasy fights than they can continue.
so if you want mature, accurate and interesting discussions then I suggest you find the right topic and avoid picking on weak ones.
YtwoJ

Fort Rucker, AL

#6 Nov 30, 2007
Fred wrote:
<quoted text>
Why do you care? if they wanna talk about Fantasy fights than they can continue.
so if you want mature, accurate and interesting discussions then I suggest you find the right topic and avoid picking on weak ones.
Agreed.
YtwoJ

Fort Rucker, AL

#7 Nov 30, 2007
But I do actually think that Giganotosaurus is definately gonna win this one! Because Giganoto is a pack hunter, and its way more powerful and heavily built than Carcharodonto! So in my theory, I believe that Giganotosaurus will definately win!

Giganto is the King!
spino X000

South Charleston, OH

#8 Dec 27, 2007
none of em win, cause while their fightin, spino comes along and kicks both of their asses across the face of the earth. matter o fact,across the entire milky-way. SPINO'S DA KING!!
Zeke Android

Caroga Lake, NY

#9 Dec 29, 2007
spino X000 wrote:
none of em win, cause while their fightin, spino comes along and kicks both of their asses across the face of the earth. matter o fact,across the entire milky-way. SPINO'S DA KING!!
You must live under a rock, cause you have the brain power of the insects there.
Megatron

South Charleston, OH

#10 Dec 29, 2007
seriously :-|
spiny

Everett, WA

#11 Dec 30, 2007
giga will win because it is 20 feet larger
Megatron

South Charleston, OH

#12 Dec 30, 2007
giga isn't 20 ft. larger than charcaro. their actually almost the same size. giga is just slighty larger than it's African cousin, charcaro.
sebedin

Köln, Germany

#13 Jan 1, 2008
Nope, Carcharodonto was 3 feet larger than giga, but he was not as heavy built as giga, and who can proof that carcha hadnt hunted in packs?
BR
Jan
Tyrant King

Canada

#14 Jan 1, 2008
Giga would kick some serious ass.
The bone structure on Giganotosaurus suggests that they can move fast, and its the opposite with Carcharodontosaurus
Giga is also larger.
sebedin

Köln, Germany

#15 Jan 2, 2008
I already said carcha is larger, 3 feet in height and lenght, and of carcha is to little known to say how fast he could movee.
BR
Jan
Zirgo

United States

#16 Jan 2, 2008
Well, they are pretty similar, and I don't see one having any clear advantage with its equipment. So I suppose Giga's increased size will give it a victory, though at sever cost. And I believe either one could bring down a Spinosaurus.
sebedin

Köln, Germany

#17 Jan 2, 2008
how often i have to say that Carcha was the larger one^^?
and of course they would defeat a spino, but they all had to fear crocs,!
REDMAN

Fort Rucker, AL

#18 Jan 2, 2008
sebedin wrote:
how often i have to say that Carcha was the larger one^^?
and of course they would defeat a spino, but they all had to fear crocs,!
agreed.
REDMAN

Fort Rucker, AL

#19 Jan 2, 2008
Carcharodonto can definately beat Giganoto at any given day! And it was larger and longer than Giganoto. They both can definately beat Spino.

“I see you.”

Since: Jan 08

Mordor

#20 Jan 2, 2008
Last time I checked Giga was bigger that Carchar but if its the other way around than yes, Carcharodontosaurus would win, although at great cost.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 15
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Dinosaur Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Jurassic Park 3 review: Dinosaur Movies 22 hr Prehistory 9
Vastatosaurus vs. Spinosaurus (Apr '09) 22 hr Gawdzilla 65
The story of Dinosaurs (2) (Jan '12) Sat Coprolite1 56
Hatching Dinosaur Egg in 8 days - opinion! Apr 29 First Dinosaur 1
Let's Talk About: The Dino King (A.K.A Speckles... Apr 29 tyrannospinus 1
News T Rex's 'bizarre' vegetarian cousin puzzles sci... Apr 28 Holy Guacamole 1
Poll Who's changed the most? Apr 25 spinosaurus baryonyx 2
More from around the web