Brother bmz, you are absolutely amazing. Without a doubt, I am an internet junkie - no arguments there, and in your view, I can be stupid, silly, idiotic whatever. But what is most shocking is that you have swallowed Ben Issac's sira wholesale which is really atonishing because all along, you have been abusing the poor basta*d. For a Koran only Mohammadan to write such things is truely amazing.<quoted text>
You see, you make statement like Internet Junkies and write rubbish.
How silly and stupid of you to write, "and ethnic cleansing of the Jewish tribes was uncalled for."
Banu Nadir and Banu Qaynuqa were allowed to go into exile. Right? So where was the ethnic cleansing? The Jewish tribes sided with the Meccan pagans, even according to your own internet sources. They were the ones, who brought up the Meccans to destroy the Prophet and Muslims.
They attacked together with the Meccans and lost, when the Meccans left them alone and went back.
That is why I said all killing was justified! Do you think the buggers Asma bint Marwan, Abu Rafi, Um Qirfa and others were very nice, kind and loving people?
There was no order from the Prophet to kill anyone. If killing had been on his mind, blood would have flowed through the streets of Mecca, when the Prophet made the Grand Triumphal Re-Entry
into Mecca. Did he kill all the Meccans or did he carry out ethnic cleansing of Meccans?
How can you choose to be ignorant? Were the leaders of the Jewish tribes innocent men, according to your own sources?
Sure Qaynuqa were spared, thanks to the intervention of Ibn Ubay or else they would have been hacked as well. BN were driven into exile, while BQ were slaughtered en mass. They were given a choice, either embrace Mohammadanism or get butchered. They obviously chose the latter. If you do not call that ethnic cleansing, then the hell is ethnic cleanising?
Okay, so you saying that Mohd never ordered hits on Kaab Ashraf, Bin Marwan, Abu Rafi, Um Qirfa? Either Ben Issac is lying or you'v forgotten what he wrote, because by the look of things, you seem to accept some of his writings and reject others.
Its not about how kind and loving they were, its whether they killed anyone or not. If they were convicted murderers, then killing them would be justifiable, otherwise not.
You then write:
"There was no order from the Prophet to kill anyone. If killing had been on his mind, blood would have flowed through the streets of Mecca, when the Prophet made the Grand Triumphal Re-Entry
into Mecca. Did he kill all the Meccans or did he carry out ethnic cleansing of Meccans?"
Mohammad had bigger fish to fry. Killing Meccans would have done him no good. The man was an astute politician who'd put Gandhi & Brian Mulrooney to shame. As long as the narcissist is told that you are my prophet and I believe in you, you have nothing to worry. The moment his egotistical desires are fulfilled, he's won and wont hold anything against you. He even spared Hind who had a hand in killing his uncle Hamza. Always keep in mind brother, that the holy Koran says " believe in Allah and his apostle"...not just Allah.