Where did we come from?

Where did we come from?

There are 7 comments on the The Countywide story from Feb 15, 2013, titled Where did we come from?. In it, The Countywide reports that:

Conventional thought for the past 70 years or so has been that people crossed over to the Americas via a land bridge at the Bering Straits and a glacial corridor down through Canada.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at The Countywide.

Atom Lad

Old Lyme, CT

#1 Feb 15, 2013
The Solutrean Hypothesis -- what's not to love? The land bridge/ice-free corridor idea, as sweet as it is, is unsupportable. And what little evidence there is (and there is only very little), geographically, is chronologically backward. What we are seeing here is an appalling, laughable, even mockable heresy gaining more and more traction. It will run over the old idea (because it is true), and all the old stick-in-the-mud Republican types will be spitting and sputtering their ways into obscurity. Let's let a little light in on this and watch it thrive.
Ronald Weiss

San Diego, CA

#2 Feb 15, 2013
I've always felt that it didn't fully come together. Is there some other proposal that you've begun to relate with?

Love to hear some intelligent debate about this.
Ian Cooper

Silver Spring, MD

#3 Feb 16, 2013
Where did 'WE' come from?

The LoneRanger & Tonto are riding down into a box canyon. At the far end, the LoneRanger notices an army of Comanche Indians, in full war-paint, frowning down from the cliff walls at him.

Turning to his left he notices a great number of very mad looking Arapaho Indians staring down.

On his right he observes a host of Cherokee Indians peering at him over the rim of the canyon.

Looking behind, he sees every Apache brave in the world slowly creeping into the canyon, blocking the exit.

The LoneRanger turns to Tonto and says, "We're in a heap of trouble, Tonto!"

Tonto's nervous reply, "What's this 'we' shit, white man?"

If I can remind the person who wrote the headline, the people who make up the vast majority of the population of the modern Americas are not the descendants of the folks who first populated America.'We' has nothing to do with it, and to suggest it does is offensive to all those who lost their lives in the centuries-long genocide that began when Europeans first came to the Americas.
Glow In De Dark

Old Lyme, CT

#4 Feb 16, 2013
With all due respect, I think we all know the "What you mean 'we'?" joke. Jay Silverheels is one of early television's overlooked comics. And further with all due respect only a cretin wouldn't understand that Anglos (in the broadest, non-Indian sense) are not the descendants of the people who first settled the United States (with some notable exceptions if you buy the Solutrean Hypothesis). But as the land bridge from Asia hypothesis loses its air what do we do with DNA evidence that points straight to Siberia? How do we reconcile the obvious earliest migration into North America -- jolly Solutrean jack tars -- with the lack of any defining DNA characteristics in present-day Native Americans? Also, their beret-wearing habits. If the Solutrean migrants wore jaunty berets, why don't present day Sioux or Iriquois have any record of that distinct look? You can ask the same question about the accordion. In southern France and northern Spain stone-age accordions (also made of stone) have been found intact at several sites. They are larger than the contemporary instrument -- about the size of a Buick -- which may have hampered their portability. And yet they are not as sweet to the ear as the Alpenhorn, which is truly an instrument created by a lunatic for lunatics. All you can do is keep the home fires burning and hope for the best, right?
Eejit Duck

Old Lyme, CT

#5 Feb 17, 2013
And he means it, too.
Arthie Flatum

Old Lyme, CT

#6 Feb 17, 2013
Eejit Duck wrote:
And he means it, too.
He means it.

Port Coquitlam, Canada

#8 Oct 13, 2013
clovis are siberian ,pre-clovis are paleo indians,olmecs are african interraced asiatic.all those i just mentioned ALL CAME FROM ASIA NOT EUROPE!the berring strait is in ASIA NOT EUROPE!

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Science Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Evolution vs. Creation (Jul '11) 5 hr Breaking Science ... 221,750
News Michelle Grossman - About NBC 10 News Story - W... (Mar '08) 5 hr AzzCapn 906
News The Un-Pretty History Of Georgia's Iconic Peach 14 hr KIR SUCKA 8
News Town hires consultant to study Danby bridge issue (Mar '12) 16 hr Stairs action eh 6
News PowWow Energy Releases Automated Water Records ... 19 hr American PieJamboree 2
News Earth's underwater dunes help explain Venus's w... Thu Fundiementally ill 2
News What makes Kentucky Kentucky? Here are some ide... Thu Negan 3
More from around the web