Yes I was talking about you.<quoted text>
Are you talking about me? I've been here the whole time. As I said, I just want to warn you that if you treat verses from John where it mentions a comforter as legitimate, then be prepared to explain why those verses are legitimate and the rest of the book is not. You will need to do that before we even get to discussing what those verses really mean and who they are referring to.
Why are you jumping to the conclusion? I did not say anything about John's verses yet.
I wanted to have a proper point by point discussion with you on the subject of prophesy.
I just asked you basic question, what is a prophesy?
You did not answer for two days this simple question and now you come talking about John and last chapter.
Is that the way to have a proper point by point discussion?
We cannot have a discussion without having made proper base and sorting out rules.
So I ask you once again, what is prophesy?
Ans.01. A "prophecy" is a prediction of what will happen in the future.
02. Let me make a "prophecy". To show that Muhammad was the comforter, you will use verses from the book of John, and then I will ask you whether other verses from John are legitimate also and ask you how you decide which verses are legitimate and which ones are not.
1. Yes a prophesy is a prediction for some events that will happen at a future date.
2 Why are you "apprehensive"? You are behaving in a strange manner. You start raising points which I never mentioned yet.
3. We are still in preliminary stages and you are talking about points that are not yet mentioned?
4. May be this is the "first discussion" in which you are asked to proceed in a slow process.
Q. My Next Question is, who makes these Prophesies?