Comments
321 - 340 of 413 Comments Last updated Friday Aug 1
mapusaurus rex

Havertown, PA

#330 May 3, 2012
Giganotosaurus wrote:
<quoted text>
Wt heack is that?
100 percent of pure epicness

here is the source: http://translate.google.com/translate...

it is bigger than carchar, giga and mapu, even rivals spino in size.

maybe 14-15m???

bout the same size as deinocheirus which was estimated to b 14m

there is also a third unnamed carcharodontid from argentina (12-13m)
and another large unnamed carcharodontosaur from south africa (t.rex size)

as well as a huge unnamed sinraptorid tooth...
mapusaurus rex

Havertown, PA

#331 May 3, 2012
it could b a freak carcharodontosaurus juvenile
Premania

Espoo, Finland

#332 May 4, 2012
Giganotosaurus wrote:
<quoted text>
What facts? Give some evidence instead of just saying "no. Just no. Your wrong ok."
Giganotosaurus is just a bigger s. American cousin.
This fact: c.iguidensis have three specimens. Biggest is 90% of c.saharicus so no near the size of c.saharicus. 10% is a big difference.

“Taste my purging steel”

Since: May 11

Location hidden

#333 May 4, 2012
Premania wrote:
<quoted text>This fact: c.iguidensis have three specimens. Biggest is 90% of c.saharicus so no near the size of c.saharicus. 10% is a big difference.
I asked for papers, links, ect. To my kbowledge, we have only a charch skeleton. G carolinii is at least 10% bigger.
Hindu Jesus

Cockermouth, UK

#334 May 4, 2012
skeletons disagree

“Australia's #1 Paleontologist”

Since: Apr 12

Location hidden

#335 May 4, 2012
Premania wrote:
<quoted text>This fact: c.iguidensis have three specimens. Biggest is 90% of c.saharicus so no near the size of c.saharicus. 10% is a big difference.
Then why is C.iguidensis widely accepted as being 14m long and bigger than C.saharicus?
tyranosaurus

Brent, AL

#336 Jul 7, 2012
I'd say that it will end in a tye because if youlook at both dinosaurus they look similare and the same weapons so it would be a stand off battle the one who crackes first will lose
Browning M1917A1

Lake Forest, CA

#337 Jul 7, 2012
tyranosaurus wrote:
I'd say that it will end in a tye because if youlook at both dinosaurus they look similare and the same weapons so it would be a stand off battle the one who crackes first will lose
I'd win, it ain't gonna be a tie.

Since: May 12

North America, Early Jurassic

#338 Jul 11, 2012
Depends on which Carcharodontosaurus you're talking about.

C. saharicus: 50/50 with a slight edge to Giga
C. iguidensis: 55/45 for Carchar

I would have normally said Carcharodontosaurus because I like him better as they are basically the same build

Since: May 12

North America, Early Jurassic

#339 Jul 11, 2012
Oh and heres the sizes

G. carolinii: Probably 13.5 m at maximum
C. saharicus: At least 12.8 m
C. iguidensis: 14 m
paulman

United States

#342 Jul 11, 2012
Giganotosaurus is so similiar to Carharodontosaurus that many scientists even consdier it a species of Carcharodontosaurus. Basically its like asking who would win between Carcharodntosaurus (iguidensis or saharicus) and a slightly larger C. carolinii. Obviously C. carolinii.
Tyrannosaurus101

Campbell, CA

#344 Jul 12, 2012
no you are
gigacarno

Baldwin Park, CA

#347 Aug 4, 2012
its pretty close....but in the end giganotosaurus because of his build i mean look at a picture he is pretty buff....i agree that like 1 meter or like 1 or 2 tons doenst really make a difference for me its bite force,wieght,and speed. and sometimes smarts ftw.And yes giga is slightly bigger.And bother looking it up on wiki beacuse....WIKI SUCKS!IT LIES ALL IT IS IS PEOPLE WHO LOOK UP THE FACTS ON ANOTHER WEBSITE AND WRIGHT IT DOWN."ohh i went on a random website and it said char is bigger"!!!!!!!...sorry about that..any way giga
Sylvilagus aquaticus

Lake Forest, CA

#348 Aug 4, 2012
gigacarno wrote:
its pretty close....but in the end giganotosaurus because of his build i mean look at a picture he is pretty buff....i agree that like 1 meter or like 1 or 2 tons doenst really make a difference for me its bite force,wieght,and speed. and sometimes smarts ftw.And yes giga is slightly bigger.And bother looking it up on wiki beacuse....WIKI SUCKS!IT LIES ALL IT IS IS PEOPLE WHO LOOK UP THE FACTS ON ANOTHER WEBSITE AND WRIGHT IT DOWN."ohh i went on a random website and it said char is bigger"!!!!!!!...sorry about that..any way giga
Giga and Carch are almost the same animals pretty much, so it's gonna be a tie.
Altanative Whatever

San Francisco, CA

#349 Aug 5, 2012
No, Giganotosaurus is slightly bigger.
Sylvilagus aquaticus

Lake Forest, CA

#350 Aug 5, 2012
Altanative Whatever wrote:
No, Giganotosaurus is slightly bigger.
Yeah, but still probably a tie.
Crazy Fish

Bournemouth, UK

#351 Aug 6, 2012
Dilophosaurus wrote:
Depends on which Carcharodontosaurus you're talking about.
yes
C. saharicus: 50/50 with a slight edge to Giga
C. iguidensis: 55/45 for Carchar
no
C. saharicus => C. iguidensis
175cm C. iguidensis skull is media myth.
Sylvilagus aquaticus

Lake Forest, CA

#352 Aug 6, 2012
Crazy Fish wrote:
<quoted text>
yes
<quoted text>
no
C. saharicus => C. iguidensis
175cm C. iguidensis skull is media myth.
1.75 meters is definetely fake.
giacarno

Baldwin Park, CA

#353 Aug 6, 2012
I thought its been decided that giganotosaurus was bigger.So caharcarodontosaurus fans give it up...
Sylvilagus aquaticus

Lake Forest, CA

#354 Aug 6, 2012
Size in this case doesn't matter. Giga was slightly bigger but perhaps in this case the individual Carch might be a little stronger which makes it equal. And on average they're the same size basically.

Tell me when this thread is updated: (Registration is not required)

Add to my Tracker Send me an email

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Dinosaur Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Tarbosaurus vs Deinosuchus 31 min tyrannospinus 3
Dinosaur Face Off! 34 min tyrannospinus 20
Oase is a BULLY! 42 min tyrannospinus 8
Megalodon vs Predator X vs Liopleurodon 46 min tyrannospinus 5
Oase is a gaylord 55 min tyrannospinus 11
Tyrannosaurus vs Carnotaurus (Nov '08) 6 hr Jakesaurus Imperator 162
Spinosaurus vs Xenomorph Queen 9 hr Oase 3
•••
Enter and win $5000
•••

Dinosaur People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

•••