Comments
1 - 20 of 1,191 Comments Last updated Apr 20, 2014
First Prev
of 60
Next Last
Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

3

2

(PART I, CHAPTERS 1 - 14 = SOME SPECIAL ASPECTS OF ISLAM AS TOLD IN THE QURAN - THE HOLY BOOK OF MUHAMMAD, MUSLIMS, ISLAM, AND ALLAH.)

1. The Quran many places tells that Allah decides everything - absolutely everything (f. ex. the time of your death is decided even before you are born – when the foetus is 4 months old actually). But the Quran also tells that man has a free will. These two are not possible to combine.(Muslim thinkers have not been able to explain this through 1400 years (the same goes for the next 3 questions, whereas question no. 5 is not discussed in Islam - there may be death penalty or at least extrication for it)). F. ex.“The Message of the Quran”- a book certified by the al-Ahzar Muslim university in Cairo, one of the top Muslim universities and a book of high esteem in Muslim propaganda - says:“We can not explain it, but it has to be true, because it is said by Allah (in the Quran*)”. A total capitulation and a very impressive statement, especially when you know the Quran is full of mistaken facts and logically invalid statements,“signs” and “proofs”. See f. ex. the chapter about predestination and free will. Has man really free will? Or does Allah really decide everything? Both together are impossible in spite of what the Quran and Islam claims – as normal from Islam only unproven claims.
2. The Quran states that Allah is omniscient and knows everything also concerning the future. But the Quran also states that man has free will. These two statements are not possible to combine as mentioned above, because if man has free will, his actions will change the future - and it will not be possible to foresee these changes if man’s will really is free, this even if the will only is free to a miniscule degree. Is Allah really omniscient?– man can always change his mind once more if he has free will, and what then about what Allah thought he knew? See the chapter about predestination and free will.
3. The Quran states that Allah is omniscient and omnipotent. But it also states that Allah sends accidents and catastrophes and demands fighting and war – all this to test you. How does Islam combine these two statements?- if Allah is omniscient, he knows everything and testing is for no reason, and much of the testing totally destroys his image as a good god.
4. The Quran many places states that Allah blocks the way - or the way back - to Islam for some people, especially for “bad” persons. Allah’s “blocking” then makes them not regret and repent, which at least a few would have done under “normal” circumstances. All the same he sends these persons to Hell without giving them this chance to repent. How can he then be called a good god?
5. Islam and Hadiths tell that Allah decides 5 months before you are born whether you are to end in Paradise or Hell. How can a person doomed to Hell before he is even born be blamed for the bad things he is forced to do, and how can he think of Allah as a benevolent god?


Then there is the question of what values a society is built on. These values can roughly be split.
Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#3
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

2

1

b- The word five month(5)month, this is also false and invented statement. Allah knows every thing even still you have not come in womb of your mother in other words still a father has not touch his wife,

(Question-3)

5. And an afterthought: In the book “The Message of the Quran”, certified by Al-Azhar Al-Sharif Islamic Research Academy in Cairo (one of the 2-3 top universities in the Muslim world on such subjects) in a letter dated 27. Dec. 1998, it is admitted rather reluctantly that there are no proofs for Allah, and that it is not possible to prove him. An additonal point here is that if there is no proof for Allah and impossible to prove him, automatically there also is no proof for, and impossible to prove Muhammad's claimed connection to a god. And if there is no Allah and/or no connection between Muhammad and a god, what then is Islam?Mengal.

(Answer)

c- Again hundered percent invented lie and false statement., Your own existence and existence of present universe all that pointing out Lord Almighty Allah. Come and read the Quran..
d--1- say He is Allah,
e- The One and Only,
f- 2-Allah, the Eternal, Abolute;
g- 3-He begetteth not,
h- Nor is Hebegotten;
i- And there is none
j- Like unto Him.

A Muslim can doubt even of his own existence but Not of Allah The lord of universe. So these and similar are contradictions of Quran ?. Really a human becomes ashamed of such like people who spread mischief and falsehood in universe and creating cahaouse and disturbance,
Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#4
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

2

2

Qadir Mengal wrote:
Thus please take into consideration the teachings of Islam in a judicious, wise, critical, analytical manner just to satisfy to yourself that you have made no mistake in choice of religion. I am fully confident that you after analytical study of Islam would be compelled to declare according to Anochy the great and famous Japans (Japans) wrestler.
“That today after accepting Islam my Journey towards searching the truth has become complete’’
Mengal

I started looking into islam after the stupid taliban destroyed the buddhas of bamiyan in March 2001. I have read the koran and lots of the hadiths. I HAVE looked at the texts judiciously and critically. And I have utterly rejected islam as any kind of true religion. What true deity would give women the position they have in islam of being repressed and subservient to men? ALL PEOPLE ARE EQUAL. What true deity would prescribe death for someone who changes imaginary friends? What true deity would have a prophet who was into pedophilia, condoning rape, and murdering people who insulted him? What true deity would try to suppress and repress all other ways of worshiping? What true deity would demand that people lose ALL their natural rights to a CULT? NO true deity would be this ignorant, repressive, and intolerant. I reject islam completely. Allah is a false god, and mohamed was no real prophet at all...just a power-hungry, amoral, dog-hating azzh0le. Enough with the nonsense, Qadir Mengal. Islam has to start answering some really tough questions, or it's going down in a hurry. I will continue to close hearts to islam. You can't fight the TRUTH, Qadir. And it's getting out there. And you can't stop it. Too bad if muslims feelings are hurt. They need to know that they are in a cult, and they need to stop wasting their lives in service of a false god and a false prophet. Hint: if you can't defend it, it's probably wrong.
Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#5
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

3

1

Mengal.

Dear sick of it

Adams Center, NY,

Love and peace for you and your family members Dear i do not know whether your comments are result of any hate or you honestly according to your own knowledge has express yourself, In former case you definitely never would get truth and like George whyte and buford even after convincing of truth reject every material howsoever it my be convencing, where as in case of later there is chance that you may get truth,At the very beginning I honestly tell you without prejudice, if you have to follow any religion than kindly in your own interest accept Islam,Otherwise my humble and honest advice for you to become Atheist and spent your life what ever way you like.Though you have raised so many objections in his post and every part of your statement requires to be corrected,because you have big misunderstanding however i just for your knowledge first attend the discrimination between men and women in Islam
Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#6
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

3

1

Qadir Mengal wrote:
Mengal.
Dear sick of it
Adams Center, NY,
Love and peace for you and your family members Dear i do not know whether your comments are result of any hate or you honestly according to your own knowledge has express yourself, In former case you definitely never would get truth and like George whyte and buford even after convincing of truth reject every material howsoever it my be convincing, where as in case of later there is chance that you may get truth,At the very beginning I honestly tell you without prejudice, if you have to follow any religion than kindly in your own interest accept Islam,Otherwise my humble and honest advice for you to become Atheist and spent your life what ever way you like.Though you have raised so many objections in his post and every part of your statement requires to be corrected,because you have big misunderstanding however i just for your knowledge first attend the discrimination between men and women in Islam.

I don't feel my statement needs to be corrected. I have not said anything inaccurate. Women do not have the same rights in islam as men. This is fact. And this is wrong. WE ARE ALL EQUAL. There is no justification for women's evidence being half as valid as a man's in a court. There is no justification for men being able to have 4 wives but women only being allowed one husband. There is no justification for women to have to be accompanied by a male family member if they leave the house. WE ARE ALL EQUAL. Any god that would treat half of his human creations in this way is a false god. A true deity knows this simple fact: WE ARE ALL EQUAL. Any religion that promotes or increases inequity between the sexes is wrong. Period. End of story. You may play with words all you wish but you cannot change the facts or alter the truth. Islam is a lie. WE ARE ALL EQUAL.
Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#8
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

3

1

MUSLIM WOMAN, MARRIAGE AND WESTERN HUMAN RIGHTS

Who-Infidel Ayyan-
Brutal islam.9/11 is work of terrorist Muslims. Women a slave creature serve men. No liberty in Islam…………………………

Mengal

Infidel Ayyan Hersi, your thinking and approach towards Islam and Muslim woman is strange one, how beautifully you have link islam with 9/11 incident, You very well Know that a group of Muslims due to injustices of west have started a struggle in shape of Alqaida, And due to their teachings small groups of Muslims of different parts influenced and started struggle to liberate them from High handedness of western world, There fore such incidents happening by hand of these groups. Which have no relevancy with Islam, or Muslim World? Do you not read and see that, all the scholars of Islam declared this incident against the teachings of Islam. If you know the, Islamic point of view, then, listen, Islam prohibits taking the life of an innocent person and declares war against such people whether, they be Muslim or belong to west or any other part of world. According to Holly Quran, who-ever save life of one innocent person, he did an act to save the whole world.

Amazingly you repeatedly talking about Human rights of Muslim women, In the cover of Islam, While Muslim women having more right than west, Today women of west is almost looking like a labor, While virtually In Islamic World or Islamic way of life, Muslim man has to work as a labor for women, and his duty is provide all nesses ties to women, and did not compel her to go to work. You have deprived the poor woman from her cloths in slogan of freedom. And misguided her to serve man to make him Happy and called it freedom,

West must know that Muslim woman has equal rights with man and it is totally absurd to say that Islam allows to beat a woman, Actually Quran only permits a man in last resort to some what aggressive attitude in case of woman’s sharing bed of man with an other stranger man though prior that even ask the man to be away from her bed let her alone be remain and repent, If this not work and she does not let the way of shameless than in lost resort semblance beating. If it does not work than separate her by pronouncing divorce. The woman before all this, even if, does not want to live with man, could get divorce through court. In Islamic law women could take divorce only on complaint, if her husband beats her., According to Islamic law marriage is a contract, And, for every contract seven (7) conditions are necessary,.

1- Parties should be Major.

2- Parties should be sound mind and sane.

3- There must be proposing, by one party and acceptance by the other Party.

4- There must be free consent, No any coercion, deceit or fraud must be present from the side of any party.

5- There must be consideration behind the contract, without any consideration contract is not valid and is void.

6- There must be witnesses of the contract, in absence of witness contract is not acceptable.

7- If parties are minor or insane than there must be a Legal heir to inter in to contract in benefit of minor or insane. However in case of reaching majority minor could make decision to separate him or her from the contract.
Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#14
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

3

1

Mengal.
Yes Buford, it was so strange when Prophet first time told it to his family members his own cousin Omma Hani(Dauter of his uncle) told the prophet .O,prophet please do not say this fact to the people, as non believe you and it will damage your mission, See a common house hold lady knows the consequence of the statement about the Journey, Do you think Mohammad (saw)have had no such capacity to understand about the cretinism of pagans, Particularly no one had experience of speed to cover 40 kilometer to a day, and here Mohammad saying that in a night he went to Yorchilam ,Philistine pray in temple Aqsa than visit heavens came back, You like people were also present at Madina and at once news of this statement reached every house of Madina, The pagans ,Mushreks or non believers like you started laughing at Prophet, so as started taunting raising finger about Messenger and the message or Quran, Just like you pagans, non believers informed Abubaker , telling him that your friend Mohammad(saw) saying that in a night he visited Mosque or temple of Aqsa Yoroshalem or philistine and came back, Initially Abubakar told them you un-believeres telling lie, Mohammad would not say so, However if really Mohammad has said so, than it is hundred percent correct,When taunting did not stop, than Abubakar suggested the Hypocrites that you all Know that Mohammad never in his life visited to philistine and seen the Mosque or Temple of Philistine, let as many of you even i have visited to Temple or Mosque al-Aqsa, so come we ask prophet some signes of mosque or temple and its surroundings, if Mohammad has seen the Temple he would give us correct answer otherwise you may say whatever you say, This advise of Abubakar accepted by all the Hippocrates and pagans. So a panel along with Abubakar went to Prophet and this suggestion was put to Mohammad(saw)..A pause silence, And Than Prophet told to the panel to ask, Now every one who has seen the temple and its surrounding started Question and Mohammad(saw) revealing or pointing out the same, So this way all the Hypocrites become silent, But,But ,But 1400hundred back one Buford repeating the same story, Prophet later on' said that when
Abubakar kept this suggestion before me, it appears me that earth slip under my feet,I worried I had not given any attention to the Temple or Mosque, But immediately the Lord Allah presented the Temple and all its surroundings, So people asked me and i gave them information from it. Buford perhaps you for the last ten years despite knowing real facts just being a jew like Goerge whyte continuously criticizing, And confirming the prophecy of Quran that Jews would be the hardened enemies of Islam and on contrary Christian would extend sympathy to islam and muslims, and they would accept the truth, So Quranic or Prophets prophecy seems hundred percent correct.
Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#15
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

2

1

THINK.
"There are over a billion muslim's, are they going to continue to praise Bin Laden as a great and noble person and aspire to kill like he did? Or will they come to there sense and beging to act like people of God and share in accepting the love of their neighbor and give love and care fore their neighbor as God wants man to do?"

Mengal.
A beautiful and humanly comment by think, Dear think please without exaggeration being fellow brother and one who to promote love and sympathy, does not salute and bow his head before this personality Who teach as follow?

1. A Muslim should share with his neighbor any fruit which he brings for his children or family, if he cannot, So he must not throw its peal or skin out of his house which at rack the children of neighbor.
2- No Muslim is Muslim who sleep with full stomach but his neighbor sleeps with hungry.
Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#16
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

2

1

Last sermon of Prophet Mohammad(saw)

who="Quadratus"]The fact is Muslims reject the worship of all the other prophets, except Muhammed. And at the same time they say God does not change! Good luck on judgment day.

[Mengal

O, Dear Quadratus "Muslim believe, all messengers from God. And respect them, However all prophets were meant to that time and for that people. Hence final message came through final messenger namely Mohammad, Quran is purely in its virgin position without change of single Dot. As such it is for you to get truth or reject the same, however, according to sayings of prophet when he was leaving the world. He in presence of more than ten thousand people in his last pilgrimage while addressing the people said, a glimpse of that i am mentioning for your information and consideration.
Mohammad(saw)
." O, People hear me carefully. Your religion today has been completed, and Allah has completed has mercy upon you. and has chosen for you Islam. Hear me o, people from today Humans are equal in all respect, No Blake is superior to that of white and no white is superior to that of black .No Arab has superiority over non Arab and so no non Arab has superiority over Arab. The usury is prohibited and in first step I forgive the usury of my tribe Bany Hashim. And no one form now paid ad ional amount to Bany Hashim, O people Hear me you do not find me next time here in Arafat I am leaving you. Listen me i am leaving among you two things Quran And my Sunnah (tridition) you will not be astray until you hold both fast. O people as I would not be present among you ,so on ward it is your duty what ever you listen to convey those who are not present. And than when prophet reached Medina than within three(3) months he left the world. However this is our belief in respect of all prophets,

" I believe in Allah his angles, His books and his Prophets And the day of judgment and to this that every good or bad happens that is from Allah And that we will be raised after death."
Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#17
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

3

1

who="Paul WV"]<quoted text>
The koran is a book?????? Are you muslim?.

Mengal.

Yes this is wonder of Koran see/

1- Word “World’’ has been used -115- times in Quran
Word “ Here After” also has been used-115-times in Quran.

2-Word “Life” has been used-145- times in Quran.
Word “Death” has been used-145- times in Quran.

3-word “Satan” has been used-88- times in Quran.
Word “ Angel “has been used -88- times in Quran.

4-Word “Non believe” has been used -25- times in Quran.

Word “Faith” has been used -25 times in Quran.

5-word “Month “ used in Quran -12- times . And months of year are-12- twelve.

6- Word “ Day” used in Quran -365- times. And days of year are -365- days
Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#18
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

3

1

Paul WV wrote:
<quoted text>
Moses was not a descendent of Ishmael.

Neither was Muhammad.
Mengal,
Dear Ishmael and Ishaq both are sons of Abraham prophet, The Arabs are descendant of Ishmael and Moses including Jesus are descendants of Ishaq, so by this way Arabs and Is realities are cousin to each other. Thus Mohammad is like Moses in all respect Moses brought Sharia or law for his tribe so Mohammad also brought sharia or law for his people un like that there is no any law in Teachings of Jesus so there why Gay marriages and so as marriages between woman to woman and man to man happening. Mohammad having father and mother, but unlike Jesus has no any father. Mohamed’s mission succeeded his own life like Moses but Jesus failed and killed or raised high in heavens. I do not understand that why you insisting pure un ambiguous facts and searching un related likeness between Jesus and Moses.

Paul WV wrote:

JESUS - The Son of God, acknowledged from GOD himself, so there is no arguement there.
God was his father. Acknowledged by God himself. So again, No arguement there.
was persecuted from the crib, True, this was very well documented.
was not told to emigrate,
was crucified. History, and the bible both confirm this..........

Simple.

Mengal .

Dear Paul WV ,according your own arguments Jesus is not like Moses. OK we for a while accept that Jesus was son of God But than Moses was not son of God, please I request you to leave your absurd arguments and do not Hate Mohammad (saw) in his own interest.
Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#19
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

3

1

who="george whyte <quoted text>none of these people becone muslim, why is that

[Mengal,

Dear george whyte perhaps you are right,I personally not aware of these becoming Muslim, But your question why is that,is a difficult question ,Because Uncle of prophet Abujehl once in presence of his clan without any ambiguity said I know my nephew is messenger of God But by god i do not obey him to become his follower as always our clan compete to his clan for superiority, so now how i accept his superiority over me, However Quran says Allah guides only those who seek Guidance, according to Quran science, wisdom or knowledge never guide, otherwise Pharaoh of Egypt fully aware of this fact that he is not God but even than he did not leave claim of his being god. Dear George failed student is known by his teacher very well but despite that teacher test him through proper prescribed manner that he on tomorrow may not say that teacher without teaching and testing him failed him. As admittedly Allah has made clear to man the truth and light, separated it from darkness, so it is up to men to go either way, time of testing is also prescribed such as Day of judgment,
Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#20
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

3

1

4- Moses, Jesus And Mohammed(saw).
5-

who="Quadratus"
6- God promised Moses that a sign that a particular prophet was that final prophet, the one that God said specifically that He would require people to obey, was that He would be "like unto" Moses. Here is how my Lord Jesus Christ is like unto Moses. I challenge any Muslim to show us that Muhammed was more like Moses:
1. Both Moses and Jesus had kings try to kill them as infants.
2. Both Moses and Jesus were saved by seeking refuge among the Egyptians.
3.Both Moses and Jesus were rejected by their people in their first advent to israel.
4. Both Moses and Jesus left Israel and got a Gentile bride.
5. Moses saved Israel in his second advent. Jesus will save israel in His second advent.
6. In their times, both Moses and Jesus were known as the greatest miracle workers in history.
7. Both Moses and Jesus fasted apart from the people for 40 days and nights.
8. Moses codified the sacrificial system for atoning for sin, Jesus fulfilled it.
9. Both Moses' and Jesus' bodies disappeared after their deaths.
Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#21
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

3

1

Mengal,

"God promised Moses that a sign that a particular prophet was that final prophet, the one that God said specifically that He would require people to obey, was that He would be "like unto" Moses. Here is how prophet Mohammad(saw).

1-Moses died of his natural death so as Mohammad . Unlike Jesus who was crucified.

2-Moses having father and mother like Mohammad(saw). but unlike Jesus had no father.
3-Moses helped by his followers and finally he succeeded to become king of Israels Like Mohammad who was helped by his followers against pagans he succeeded and became king of Arabs. Unlike Jesus his followers left him he became helpless and not succeeded in result was murdered.

4-Moses in his life enforced the Mosaic law or sharia, so As Mohammad(saw) but unlike Jesus his mission was not completed in his own life than his disciples distorted his teachings.

5- Moses codified the stoning the Rapist So did ordered Mohammad (saw) and fulfill the teachings But UN like Jesus law of tit for tat ask followers who one slap on one cheek present the other cheek

^ Moses buried by his followers after his death And so as Mohammad(saw) but unlike Jesus who was taken to heaven,
&-
7-Moses left his native place than come bake fight with Faroah and succeed. So as Mohammad(saw) also left his native place went Medina and come back fought and succeeded. Un like Jesus he was caught hold and hanged.
Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#22
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

2

1

Quadratus


rabia wrote:
it was cold winter night when me, my mom and my younger brother left our home. we didn't know where to go but our destiny was heaven .we were in search of GOD. We were walking on the track of light and right. we were busy in his remembrance because one sufi who came to our village for tableegh he told our people adopt right path, right ways of life. he told us abt one GOD.
one day during our journey we saw a giant bear coming towards us but my mom said don't worry we are in search of GOD we can't see HIM but HE knows where are we he will help us and by saying this me and my mom begged ALLAH for help and suddenly land sliding happened and that bear was no more. after seeing this miracles our faiths became more stronger.3 months were gone and we were unable to find a muslim village and one day we entered to baltistan(PAKISTAN)there we saw some men we asked them to help and our new brothers helped us. they gave us food to eat and clothes to wear and took us to a Masjid ad there we became muslims officially by reciting Kalima of light and right(touheed).
we faced a lot of difficulties in our journey toward GOD.BUT AT THE END ALLAH TA'ALA gave us alot HE has blessed us with peace of mind. i don't have sacttered faiths’ don't worship those thing(stars ,moons, sun, animals, mountains e tc) which are busy in ALLAH'S worship.

Quadratus

Rabia, that is a very touching story, Stories of people searching for God affect me deeply. When I was seventeen I was not a good person. I cared nothing for God, I hated church, prayer bored me to tears, I hated reading God's word, Christian music bored me terribly, I much preferred rock. I did not obey God, and had no intentions of ever doing so. The one day while forced to be at church, God called me to Him. For the first time I saw the evil in my heart, and I saw that Jesus Christ had died on the cross for my sins, and had risen from the dead three days later. That day I repented of my sin and believed in Jesus as my God and Savior. Within one day I was transformed. Now I loved God, I loved His word, I loved church and being with other Christians, I wanted to pray, and for the first time in my life I began obeying God from my heart. I know two things about that day. I was completely changed from the inside out, and I didn't do it. I was saved by Jesus my God.
Now Rabia, you had a powerful experience, and I had a powerful experience. Yet our experiences contradict each other. How does one determine which experience is truly from God?

Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#23
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

3

1

Qadir Mengal
, Pakistan

who="Quadratus"
Rabia, that is a very touching story, Stories of people searching for God affect me deeply. When I was seventeen I was not a good person. I cared nothing for God, I hated church, prayer bored me to tears, I hated reading God's word, Christian music bored me terribly, I much preferred rock. I did not obey God, and had no intentions of ever doing so. The one day while forced to be at church, God called me to Him. For the first time I saw the evil in my heart, and I saw that Jesus Christ had died on the cross for my sins, and had risen from the dead three days later. That day I repented of my sin and believed in Jesus as my God and Savior. Within one day I was transformed. Now I loved God, I loved His word, I loved church and being with other Christians, I wanted to pray, and for the first time in my life I began obeying God from my heart. I know two things about that day. I was completely changed from the inside out, and I didn't do it. I was saved by Jesus my God.
Now Rabia, you had a powerful experience, and I had a powerful experience. Yet our experiences contradict each other. How does one determine which experience is truly from God?

Mengal,
Dear Quadratus
Please also judge this true story from history of Islam. The second caliph umer conquered Egypt and than appointed his Governor to rule and also collect the Usher or Islimic Tex, The inhabitants residing near to Nile river before accepting islam having custom that every year in start of year, make up a beautiful girl and than hand over it to Nile river by throwing it in to river and in that sacrifice the river gave them water or irrigated their land for the whole year, So on coming of year they all came and requested the Governor for throwing girl, The governor prohibit them in result the water of Nile started receding and even came level of drying the people started going back to its original religion .Looking this Governor wrote Caliph Umer and informed him about the matter, Where upon Umer, the caliph wrote a letter to the name of River Nile,
Saying, "In the name of Allah the most Gracious, and the most merciful, O. River Nile if You belong Allah than give water to the people if you belong to other than Allah than do whatever you wish,"
After writing this same was handed over to a messenger who brought it to Governor and that Governor took the people to Nile and on throwing the letter in to Nile river same as busted of water and touch the levels where ever before water had not reached.


" Mengal,
Dear Quadratus On the day of Judgment when such type of people to be asked to call for help to these Gods ,patrons and helpers to help him and save him from hell fire, he called them but gets no reply than beg to lord sent him back in world that he may reject them and serve true lord but he will be asked that time is over why truth has not reach you and prophets have not warn you , thus he will thrown in to hell fire which is bad place.
Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#24
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

3

1

Islamic principles in war with enemy.

The Islamic Caliph bound to insure the Muslim army must follow the following principles in war.

1- the woman and children of enemy shall not be killed.

2- The priests and clerics also not to be killed and they are to be treated honorably.

3- The sick and non combatants also will not be murdered.

4-All prayer places to be kept safe and no any church and sanygoug will be destroyed.

5- No orchard or standing crop will be damaged.
Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#25
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

3

1

WHO-MADSCOT

If "god" is beyond the universe, how can you know what he thinks or what he does or can do?
Actually, if god did exist, there would be some sort of sign that scientists could find. Since there none...
Since you are the one that claims he exists, you are the one that has to supply proof. So, let's see your proof outside of a holy book.

Who- Mengal.
Dear madscot. God is appearing from His creation very well, But what about if you spot far away a smoke, than please tell me what you think about same, whether you automatically without arguments will not admit that same is result of any fire, Why you think so, because without fire smoke cannot be exist. Here what has forced you to not accept despite seeing presence of sun, earth other stars including your self with perfect order, than why you demanding to one show you the God but not there insist to show him first the Fire than you admit that there is fire or same is result of any fire.
Dear madscot, The Quran and Prophet of Islam are the best proof of that God Whom we worship. We know through logic the capacity of any human for acquiring any knowledge or having experience, that a human how could get knowledge?
Any one in his life only could acquire certain knowledge in a particular time period in a particular subject in which he after spending his whole life to learn and made experiments. Yes if prophet of Islam the Mohammed(saw) would not come with such teachings than surely it would have been difficult for us to believe or know accurately presence of one God and surely you would have seen us worshiping different things, This is why the humans who so deprived the actual teachings of Islam wandering to resolve the very questions about existence of one creator but Muslims on this subject due to presence of Quran or acquaint of Mohammed (saw)having no slightest doubt about creator and this Muslim knows after learning the life of Mohammed(saw).There are hundreds of examples which show that there is Power behind the knowledge or teachings of Mohammed (saw). And that Power is not any Human But it is a Supper natural the one to whom Prophet Mohammed called the creator of universe, named Him Allah the God. Only one or two living prophesies out of the hundred are enough if you are really honest and rightly thinking other wise you know that words miracles never guide or convince a person to right path.
Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#26
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

3

1

RELIGION AND COMMENTS OF HUMAN

Who "Human" Religion is with out a doubt at the top of my list of things that I have Anger issues with.
I am so angry about the injustices done in the name of deities and even more angry because, I do not know how to deal with it.
And it really pi**es me off that any evil under the sun which is done in the name
Of some deity for the cause of some religion is accepted as divine good by masses
Of people who are so desperate that they will blindly serve any and all lies any and
All crap that religion dishes out, because they are made slaves of that religion .Slaves
Who dare not question there master! No matter how wrong there master may be!
And they want to enslave us as well, Enslavement to the will of the ancient dead is no
Kind of life for those of us who know what life can be beyond slavery.

Who-Mengal.
Al-Messeri, was telling let ask this person what purpose the pen is made for, Answer would come for writing. Car is made for what purpose answer for mounting and traveling. Water and other earthly creatures for sub serving humanity, And Human for What purpose, answer for nothing / Lo: this is wisdom of human, How he for gets and denies His creator and denies that all other thing made to do or serve to any other creature or for man But man the most high for nothing and nature the dead material is result of an intelligent entity, How for away from wisdom and how the human is ungrateful to his creator.

Qadir Mengal

Pakistan

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#27
Nov 15, 2011
 

Judged:

3

3

1

SNOW QUOTE “DEAR MENGAL YOU HAVE WRITTEN VERY INTERESTING POST”

You have written a very interesting post!
There are a big misunderstanding between you and the atheist way of thinking; that is for sure.
The universe probably mostly is energy, yes even matter is energy at rest, what we can se around us are only ashes from the energy flow from concentration spots like stars and outwards. Our own tiny world here on earth is made out from these ashes that we call matter. Even when matter feels firm and strong and looks so to us it is mostly empty space. The whole earth could be concentrated to the size of a football or even smaller. And there are unseen dimensions to us where energy and matter pops in and out from, in reality very interesting.
But the main thing about it, there is no God plan behind it. It just happens in the process of balancing the energy flow. The ashes are created and give an almost infinite number of possibilities for interesting combinations of constructions. Some of these caused our creation, just by coincident. Yes, it is fantastic, especially for us who are so lucky to be able to experience our own existence. And we should take well care of this fantastic opportunity.
But still nature that created us, just by coincident doesn’t mind about us at all! We are not important at all. Life has no other purpose than life itself, to maintain generations to follow. There is no plan other than the laws of nature running the whole process. So does this understanding make atheists less happy or less morally able? Not at all! The difference between atheists and religious people is the freedom atheists have to choose high morals judged by their own feelings and experience and not morals told to them. Morals followed by religious people and that they in reality don’t always understand well is more harmful to them. Sometimes they follow only it in fear of being excluded from their social group or even worse, being punished for it. It is a life in fear and frustration, caused by their social belonging.

Mengal
Dear Snow: your thought or perception about our existence seems is that, we have got life in co- incidence and there is no any conscious or intelligent act behind our creation, further, your above post clearly shows that our own earth sun or other stars are remainders of energy. Which is located High above, or beyond reach of our present world. And admittedly there is no any perception in your mind about presence of the ocean of energy, chemical or matter. Let, for a moment we consider the nature, presence and working of our own world in which we are living. Admittedly the origin of our sun, moon, earth, air, water & other like stars are one and same and while all this is a part of emitting energy or chemical or matter .The period of separation and emitting of this ashes or energy is also same and one, than please, you ever has thought, why this energy located in different shapes and types. Some places this energy is shining such as like sun on other places this energy or martial has got no effect from any evolution where as, some places the said material or energy located in shape of our earth or moon. This material or chemical some where, appearing like air and water. This material or energy all together, standing in different shapes and is cause of our existence. I have read an article about existence of life and genome. It is so, complicated and strange that in a position never, never our life could take place as co-incidence.

Tell me when this thread is updated: (Registration is not required)

Add to my Tracker Send me an email

First Prev
of 60
Next Last
Type in your comments below
Name
(appears on your post)
Comments
Characters left: 4000
Type the numbers you see in the image on the right:

Please note by clicking on "Post Comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

•••
•••