Idiot I never said he fabricated anything. If I implied it, i didnt mean to.<quoted text>
Again, did Rabbi Raphael, a TOP historian of Jewish HISTORY, and a man who "for the last generation .. has been the EDITOR of the quarterly journal, American Jewish HISTORY" FABRICATE the information or statistics in my quote?
Rabbi Raphael gave statistics, did he make them up?
Understand, these exchanges are saying OUR rabbis cannot be TRUSTED because they "CORRECT" or PERVERT truth and HISTORY.
WHAT I SAID (FOURTH TIME)
was that 16 years later another scholar looked into the issue and had a slightly different conclusion.]
This is how historical studies work.
Each work IMPROVES on the previous, and/or criticizes the previous.
If you have a problem with that, adress it to the second work 16 years later, NOT ME.
More importantly, read BOTH works. At this point you havent even read the first work. All you do it cut and paste, and ground your comments on reputation instead of CONTENT.
Moving on. i.e. please dont bother replying the same reply again.