Baha'i news: Three Baha'is, jailed fo...

Baha'i news: Three Baha'is, jailed for humanitarian work, begin...

There are 1 comment on the Worldwide Faith News story from Nov 18, 2010, titled Baha'i news: Three Baha'is, jailed for humanitarian work, begin.... In it, Worldwide Faith News reports that:

Baha'i news: Three Baha'is, jailed for humanitarian work, begin fourth year in detention From Baha'i World News Service - Subscribe Date Fri, 19 Nov 2010 01:07:19 +0200 Baha'i World News Service For more information, contact [email protected] Three Baha'is, jailed for humanitarian work, begin fourth year in detention NEW YORK, ...

Join the discussion below, or Read more at Worldwide Faith News.

Freedom of Conscience

Battle Creek, MI

#1 Dec 1, 2010
Here's the glaring irony: While appealing during the last four years to the international community for help with Iran, the US Baha'i assembly was busy seeking to destroy other Baha'i denominations in US courts.

It's an interesting ruling by the US 7th Circuit Court of Appeals that affects all of the nearly dozen Bahai denominations. Here are the highlights of it from my reading:

7th Cir: Public online 08-2306 case documents
Opinion in case# 08-2306 \

p 7: False finding of "fact" by Judge Austin in 1966

p 13: "...civil authorities may not make judgments about religious controversies when deciding church property disputes. Kedroff, 344 U.S. at 116.(The church-autonomy principle recognized in Watson “must now be said to have federal constitutional protection as a part of the free exercise of religion against state interference.”)."
"Building on Kedroff, the Supreme Court held in Presbyterian Church that “the First Amendment severely circumscribes the role that civil courts may play in resolving church property disputes.”

p 14-15: "Considered in light of these First Amendment limitations on the court’s authority, certain aspects of the 1966 injunction are troubling. The decree declares that “there is only one Baha’i Faith,” that Shoghi Effendi was its last Guardian and none has come since, and the National Spiritual Assembly was its representative and “highest authority” in the United States and was “entitled to exclusive use of the marks and symbols of the Faith,” including the exclusive use of the word “Bahá’í.” Declarations of this sort push the boundaries of the court’s authority under Kedroff and Presbyterian Church. In church property disputes (trademark suits obviously qualify), the First Amendment limits the sphere in which civil courts may operate. When a district judge takes sides in a religious schism, purports to decide matters of spiritual succession, and excludes dissenters from using the name, symbols, and marks of the faith (as distinct from the name and marks of a church), the First Amendment line appears to have been crossed."

p 17: "’It is a principle of general application in Anglo-American jurisprudence that one is not
bound by a judgment in personam in a litigation in which he is not designated as a party or to which he has not been made a party by service of process.’”"

p 20: The court expands on and concludes that the parties were simply not in privity with the 1966 flawed decision by Judge Austin.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Bahai Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
News Opinion: Iran should stand trial for persecutio... (Oct '14) Oct 13 Ivonka22 3
News Baha'i Student Expelled and Banned from Univers... Sep 29 Brexit 2
News Persecuted in Iran, Baha'is worse off in Iraq (Sep '14) Sep '14 Shaq 1
News Faith Forum: What religion does God follow? (Nov '12) Feb '14 Hilarious 47
News Supreme Court to hear new case on religion in p... (Nov '13) Nov '13 woodtick57 6
Baha'i Fallacies and Contradictions (May '08) Oct '13 RonPrice9 36
News Interfaith Initiative Centre County | A journey... (Aug '13) Aug '13 Kathwynn 1
More from around the web