I get it! All of the "Great Quranic Scholars of earliest times" got together with all of the "Authentic Reciters" and together they decided to clarify how Allah/Jibreel/Mohammad's Qur'anic Arabic SHOULD sound when recited -because that's what matters most of all- so they invented diacritical marks that everyone agreed on that have persisted to this day! The very thought makes my hair stand up! It's a miracle, I say!<quoted text>
See how you are "muddling up" your arguments. I said Almost ALL Urdu Books are written without any punctuation marks. And it is not the case with Urdu, But Persian and Sindhi are also written without punctuation marks.
I do not know Persian, but since it uses the same letters as Urdu, I can read it, but I make hundreds of mistakes, because I do not understand a word of it.
But if someone put punctuation marks, I will be able to read it correctly, even if I might not understand a word of it!!
Of Course, Caliph Othman and Arabs of his time, knew how to read Arabic without punctuation marks and without dots.
Quran was always recited in prayers, if you offer regular prayers in ANY Mosque, you will hear the full Quran many times during one year!! During Ramadan nights itself, Whole Quran is recited more than once from beginning to end!!
All of these Learned Reciters, learned and practiced their Quran in front of Companions of prophet and they were allowed to teach others, only after they got is perfected.
My arguments are not to convince you, because there is no cure for some one who has "sickness inside his hearts".
Your arguments show that you are an atheist.