Ali

Hyderabad, India

#372 Oct 5, 2011
MAY I BE EXCUSED IF I AM WRONG

Your Quote from one of the Scriptures:
[40:34] Joseph had come to you before that with clear revelations, but you continued to doubt his message. Then, when he died you said, "GOD will not send any other messenger after him.(He was the last messenger)!

I am guessing its from Bible.My understanding is Creator of Origin is addressing to humans at the time of Jesus(Beloved of God p.b.u.h),that humans at and after the time of Joseph(Beloved of God p.b.u.h) figured there wont come another Messenger from the Creator after Joseph(Beloved of God p.b.u.h) passed away.Its what the humans thought,hence "Then, when he died YOU said, "God will not send any other messenger after him."

From what ive read in Quran,i understand The Creator informs that Muhammad(Beloved of God p.b.u.h) is the seal of Messengers.That The Creator aint gonna send a new Messenger after Muhammad(Beloved of God p.b.u.h),Jesus(Beloved of God p.b.u.h) will return to earth,but he doesn't fit into the definition of a New Messenger.

Yo,its nice to know ur Intrigued,they say it can prove to be a source of Wisdom.Stay on the hunt
Mikielabdullah

Los Angeles, CA

#373 Feb 2, 2012
All messengers are prophets and messengers, not just messengers or prophets.

However, all prophets are not messengers.

We take this form quran. The buhai faith is a lie; a fabrication of man.

No where in any of the religious texts (bible, or quran) do we find a messenger (someone who brought revelation IE scripture) that was not a prophet.
Mirza Hussain

Saint John, Canada

#374 Feb 2, 2012
Jane wrote:
<quoted text>that is very true. we are trying to learn about your religion - dont shut us off by this kind of comment - why are Muslim this way? I know for a fact that this is NOT the teaching of you prophet nor does the quran commends it. Muslims should learn to speak nicely so we folks like us can learn from them.
thank you.
This is because Muslims are afraid of the truth. They don't want to accept what their conscience say. The prophet after Moahmed is

M&#299;rz&#257; Ghul&#257;m A&#7717;mad February 13, 1835 – May 26, 1908 CE, or Shawal 14, 1250 – Rabi' al-thani 24, 1326 AH) was a religious figure from India and the founder of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community.
ayesha

Bangladesh

#375 Feb 6, 2012
You are very confused . You need some help . Holy book of Islam is revealed in Arabic not in English its very clear in Arabic as well as in English translation that Allah ask to all prophets about agreement and witness for one and only our beloved prophet and messenger Muhammad peace be him the last and final no one will come later. Our beloved prophet himself said that he is the last and final prophet and messenger so there is no second thought in Islam .
vindettamb

Toronto, Canada

#376 Feb 25, 2012
you guys might be right mohammed might not be the last messenger but listen if there is where is the messenger. i've also heard that the bible and quran has been touched and changed have you noticed that evryone of you have a differnet answer about it. im just saying ,but just answer this where is the messenger.
Salma

Saint John, Canada

#377 Feb 25, 2012
The last prophet of Islam is Mirza Ghulam Ahmed (PBHM).
aadil

Mumbai, India

#378 Mar 6, 2012
@submitmj and all d ppl here,
plz read following completely,

Well my friend @submitmj u may have quoted Quran out of context or you may have not understood the exact meaning about things quoted there.
We Muslim Belive in one thing as per the teaching of Quran and Messenger of God 'Mohammad'(bpuh), that Jesus(bpuh) will be coming back in this world (bit before the END OF THE WORLD) to fight the EVIL, etc...
And the thing you are quoting as another messenger is actually "Jesus(bpuh)"
And my frnd as you already know that 'Jesus'(bpuh)came to this world much before 'Mohammad'(bpuh)...
TO ALL MY FRIENDS AND MY SELF TOO, PLS DO NOT INTERPRET ANY HOLY BOOK AS PER OUR INDIVIDUAL IDEA, NEVER READ ANY THING OUT OF CONTEXT, BETTER TO ASK SOME SCHOLARS...
THANK YOU...
Med

Birmingham, UK

#379 Mar 21, 2012
let me answer that for u, every muslim believes thats jesus pbuh will return once again back on earth, and that Jesus will come with the same teaching as Muhammed. In that passage god is referring to the arrival of jesus pbuh back on earth and he will be the witness to Muhammed pbuh, almighty GOD and the Quran.

I hope this helps mate

Peace
explainer

Bihac, Bosnia and Herzegovina

#380 Jun 7, 2012
submitmj wrote:
Sylvia, what else can GOD possibly mean when He says .....[3:81] "GOD TOOK A COVENANT FROM THE PROPHETS, SAYING, "I WILL GIVE YOU THE SCRIPTURE AND THE WISDOM. AFTERWARDS, A MESSENGER WILL COME TO CONFIRM ALL EXISTING SCRIPTURES".
Clearly, GOD makes a distinction in Quran between Prophets and Messengers. The above verse GOD is talking about a covenant He took with the PROPHETS who were GIVEN the SCRIPTURES. We all know the Quran is the final scripture from GOD. So, when He says "AFTERWARDS, A MESSENGER WILL COME TO CONFIRM ALL EXISTING SCRIPTURES", He means exactly that. GOD does not lie or make mistakes. He is GOD. The ONE we are supposed to trust 100%. GOD (the author of QUran) makes a clear distinction between Prophets & Messengers. Prophets bring new scriptures and Messengers confirm them.
Remember...[40:34] Joseph had come to you before that with clear revelations, but you continued to doubt his message. Then, when he died you said, "GOD WILL NOT SEND ANY OTHER MESSENGER AFTER HIM.(He was the last messenger)!"** GOD THUS SENDS ASTRAY those who are transgressors, doubtful.
If you find yourself angry that I'm saying MOhammad is not the last messenger, you need to ask yourself why. All I'm doing is trusting GOD alone and quoting verse from Quran.
With regard to the aayah,

“but he is the Messenger of Allaah and the last (end) of the Prophets”[al-Ahzaab 33:40]

Why it did not say the last of the Messengers?– the end of the Message does not mean the end of Prophethood, but the end of Prophethood does mean the end of the Message. That is because every Messenger is a Prophet, but not every Prophet is a Messenger. Hence the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said:“There will be no Prophet after me,” and he did not say, there will be no Messenger after me. If you believe in the above verse you have to admit that there will be no more Messengers because in order for a Messenger to come he has to be a Prophet as well. We said that every Messenger is a Prophet as well just like Muhammad salallahu alayhi wa salam was a Prophet and a Messenger.

Thus we know that there is no Messenger and no Prophet after him (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him); he was the last of the Prophets and of the Messengers,(peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him).
Mohammad aarif momin

India

#381 Jul 27, 2012
hey, listen Mohammad is a last messanger and please don't try to currupt Islam otherwise "GOD ka azab bahut hi jald aane wala he"
black flag

London, UK

#382 Nov 24, 2012
so if what u muslims say is true that these certain surahs in the quran are actually talking about somelse then that someone else can only be imam mhadi.all muslims know aout this figure whether they believe or not thats a diffrent matter.you people shuld also remember that when the prophet muhammad came he did say i bring no new religion but only confirm that which was sent before me.So remember the prophet muhammad did confirm that which came before him through the quran which are the words of god through the ange jibrail.SO ASK YOURSELFS AGAIN AND STUDY THE VERSES CAREFULLY THEN STUDY ALL ASSOCIATED WITH THAT SUBJECT THEN MAKE SURE ALL YOUR SOURCES ARE AUTHENTIC THEN MAKE YOUR DECISIONS MY MUSLIM BROTHERS AND SISTERS FOR REMEMBER EVERYTHING YOU TRY TO PREACH IS RECORDED AND A DAY WILL COME WHEN ALL MUST ANSWER TO THE ALMIGHTY SO DO NOT ASSOCIATE THAT WITH YOUR LORD THAT YOU DONT UNDERSTAND BUT BETTER TO SAY THE ALMIGHTY KNOWS BEST.
Shakim Allah

United States

#383 Dec 19, 2012
Watching in the Wings wrote:
No other prophet of God, other than Muhammad, committed murder.
Any human who breaks Gods own commandments can not be trusted to speak for God. It is totally illogical to accept this false premise, that Muhammad could have been guided by God when he broke the 6th commandment of God and claimed he had 'special rights'. Not even Jesus, who was born without sin, and persecuted unto death did not harm a single hair on a single head or shed a single drop of blood in violence. And when God was revealing through Jesus his perfect will, he taught us that we are not given the authority to judge, condemn or enact punishment on any human, that only GOD HIMSELF has this power.
Muhammad claimed authority and power that was not his to claim and claimed that God gave it to him, then he claimed that God said he never assigned "partners" with him. The teachings of Muhammad are so convoluted that it takes complete denial of logic to accept it. Yet Muslims right here on this forum have claimed it is the most logical religion...in an insane asylum perhaps.
MOSES killed a man, Made sure no one was lookin and buried him in the sand. I find it funny how the same people that brag about Muhammad getting his surahs from Christianity, but dont to accept the evils in those surahs, that came from Christianity. Its silly to condemn muslims for what they learned from Christians and Jews. ill leave it at that ;-)
rajhassan

Ashburn, VA

#384 Dec 21, 2012
prophet mohammad pubh is a last and final messenger he is a king of all messenger ok
rajhassan

Ashburn, VA

#385 Dec 21, 2012
salma yur kafir and yur murtad allha is a greatest and prophet mohammad (pubh) is a last and final messenger.
mirza gulam ahamad was a kafir murtad aur mirza are go to hell
Faith

New Baltimore, MI

#386 Dec 21, 2012
rajhassan wrote:
prophet mohammad pubh is a last and final messenger he is a king of all messenger ok
Muhammad was a criminally insane sociopath that fabricated his gutter religion in order to justify his criminal, sexually deviant acts....The end.
rajhassan

Ashburn, VA

#387 Dec 21, 2012
FAITH you are kafir yu ar go to hell. yu ar relligion is false and mirza was a kafir
Faith

New Baltimore, MI

#388 Dec 21, 2012
rajhassan wrote:
FAITH you are kafir yu ar go to hell. yu ar relligion is false and mirza was a kafir
Could you find someone sane to translate that into a language I can understand? Google Translate evidently hasn't added a Gibberish lexicon yet.
talat

Jeddah, Saudi Arabia

#389 Jan 30, 2013
dear brother a very minor misunderstanding lead u to this confusion i will try to explain it here.
regarding 40:34, Then, when he died you said, "GOD will not send any other prophet after him.
in this verse "he" is prophet yousuf and "you" is people of that time who said that Allah will not send any prophet after prophet yousuf.
it was an assumption of people which is quoted by Allah in his book. pls read a few lines back and after of this specific verse u will understand urself i m sure brother. thanks
talat

Jeddah, Saudi Arabia

#390 Jan 30, 2013
and i realy appreciate of ur intention to understand things
also i m sory how they shut u up which is realy not a good trend
prasad

Guntur, India

#391 Feb 1, 2013
brother you didnt underastand the language.so it will be better for you go to arabic school or madarsas becasuse we should understand the language not just read .

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Islam Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
No Muslim can think of profaning holy Prophet (... (Jan '11) 3 min Aryan 51,827
Allah "The Most Gracious, The Most Merciful" Pr... 4 min Lawrence Wolf 146
Islam Will Conquer Italy and the Entire West (Sep '10) 8 min chazmo 386,028
Buddhism v Islam in Asia: Fears of a new religi... (Jul '13) 9 min Hello 25
Millions of Muslims are leaving Islam in India! (Dec '11) 9 min Yupp111 221
There is no ALLAH. 11 min Rabbeen Al Jihad 195
20000 Americans Convert To ISLAM Each Year (May '12) 15 min Abdurratln 785
Who Is Allah? (Aug '07) 20 min Dragnet52 205,804
Reading Quran Increases IQ 20 min STEFANO COLONNA 154

Islam People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE