Comments
41 - 60 of 106 Comments Last updated Jul 26, 2014
Taliban killer

Akron, OH

#45 Oct 12, 2012
Sheikh Rayees wrote:
Brother these are genuine errors which have been pointed out in vedas. Vedas says earth is static,earth is flat,sun revolves round the earth etc etc one doesnt need to be more efficient to understand this. An average human can understand it without much effort. Comming to the ur point of error in Quran then let me tell u there is not a single error in Quran or any other authentic Book of Islam. No one yet could mention a single error. Even modern science accepts the teachings of Islam. What is mentioned in Quran is being discovered now by science. Quran says earth is round, Quran says rain comes from clouds, Quran says earth revolves around the sun, Quran says moon doesnt have its own light, Quran says earth will change its direction of rotation and science proving it now. My brother all this has been mentioned in Quran more than 1400 years ago. Either you accepts the scientific errors in Vedas or you reject the philosophy of science.
and everything you said the Quran said was said 1000 or so years before Mohammad. See ancient Greek scholars.
prajwal gowda

Bangalore, India

#46 Oct 15, 2012
Saabi Soole makla
prajwal gowda

Bangalore, India

#47 Oct 15, 2012
One whole Islam will be eradicated ..
Rehman

Aurora, Canada

#48 Oct 15, 2012
truth wrote:
all hindus are madarchod gandus
Yes indeed! Not even one brahmin open his stupid mouth to say something againt the above accusations?
paritosh

Mumbai, India

#49 Dec 5, 2012
AayaM gaaO: paRiSnark`xmaIdsadna\ maatarM paur:|
ipatar ca pa`yantsva:||
ŕ yajauvao-d 3ó6

The Earth with all its waters
Revolves round the sun.

Or

The Earth revolves
With its mother water In its orbit,
The Earth revolves
Around its father, the Sun.
- Yajur Veda 3/6
gagik

Yerevan, Armenia

#50 Dec 20, 2012
bro, how can a book says.. sun is moving around the earth and at same time in other page saying moon and sun are fixed !!.. u got wrong information...even if u read also..its out of ur thoughts to understand its inner meaning. vedas text is not a simple text to understand all- its is writen with deep meanings
Debra M

Mount Vernon, WA

#51 Jan 10, 2013
abu huzaifa wrote:
The above verse says the Sun did not
had light before Indra gave the light to
Sun.
Rig Veda 10.62.3 Ye raised the Sun to
heaven by everlasting Law, and spread
broad earth, the Mother
And the above verse also says the sun
was raised to heaven, which is a
scientific error. Because the Sun is not
above us, the Earth is revolving around
the Sun.
2: The Vedas says THE EARTH HAS
FOUR CORNERS AND ENDS
The Stone Age Vedic science have gone
one step ahead in stupidity it says the
Earth has ends and sides
Atharva Veda 15.7.1 He, having
become moving majesty, went to the
ends of the earth…
अन&#23 81;त [Anta]= End
सी&#23 50;ा [Siimaa]= boundary, End
It’s very amazing that where did Virat
went when the earth is spherical in
shape, and how can someone go to the
ENDS OF THE EARTH when it is
Spherical.
**********
THE CHRISTIAN BIBLE SAYS THE SAME THING :
Isa_11:12 And he shall set up an ensign for the nations, and shall assemble the outcasts of Israel, and gather together the dispersed of Judah from the four corners of the earth.
Does that also "PROVE" the Christian Faith as WRONG..LOL
I suggest that you refrain from literal interpretation :)
and look for what is hidden beneath the surface
**********
Atharva Veda 20.88.1 Him who with
might hath propped earth's ends…
Rig Veda 1.62.8 Still born afresh, young
Dames, each in her manner, unlike in
hue, the Pair in alternation around four
sides of earth
Rig Veda 4.50.1 Him who with might
hath propped earth's ends…
Rig Veda 10.58.3 Thy spirit, that went
far away, away to the four-cornered
earth
4 Thy spirit, that went far away to the
four quarters of the world
Rig Veda 6.62.1 . I LAUD the Heroes
Twain, this heaven's Controllers:
singing with songs of praise I call the
Asvins,Fain in a moment, when the
morns are breaking, to part the earth's
ends
THE BIBLE SAYS THE SAME THING....:) ♥
Isa_11:12 And he shall set up an ensign for the nations, and shall assemble the outcasts of Israel, and gather together the dispersed of Judah from the four corners of the earth.

“Mad as Hell”

Since: Sep 12

Location hidden

#52 Jan 10, 2013
When will you fools understand that ANY book or statement thousands of years old has a high chance of being wrong, just as civilisation a 1000 years in the future will make our current level of knowledge and understanding appear childlike.

There is no way to make one religion appear better than another especially when comparing wrongs, misconceptions, mis-translations etc.

Be free from this garbage:
http://ffrf.org/
Slave of PBUH

Guwahati, India

#54 Mar 1, 2013
The above text that Mr. Abu zafia written is just basless. It has no logic, the whole translation is wrong. So it is better not to see it.

For me Vedas is expired text , and our holy book is the new one . So it is better to follow our holy book.
Abc

Paris, France

#55 Mar 22, 2013
truth wrote:
all hindus are madarchod gandus
ur prophet was a rapist of 5 yrs old child aisha.... Most of u are voilent nature, bcoz thats what ur allah teaches.... All terroist are the product of ur quaran n still u claim islam is peace. Just watch ur words..namsate...
Hassan

London, UK

#56 Mar 22, 2013
hinduism is a religion and mystical. You are supposed to delve into Hinduism to find the inner meaning.
Islam is not a religion. It is a dogma of laws & personal grievances from Muhammad.
Islam is you baap

United States

#57 Mar 25, 2013
Abc wrote:
<quoted text> ur prophet was a rapist of 5 yrs old child aisha.... Most of u are voilent nature, bcoz thats what ur allah teaches.... All terroist are the product of ur quaran n still u claim islam is peace. Just watch ur words..namsate...
Do you have any proof that Muhammd raped Aisha.You stupid
Samm

Mumbai, India

#58 Mar 30, 2013
It is hilariously interesting to note that there are comparisions between islam,christianity & HINDUISM->THERE ARE NO COMPARISIONS ,HINDUISM IS THE MOTHER OF ALL RELIGIONS!! PERIOD!!(by the way,the word -HINDUISM is an incorrect pronounce by the original iranian people i.e the Parsis a.k.a the Zorastrians who were CRUELLY MURDERED AND DRIVEN OUT FROM THEIR OWN COUNTRY BY MOSLEMS AND NOW HAVE FOUND REFUGE IN HINDUSTAN!).
It actually meant people living near the SINDHU river!..pronounciation issues by the Parsis which was also later followed by Arabs who traded with the people living during the SINDHU river!!.
JUST ONE CLASSIC EXAMPLE COPIED BY OTHER RELIGIONS AND TAKEN FROM THE HINDU SCRIPTURES IS THE VERY 1ST STORY FROM THE "DUS AVATAR" OR 10 AVATARS OF VISHNUJI! IT IS THE FISH OR THE "MATSYA" AVATAR AND IN THIS AVATAR KING MANU WAS GUIDED BY LORD VISHNU IN THE FORM OF A FISH TO MAKE A BOAT AND PACK IT UP WITH A PAIR OF EVERY LIVING BEINGS-(HUMAN,ANIMAL,TREES,BIR DS,ETC..)
REASON BEING THAT THE WORLD WAS TO BE DESTROYED BY A GIANT FLOOD COMING FROM THE SEA AND WOULD BE NEEDED TO BE REBUILT ALL OVER AGAIN..
WHEN THIS FLOOD WOULD COME INLAND--LORD VISHNU WOULD GUIDE THE BOAT WITH KING MANU AND THE OTHER PAIRS TO THE CENTRE OF THE OCEAN WHERE IT IS ALWAYS CALM EVEN IN A THE CASE OF A STORM!
ONCE THE WATERS RECEDED ,KING MANU(THE LAW MAKER) WOULD THEN REBUILD THE WHOLE WORLD AGAIN!!)
--NOW THE FRADULENT PART FROM THE christians--the CONCOPTED FALSE Story of the so-called 'noah's ark'.. A DIRECT RIP-OFF OF THE MATSYA AVATAR OF LORD VISHNU..

THE moslems too become fradent as they too believe in this fraudulent story as their religious teachers keep on mentioning noah-giving examples about the same and then following it with words :peace be upon him!!!
WHAT A FRADULENT JOKE!!

FOLLOWING SANATAN DHARM - MEANING 'HUMANITY IS THE RELIGION- LOVE & HELP YOUR FELLOW HUMANS!' IS THE ONLY WAY TO MOVE FORWARD TOWARDS PEACE & SPIRITUAL ENLIGHTENMENT..
sku

United States

#59 Apr 2, 2013
this is mis explain of veda.
Gandu Ganesh

Arlington, TX

#60 Apr 2, 2013
abu huzaifa wrote:
VEDAS ALSO SAYS THE SUN AND
MOON ARE FIXED
Yajur Veda 4.25 …He has fixed the
bright sun and the moon
Hinduism is a fraud.
They worship sexual organs.
honey Singh

Hyderabad, India

#61 Apr 16, 2013
Allah Hu Shaitan wrote:
What a disgusting Pig was Mohammed. Whenever I read about this Pig I become more and more determined to eradicate the evil named Islam.
why do you read about your god (pig), yeah pig which eats shit is a god in Hinduism called varaha,salo ko sharam ani chahiye aise janvaro ki pooja karke.
aur suvar, now dont think im calling you god. Vedas says earth (prithvi) is static and immovable not Indian or your arse peninsula.
honey Singh

Hyderabad, India

#62 Apr 16, 2013
Abc wrote:
<quoted text> ur prophet was a rapist of 5 yrs old child aisha.... Most of u are voilent nature, bcoz thats what ur allah teaches.... All terroist are the product of ur quaran n still u claim islam is peace. Just watch ur words..namsate...
hazrat aisha was the WIFE of prophet Muhammad, he did not had com illicit relationship like your gods

just look at your religion man, your god Shiva raped Vishnu he was a homosexual, he raped poor Vishnu when he was in his MOHINI avatar. indra raped ahalya and was cursed by gautama and lost his testicles, lol then he had to borrow testicles from ram who was impotent and let his wife elope with ravana, who enjoyed his wife for 12 years.
Mustafa

Hyderabad, India

#63 Apr 16, 2013
Ganesh Ram wrote:
Can any Hindu tell us if any one of their gods or saints behaved like the prophet of Islam,whose deeds, all muslims must follow?
Mohammed attacked the Jewish tribe called Banu-L-Mustaliq because of their wealth. In a surprise raid, the Muslims drove them to the Sea. They slaughtered many members of the Banu-N-Mustaliq Tribe and looted away a booty of 2000 Camels, 5000 Sheep and 500 Women! 500 women were captured screaming and crying after they had watched their husbands and sons being slaughtered. The most beautiful captive was Juwayriyya, daughter of the chief of the Banu-L-Mustaliq. Mohammed snatched her to satisfy his own animal lust. The captured women were supposed to be returned by the Muslims upon payment of a ransom. But the night after the battle itself, Mohammed and his army raped each and every one of them. One of the men Abu Sa'id Khudri of Mohammed's army reported :
"We were lusting after women and chastity had become too hard for us, but we wanted to get the ransom money for our prisoners. So we wanted to use the "Azl" (Coitus Interruptus- where the man withdraws before ejaculating)...We asked the Prophet about it and he said: "You are not under any obligation to stop yourselves from doing it like that.." Later on the women and children were given for ransom to their envoys. They all went away to their country and not One wanted to stay although they had the choice.."
So the Great Prophet of Peace told his men it was perfectly FINE to rape women as long as you didn't ejaculate inside them (which made them pregnant). What supreme logic! Any human being with the slightest shred of morality has to be nauseated by this Man and the religion he preached. Mohammed, the supreme religious figurehead of Islam sanctions RAPE, pure and simple. Not only did the Muslims commit this horrifying crime, they decieved the Tribesmen into paying Ransom for their womenfolk, who only paid the money in a desperate attempt to save their women's honor. To call such a Prophet and his followers the epitome of Evil is probably an understatement.
And forbidden to you are wedded wives of other people except those who have fallen in your hands (as prisoners of war)...(Maududi, vol. 1, p. 319).(See also Suras 4:3 and 33:50)

In our view the man who rapes a woman, regardless of whether she is a virgin or not, if she is a free woman he must pay a "dowry" like that of her peers, and if she is a slave he must pay whatever has been detracted from her value. The punishment is to be carried out on the rapist and there is no punishment for the woman who has been raped, whatever the case.(Imam Maalik, Al-Muwatta', Volume 2, page 734)

this is islam's stand on having sex with slaves, muslims were never allowed to rape prisoners/slaves. instead they used to marry them if they liked them.

but this is not the case in hinduism,''A Brahmin male by virtue of his birth becomes the first husband of all women in the universe.''(Manu 3.14)

Atharva Veda 5.17.8]Even if ten former husbands--none a Brahman--had espoused a dame, And then a Brahman took her hand, he is her husband, only he...

this means any brahmin can enter any house and can have sex with any women he like but no one can object as he is the ''husband of all women in the world''

"O Indra, what do the cows make for you among the Kikatas. They neither yield milk for your offerings, nor do they warm the vessel of libation. Bring to us these cows, bring to us also the wealth of Pramagand (their King). O Brave one, grant us the possessions of the people of low status." [Rigveda 3:53:14

"Handless be these our enemies! We enervate their languid limbs. So let us part among ourselves, in hundreds, Indra! all their wealth." [Atharvaved 6:66:3

god, I really dont know who started this plundering religion, looks like it was especially made to loot people's wealth
Mustafa

Hyderabad, India

#64 Apr 16, 2013
Ganesh Ram wrote:
Can any Hindu tell us if any one of their gods or saints behaved like the prophet of Islam,whose deeds, all muslims must follow?
Mohammed attacked the Jewish tribe called Banu-L-Mustaliq because of their wealth. In a surprise raid, the Muslims drove them to the Sea. They slaughtered many members of the Banu-N-Mustaliq Tribe and looted away a booty of 2000 Camels, 5000 Sheep and 500 Women! 500 women were captured screaming and crying after they had watched their husbands and sons being slaughtered. The most beautiful captive was Juwayriyya, daughter of the chief of the Banu-L-Mustaliq. Mohammed snatched her to satisfy his own animal lust. The captured women were supposed to be returned by the Muslims upon payment of a ransom. But the night after the battle itself, Mohammed and his army raped each and every one of them. One of the men Abu Sa'id Khudri of Mohammed's army reported :
"We were lusting after women and chastity had become too hard for us, but we wanted to get the ransom money for our prisoners. So we wanted to use the "Azl" (Coitus Interruptus- where the man withdraws before ejaculating)...We asked the Prophet about it and he said: "You are not under any obligation to stop yourselves from doing it like that.." Later on the women and children were given for ransom to their envoys. They all went away to their country and not One wanted to stay although they had the choice.."
So the Great Prophet of Peace told his men it was perfectly FINE to rape women as long as you didn't ejaculate inside them (which made them pregnant). What supreme logic! Any human being with the slightest shred of morality has to be nauseated by this Man and the religion he preached. Mohammed, the supreme religious figurehead of Islam sanctions RAPE, pure and simple. Not only did the Muslims commit this horrifying crime, they decieved the Tribesmen into paying Ransom for their womenfolk, who only paid the money in a desperate attempt to save their women's honor. To call such a Prophet and his followers the epitome of Evil is probably an understatement.
In our view the man who rapes a woman, regardless of whether she is a virgin or not, if she is a free woman he must pay a "dowry" like that of her peers, and if she is a slave he must pay whatever has been detracted from her value. The punishment is to be carried out on the rapist and there is no punishment for the woman who has been raped, whatever the case.(Imam Maalik, Al-Muwatta', Volume 2, page 734)

And forbidden to you are wedded wives of other people except those who have fallen in your hands (as prisoners of war)...(Maududi, vol. 1, p. 319)

this is islam's stand, but what Hinduism teaches is very shameful.

Atharva Veda 5.17.8]Even if ten former husbands--none a Brahman--had espoused a dame, And then a Brahman took her hand, he is her husband, only he...

Manu 3.14 A Brahmin male by virtue of his birth becomes the first husband of all women in the universe.

now a brahmin can enter into any house and have sex with any women he wishes because he is the ''husband of all women''

the maximum punishment a man can get for raping women except for shudra is hitting on the wrist, lol a vaisya, khatriya can freely rape shudra women and they dont get any punishment.

"Handless be these our enemies! We enervate their languid limbs. So let us part among ourselves, in hundreds, Indra! all their wealth." [Atharvaved 6:66:3

"Slay everyone who pours no gift, who, hard to reach, delights thee not. Bestow on us what wealth he hath: this even the worshipper awaits." [Rigveda 1:176:4

"Handless be these our enemies! We enervate their languid limbs. So let us part among ourselves, in hundreds, Indra! all their wealth." [Atharvaved 6:66:3]”

this is what hinduism says, looks like this religion was started to loot people's wealth
Mustafa

Hyderabad, India

#65 Apr 16, 2013
power_puff_girl wrote:
while I have read "scientific verses" of Quran and seen that they are as flawed as every other religious texts,
I'm not really familiar with Vedas. I'm ready to accept that they may have some errors, as I'm an agnostic.
I would like to quote the hymns mentioned as erroneous by the first user.
"I, As the Sun goes round the heaven, have travelled round the Serpents' race"
----- this does not mention that Sun is moving around Earth. it says that sun revolves around the "HEAVEN". any science student knows that Sun is not stationary, that sun and other stars revolve around the center of milky way galaxy.
so, I don't see it as erroneous because heaven could mean anything and everything, we don't know what did the sages mean by heaven.
wat did you say ''it MAY have'' you are either pretending to be a agnostic or havent completely left hinduism.

Rig Veda 1.35.9 The golden-handed Savitar (sun), far-seeing, goes on his way between the earth and heaven...

Atharva Veda 6.8.3 As the sun day by day goes about this heaven and earth...

Tell me when this thread is updated: (Registration is not required)

Add to my Tracker Send me an email

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Islam Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Who Is Allah? (Aug '07) 13 min MUQ1 201,549
No Muslim can think of profaning holy Prophet (... (Jan '11) 31 min MUQ1 50,232
Islam Will Conquer Italy and the Entire West (Sep '10) 51 min Team America 365,835
i want to seee the holy spirit descend on all m... 2 hr Faith 12
Isis beheads Steven Sotloff. 2 hr Faith 5
Iraq Will Be BIG GRAVE Foe Jihadists 2 hr ISIS 6
Poll: 92% of Saudis Believe "ISIS Conforms to t... 3 hr Joe 39
•••
Enter and win $5000
•••

Islam People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

•••