Are Sikhs Hindus?

Are Sikhs Hindus?

There are 55 comments on the About.com story from Nov 1, 2011, titled Are Sikhs Hindus?. In it, About.com reports that:

After over a decade, the Sikh religio-political scenario is torrid again. This time it's the Hindu-Sikh divide caused by the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh - the fundamentalist Hindu faction of the ruling Baharatiya Jananta Party - which is trying to press the fact that Sikhs are actually Hindus.

Join the discussion below, or Read more at About.com.

First Prev
of 3
Next Last
roshan singh

Vapi, India

#1 Nov 2, 2011
NO absouletly not, sikhs are not hindus it's a distinct religion. They do not worship any hindu lord and not even belive in statue worshipping "sikhs are hindus" is a nonsense statement.
mard singh

London, UK

#2 Nov 2, 2011
It is a RSS stunt, who have started saying that the Sikhs are an armed wing of Hinduism, and yet discriminate against the Sikhs.
What a crap.
We are Sikhs, with distinct set of beliefs, and we worship only ONE God.
I am a Sikh and not a Hindu.
hindutva_fauji

UK

#3 Nov 2, 2011
No they are not but Sikhs are our brothers. They are from Hindus and the Sikhs do have references to sanatan deities in Granth sahib ji.
They cannot be classed as Hindu but are neighbours
Anti rat campaign

United States

#4 Nov 2, 2011
hindutva_fauji wrote:
No they are not but Sikhs are our brothers. They are from Hindus and the Sikhs do have references to sanatan deities in Granth sahib ji.
They cannot be classed as Hindu but are neighbours
you r no less then rat.
what you said,muslims can also say it,
you hindus are madarchod gandus
Xpert

Delhi, India

#5 Nov 9, 2011
"Allah created the Light; then, by His Creative Power, He made all mortal beings. From the One Light, the entire universe welled up. So who is good, and who is bad?" ||1||(Guru Granth Sahib Ji, Ang 1349)

According to Guru Granth Sahib ji it clearly shows
that Sikhs are not Hindus people can say whatever
they want.
pak punjabi

UK

#6 Nov 9, 2011
Xpert wrote:
"Allah created the Light; then, by His Creative Power, He made all mortal beings. From the One Light, the entire universe welled up. So who is good, and who is bad?" ||1||(Guru Granth Sahib Ji, Ang 1349)
According to Guru Granth Sahib ji it clearly shows
that Sikhs are not Hindus people can say whatever
they want.
wah veer g. tusa sada dill khush kar dita ve. Sar Sri Akaal veer g. Rab twano apri hamesha sukhi rakhe.
Indian

Bangalore, India

#7 Nov 9, 2011
Hinduism(Arya Samaj) also not believe in idol worshipping.

But people don't believe in Hinduism but Universalism form of hinduism. Worshipping something does'nt let you burn in hell unless your deeds are evil.

People says Idol worshipping is bad ,,then why you make idol mosque ,church

they say god lives there ,
so why don't they worship god using brain.

make an idol , worship it ,what's wrong with this , god would feel happier if you create his stone idol and worship him in human form,

Jesus was the human form of god so people worship jesus in human form , so what's wrong

I think peoples who believes that idol worship people would burn in hell are sick peoples.

they must be psychopath when they say such things.or there religious text says such things.
Abe mullo gaand mrwalo

Vancouver, Canada

#8 Nov 9, 2011
Saale mullo chiddte kyu ho tum hamesha..Katti lulli wale gandmare
Xpert

New Delhi, India

#9 Nov 10, 2011
If somebdoy beleives in his scripture doesn't mean
he is cray. Muslims beleive in every word of Quran
what u're trying to say? Christans beleve in bible
are they psyschopath? Jews beleive in their holy
book Torah also known as Talmud are they psycho?

Same as Sikhs are told to beleive in word of SGGS
what's wrong with that? Moreover SGGGS does not
say someone will burn in hell? Why? If that was the then case Sikhs woudn't have saved so many mothers and daughters who belonged to Hindu, Jains, Buddhit community. Peace

" Recognize all human race as one" ( SGGS)
tapas

Kolkata, India

#10 Nov 14, 2011
Both the religion are mostly identical. Many hindus do worship gurunanak than any other community saint. Similarly sikhs also worship hindu gods. They have striking resemblance in names also. It is very difficult to differentiate between a hindu and sikh.
Mr Spok

UK

#11 Nov 14, 2011
Who was Nanak Singh's dad? Just curious
mard singh

Glasgow, UK

#12 Nov 14, 2011
Mr Spok wrote:
Who was Nanak Singh's dad? Just curious
Gandu saab who is/was Nanak Singh.
na mard sing

United States

#13 Nov 14, 2011
mard singh wrote:
<quoted text>Gandu saab who is/was Nanak Singh.
i was the father of guru nanak
Jinx

Delhi, India

#14 Nov 16, 2011
na mard sing wrote:
<quoted text>
i was the father of guru nanak
so you are a Muslim, huh?
uyt

Mexico, Mexico

#15 Mar 25, 2012
All right.
Hindu Soulja

Leamington Spa, UK

#16 Mar 25, 2012
Sikhs claim they are not hindus but they come to our temples regularly apart from hindu punjabis no other hindus go to gurudwara in majoirty. They stole our practices and customs including hindu names but claim sikh is different faith.
sikh warrior

Basingstoke, UK

#17 Mar 25, 2012
Hindu Soulja wrote:
Sikhs claim they are not hindus but they come to our temples regularly apart from hindu punjabis no other hindus go to gurudwara in majoirty. They stole our practices and customs including hindu names but claim sikh is different faith.
anyone who worships a monkey or elephant r no sikh we all know many hindus pretent to be sikhs (rss) hindu soulja what war have u guys won without sikhs where was the hindu soldiers when muslim took there women and sold in kabul lol u hindus make me laugh without sikhs india army is a joke lol hahahaha stupid dothead

Since: Sep 11

Location hidden

#18 Mar 25, 2012
sikh warrior wrote:
<quoted text>anyone who worships a monkey or elephant r no sikh we all know many hindus pretent to be sikhs (rss) hindu soulja what war have u guys won without sikhs where was the hindu soldiers when muslim took there women and sold in kabul lol u hindus make me laugh without sikhs india army is a joke lol hahahaha stupid dothead
sikhs are trully great people and are responsible for panjab remaining panjabi and not becomeing afghanised
i am hindu jat

Mumbai, India

#20 Mar 25, 2012
atleast we worship elephant or monkey. what about your gurus. dont they
looked like apeman or bigfoot and i think you know about bigfoot.and who
want pretent to be adhimanav. we won many war without you jat of bharatpur
won without you,maratha won without you,peshawa brahmin won withoutyou raja raja won wihout you.raja vikramaditya won without you.raja puru won
without you. and sihk did'nt'saved any hindu. you could'nt' saved yourself
in 1947 riots and 1984 riots. hwo would you save anybody.because of hindus
you lived here peacfully if we want we can give you another 1984.

and indian army without sikh would be much batter.jat regiment has not sikh
rajputana regiment has not sikh.dogra regiment has not sikh and many more
regiment has no sikh.india has third largest army where just five precent are sikh.more then sevan lakhs peopel hanged or killed by british hwo many sikh. give me 10 sikh name who hanged or killed by british if you want i will give you how many hindus gave life for this country.you blockheaded
peopel
sikh warrior wrote:
<quoted text>anyone who worships a monkey or elephant r no sikh we all know many hindus pretent to be sikhs (rss) hindu soulja what war have u guys won without sikhs where was the hindu soldiers when muslim took there women and sold in kabul lol u hindus make me laugh without sikhs india army is a joke lol hahahaha stupid dothead
zoravar singh

Mumbai, India

#21 Mar 25, 2012
hindu jat is also my user name so dont confuse.now i
shall come with my real name.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
First Prev
of 3
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Sikh Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
punjabi wife (Jun '15) 1 min Guna boy 416
Ahmedabad hot gay pm here (Apr '15) 4 min Gandingar rahul 26,640
kya kisi ne apni mom sis ya wife ko kisi or se ... (Jul '15) 7 min homedelight 449
pyasi housewife (Jun '15) 7 min Guna boy 22,079
delhi unsatisfied housewife (Apr '15) 18 min gora lund legi kya 3,318
kiski behan land chusne me mahir hai 29 min azhar 92
tumhari mom kiski randi he (Mar '15) 40 min Rohit c 578
More from around the web