ATTN: Barbara Anderson re: OSCE confe...

Since: Oct 10

Homebush, Australia

#396 Oct 6, 2012
diogenes wrote:
<quoted text>
Nope, you are WRONG. Hitler was a practicing Catholic. Again from Wikipedia:
"The eight-year-old Hitler took singing lessons, sang in the church choir, and even entertained thoughts of becoming a priest.[18]"
8 yr old hitler took singing lessons from a priest. OH LOL

your really are a trick aren't 8yrs old, how many JW baptised at 8 going to meetings out witnessing are no longer attending are they practising JW.

by the way taking singing lessons does not make one a practising Catholic, how many kids go to Catholic schools, take singing piano lessons from the nuns but never set foot in a church for communion.

you really are desperate arent' you.

Since: Oct 10

Homebush, Australia

#397 Oct 6, 2012
diogenes wrote:
<quoted text>
Nope, you are WRONG. Hitler was a practicing Catholic. Again from Wikipedia:
"The eight-year-old Hitler took singing lessons, sang in the church choir, and even entertained thoughts of becoming a priest.[18]"
by the way, he was eight, when he became renound, was he a practising Catholic, did he go to communion, what is a practising Catholic to you diogenese, one that has singing lessons at eight and thinks OH I think I will be a preist when I grow up.

yes just like many eight year olds who think they will be a policman, fireman or whatever.
diogenes

San Antonio, TX

#398 Oct 6, 2012
array wrote:
<quoted text>there is no need to make untrue statements to defend the faith, this is the problem with you lot.
Please show me where I made an untrue statement?
diogenes

San Antonio, TX

#399 Oct 6, 2012
array wrote:
<quoted text>8 yr old hitler took singing lessons from a priest. OH LOL
your really are a trick aren't 8yrs old, how many JW baptised at 8 going to meetings out witnessing are no longer attending are they practising JW.
by the way taking singing lessons does not make one a practising Catholic, how many kids go to Catholic schools, take singing piano lessons from the nuns but never set foot in a church for communion.
you really are desperate arent' you.
HE SANG IN THE CHURCH CHOIR and ENTERTAINED THOUGHTS OF BECOMING A PRIEST.

Since: Oct 10

Homebush, Australia

#400 Oct 6, 2012
diogenes wrote:
<quoted text>
Please show me where I made an untrue statement?
just a few posts ago trying to make out that Hitler was a practicing Catholic because he took sining lessons at age 8, and said oh I want to become a priest, but we know that never happened in fact he murdered Catholics as well as JW, gypsies homosexuals and others, no accounts of him taking communion later in life was there, so yes you make untrue statements.

“Christmas ONLY for Christians!”

Since: Sep 12

Location hidden

#401 Oct 6, 2012
This just in...

Adolf Hitler's middle name...

JEHOVAH!

“Christmas ONLY for Christians!”

Since: Sep 12

Location hidden

#402 Oct 6, 2012
Pam wrote:
It was Hitlers father that had an unmarried mother, and one of the 3 men suspected was a Jew.
Hitlers father had his name changed legally.
From wiki:
Historians have discussed three candidates as Alois' biological father: Johann Georg Hiedler, his brother Johann Nepomuk Hüttler, and a Jew named Leopold Frankenberger.[8]
Most historians are satisfied that Alois' father was Johann Georg Hiedler, who during his own lifetime was the stepfather and posthumously legally declared the birth father of Alois. According to historian Frank McDonough, the most plausible theory is that Johann Georg Hiedler was the real father of Alois. An explanation for Alois being sent to live on his uncle's farm as a child is that Hiedler and Maria were simply too poor to raise him, or could not raise him as well as his uncle, or perhaps Maria's health was in decline (she died when he was 10).
Werner Maser suggests that Alois' father was Johann Nepomuk, Georg's brother and Hitler's step-uncle, who raised Alois through adolescence and later willed him a considerable portion of his life savings, but never admitted publicly to be his real father. According to Maser, Nepomuk was a married farmer who had an affair and then arranged to have his single brother Hiedler marry Alois' mother Maria to provide a cover for Nepomuk's desire to assist and care for Alois without upsetting his wife.[5] This assumes Hiedler was willing to marry Maria in this situation, and Adolf Hitler biographer Joachim Fest thinks this is too contrived and unlikely to be true.
Hitler, following the rumours that his paternal grandfather was a Jew, in 1931 ordered the SS (Schutzstaffel) to investigate the alleged rumours regarding his ancestry, they found no evidence of any Jewish ancestors.[9] Hitler then ordered a genealogist by the name of Rudolf Koppensteiner to publish a large illustrated genealogical tree showing his ancestry, this was published in the book "Die Ahnentafel des Fuehrers" (The pedigree of the leader) in 1937, which concluded that Hitler's family were all German-Austrians with no Jewish ancestry and that Hitler had an unblemished "Aryan" pedigree.[10] As Alois himself legitimised Johann Georg Hielder as his father and the priest changed this on his birth certificate in 1876 this was considered certified proof for Hitler's lineage, thus Hitler was considered an Aryan.[11]
After the war Hitler's former lawyer, Hans Frank, claimed that Hitler told him in 1930 that one of his relatives was trying to blackmail him by threatening to reveal his alleged Jewish ancestry.[12] Hitler asked Frank to find out the facts. Frank says he determined that at the time Maria Schicklgruber gave birth to Alois she was working as a household cook in the town of Graz, her employers were a Jewish family named Frankenberger, and that her child might have been conceived out of wedlock with the family's 19-year-old son
This is true.

There is a lot of belief that Hitler had Jewish blood and Black blood flowing in his veins.
diogenes

San Antonio, TX

#403 Oct 6, 2012
array wrote:
<quoted text>just a few posts ago trying to make out that Hitler was a practicing Catholic because he took sining lessons at age 8, and said oh I want to become a priest, but we know that never happened in fact he murdered Catholics as well as JW, gypsies homosexuals and others, no accounts of him taking communion later in life was there, so yes you make untrue statements.
You conviently skip the part where he actual sang in the church choir. Then you attempt to change the goal posts by saying he didn't take communion later in life. NO ONE has disputed that.

You are the one being dishonest.

Since: Oct 10

Homebush, Australia

#404 Oct 6, 2012
diogenes wrote:
<quoted text>
HE SANG IN THE CHURCH CHOIR and ENTERTAINED THOUGHTS OF BECOMING A PRIEST.
at 8, do you call JW that are no longer JW praticing JW because they were brought up in the JW faith, but do not practice the faith.

Was he a practising Catholic when he slaughtered millions in concentration camps. Was he?

your talking about an 8 yr old child.

Since: Oct 10

Homebush, Australia

#405 Oct 6, 2012
diogenes wrote:
<quoted text>
HE SANG IN THE CHURCH CHOIR and ENTERTAINED THOUGHTS OF BECOMING A PRIEST.
oh and what of the 8yr old JW that entertained thoughts of becomong pioneers elders, but as adults no long PRACTISE their faith are they still practising JW, are they.

Those JW that set foot in the KH once a year at memorial and never associate otherwise are they practicing JW?

Since: Oct 10

Homebush, Australia

#406 Oct 6, 2012
diogenes wrote:
<quoted text>
You conviently skip the part where he actual sang in the church choir. Then you attempt to change the goal posts by saying he didn't take communion later in life. NO ONE has disputed that.
You are the one being dishonest.
no I mentioned sining in the church choir that does not make him a pracicing Catholic does it.

prac·tice
&#8194; &#8194;[prak-tis] Show IPA noun, verb, prac·ticed, prac·tic·ing.

noun
1.
habitual or customary performance; operation: office practice.

2.
habit; custom: It is not the practice here for men to wear long hair.

3.
repeated performance or systematic exercise for the purpose of acquiring skill or proficiency: Practice makes perfect.

Since: Oct 10

Homebush, Australia

#407 Oct 6, 2012
diogenes wrote:
<quoted text>
You conviently skip the part where he actual sang in the church choir. Then you attempt to change the goal posts by saying he didn't take communion later in life. NO ONE has disputed that.
You are the one being dishonest.
what did I say here, you telling lies.

8 yr old hitler took singing lessons from a priest. OH LOL

your really are a trick aren't 8yrs old, how many JW baptised at 8 going to meetings out witnessing are no longer attending are they practising JW.

by the way taking singing lessons does not make one a practising Catholic, how many kids go to Catholic schools, take singing piano lessons from the nuns but never set foot in a church for communion.

you really are desperate arent' you.

Since: Oct 10

Homebush, Australia

#408 Oct 6, 2012
diogenes wrote:
<quoted text>
You conviently skip the part where he actual sang in the church choir. Then you attempt to change the goal posts by saying he didn't take communion later in life. NO ONE has disputed that.
You are the one being dishonest.
show where Hilter took communion regulary, attended church regualary, can you, not at 8 but as Gareth said when he murdered millions he was a practicing Catholic, show the proof.

“Christmas ONLY for Christians!”

Since: Sep 12

Location hidden

#409 Oct 6, 2012
This thread is one of the funniest threads I've ever seen!

Hey cult defenders, your paranoid is showing!
diogenes

San Antonio, TX

#410 Oct 6, 2012
array wrote:
<quoted text>show where Hilter took communion regulary, attended church regualary, can you, not at 8 but as Gareth said when he murdered millions he was a practicing Catholic, show the proof.
No one said the priest gave him singing lessons. That is another one of your inventions. Hitler sang in the church choir, which would have required regular attendance.

Next you need to show me where Gareth said Hitler was a practicing Catholic during the time he murdered millions?

Note the statement Gareth makes in post 366:

"Hitler went to monastic school and was 'confirmed'. But he rejected Catholicism early on. "
Why

Scarborough, UK

#411 Oct 6, 2012
array wrote:
<quoted text>at 8, do you call JW that are no longer JW praticing JW because they were brought up in the JW faith, but do not practice the faith.
Was he a practising Catholic when he slaughtered millions in concentration camps. Was he?
your talking about an 8 yr old child.
the claim on the table was he had NEVER BEEN a practicing catholic. Diogenes proved you wrong!

Since: Oct 10

Homebush, Australia

#412 Oct 6, 2012
Bite My Jehovah wrote:
This thread is one of the funniest threads I've ever seen!
Hey cult defenders, your paranoid is showing!
I know I couldn't really care less if he was a practicing Catholic or not, sorry I butted in, its become a waste of time.

Since: Oct 10

Homebush, Australia

#413 Oct 6, 2012
Why wrote:
<quoted text> the claim on the table was he had NEVER BEEN a practicing catholic. Diogenes proved you wrong!
no he was not a practicing catholic, already knew that nothing to prove.

Since: Oct 10

Homebush, Australia

#414 Oct 6, 2012
array wrote:
<quoted text>no he was not a practicing catholic, already knew that nothing to prove.
diogense said...Nope, you are WRONG. Hitler was a practicing Catholic. Again from Wikipedia:

"The eight-year-old Hitler took singing lessons, sang in the church choir, and even entertained thoughts of becoming a priest.[18]"
diogenes

San Antonio, TX

#415 Oct 6, 2012
array wrote:
<quoted text>diogense said...Nope, you are WRONG. Hitler was a practicing Catholic. Again from Wikipedia:
"The eight-year-old Hitler took singing lessons, sang in the church choir, and even entertained thoughts of becoming a priest.[18]"
Are you drinking tonight? I suggest you go to bed and try to sleep it off. You are completely incoherent.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Jehovah's Witness Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Let's try this again, 144,000 ONLY? No jw has b... 2 min ihveit 888
New Today music thread 11 min GreatSouthbay4040 1,683
Trinity...why does it matter?! 51 min dlmacoop 919
Seek and you shall find! 1 hr Maravilla 15
Why the NWT is the best ever! 1 hr dlmacoop 709
Hey JW Subliminal Artist!! YOU are done! 2 hr TempleMicrowave 223
Real JW's for your good should leave this forum! 2 hr dlmacoop 462
More from around the web